Capacity for increasing soil organic carbon stocks in dryland agricultural systemsF. C. Hoyle A B C , M. D’Antuono A , T. Overheu A and D. V. Murphy B
A Department of Agriculture and Food Western Australia, Baron Hay Court, South Perth, WA 6151, Australia.
B Soil Biology and Molecular Ecology Group, School of Earth and Environment, Institute of Agriculture, University of Western Australia, 35 Stirling Highway, Crawley, WA 6009, Australia.
C Corresponding author. Email: firstname.lastname@example.org
Soil Research 51(8) 657-667 https://doi.org/10.1071/SR12373
Submitted: 21 December 2012 Accepted: 7 June 2013 Published: 20 December 2013
Assessment of the potential for soil carbon sequestration based on soil type, land use, and climate scenarios is crucial for determining which agricultural regions can be used to help mitigate increasing atmospheric CO2 concentrations. In semi-arid and Mediterranean-type environments, soil organic carbon (SOC) storage capacity is rarely achieved under dryland agricultural systems. We aimed to assess both actual (measured) and attainable (modelled) SOC stock values for the dryland agricultural production zone of Western Australia. We measured actual SOC storage (0–0.3 m) and known constraints to plant growth for a range of soils types (3–27% clay) and land uses (continuous cropping, mixed cropping, annual and perennial pastures) on the Albany sand plain in Western Australia (n = 261 sites), spanning a rainfall gradient of 421–747 mm. Average actual SOC stocks for land use–soil type combinations ranged from 33 to 128 t C/ha (0–0.3 m). Up to 89% of the variability in actual SOC stock was explained by soil depth, rainfall, land use, and soil type. The scenarios modelled with Roth-C predicted that attainable SOC values of 59–140 t C/ha (0–0.3 m) could be achieved within 100 years. This indicated an additional storage capacity of 5–45% (7–27 t C/ha) depending on the specific land use–soil type combination. However, actual SOC in the surface 0–0.1 m was 95 to >100% of modelled attainable SOC values, suggesting this soil depth was ‘saturated’. Our findings highlight that additional SOC storage capacity in this region is limited to the subsoil below 0.1 m. This has implications for management strategies to increase SOC sequestration in dryland agricultural systems, as current practices tend to concentrate organic matter near the soil surface.
Additional keywords: carbon farming, carbon modelling, carbon sequestration, climate variability, farming systems, Roth-C.
Sustainable management of soil, and in particular soil organic carbon (SOC), is widely regarded as beneficial to soil functions that support plant productivity (e.g. nutrient cycling) and has been associated with the continued viability of the agricultural sector (Hoyle et al. 2011). Sequestering carbon in agricultural soils is also seen as one way of decreasing atmospheric carbon dioxide (CO2) concentrations and mitigating climate change. Consequently, land managers, industry, and government are interested in identifying land uses that increase net plant/animal organic carbon inputs to the soil and then understanding how these changes will impact soil function (Cookson et al. 2005; Hoyle and Murphy 2006; Murphy et al. 2011) and carbon sequestration (Álvaro-Fuentes et al. 2012; Sauer et al. 2012). Although more than half of organic carbon inputs to soil return to the atmosphere as CO2 via microbial decomposition (Lynch 1983; Hoyle et al. 2008), a component of the remaining carbon is sequestered in more stable soil organo-mineral complexes (Baldock and Skjemstad 2000; Six et al. 2002). Thus, the potential for increased carbon storage could be achieved via greater inputs, and improved retention of plant/animal residues and associated organic carbon in the soil.
Fundamental studies of the potential for storage of SOC have identified key soil attributes and climate factors that determine the upper and lower thresholds for SOC (Ingram and Fernandes 2001). These include soil depth, texture (i.e. proportion of clay, silt, and sand), and degree of aggregation, which effectively determine the potential SOC storage of a soil if climate is not limiting inputs of organic matter from plant growth. For example, increasing clay content can increase the amount of SOC that is physically protected from microbial breakdown (Hoyle et al. 2011). Climate parameters (temperature and rainfall) affect SOC levels indirectly by affecting plant growth and net primary productivity (Grace et al. 2006), and directly by regulating the rate of microbial soil organic matter (SOM) decomposition (Hoyle et al. 2006), thus determining the attainable SOC storage capacity (Ingram and Fernandes 2001). With the exception of soil engineering (e.g. soil inversion, claying; Hall et al. 2010) there is little scope to significantly influence either the inherent physical or climatic influences on carbon storage in soils. The actual SOC storage capacity measures the current status of SOC values and is regulated by both historical climatic conditions and also agronomic, soil, and livestock management decisions made in situ (Ingram and Fernandes 2001). Agronomic choices such as crop or pasture selection, fertiliser application rates, net organic matter removal (e.g. burning), management of the soil (e.g. tillage practices), and removal of soil constraints to plant growth (e.g. liming to increase soil pH) alter plant biomass production, contributing to whether or not the actual SOC storage is as high as the attainable SOC capacity (Hoyle et al. 2011). Therefore, actual SOC stock values depend not only on soil type (the potential of the soil to protect SOM) but also on the land use and management (determining net primary productivity).
Semi-arid and arid soils constitute a third of the global land area and are widely used for agricultural production (Harrison and Pearce 2000). The Western Australian grain-growing region consists of 18 million ha of semi-arid land and is responsible for ~40% of Australia’s annual grain production (Australian Bureau of Agricultural and Resource Economics, www.abareconomics.com). The region is characterised by cool, wet winters and hot, dry summers. Only one crop (e.g. wheat, oats, lupin, canola) or annual pasture can be grown during the winter months (with no plant cover in summer), while growth of perennial pastures is possible over summer by utilising stored water and in response to infrequent summer rainfall. Studies often report that increasing the frequency and longevity of pasture phases will increase SOM (Dalal and Chan 2001). This increase occurs at a faster rate than changes in SOM resulting from the implementation of crop management practices such as zero tillage and stubble retention, which aim to increase the amount of crop residue returned to soil (Murphy et al. 2011). This increase does not seem specific to pasture type (Guo and Gifford 2002; Sanderman et al. 2010; Chan et al. 2011), although for permanent perennial pastures, those with spreading growth (e.g. kikuyu, Pennisetum clandestinum, as assessed in this study) can have higher SOC stocks than plants that clump (e.g. Rhodes grass, Chloris gayana), where bare soil remains between plants (Sanderman et al. 2013b). One option to increase actual SOC in this region may be to promote land-use systems which support greater net primary productivity and have potential to increase allocation of SOC to depth (e.g. perennial pasture systems; Jackson and Roy 1986; Nie et al. 2008). This concept was evaluated for the Albany Sand Plain in Western Australia, an area of 2250 km2 which typifies common land uses representative of semi-arid and Mediterranean-type agricultural production systems: cereal-dominated cropping (continuous cropping), mixed crop–pasture rotational systems (mixed cropping), and either permanent annual or perennial pastures for livestock grazing.
In the past, management changes have been a result of commodity prices, but future changes could potentially result from changes in annual rainfall patterns. The Albany Sand Plain catchment was also chosen because the distribution of each land use is likely to change as the climate continues to become drier (i.e. more crop and less pasture). From 1950 to 2003, the south-west of Australia is estimated to have experienced a 15% decrease in heavy winter rainfall (Nicholls 2010), which, combined with larger temperature anomalies (Nicholls 2003), has theoretical implications for net primary productivity and associated SOC sequestration. Mpelasoka et al. (2008) projected continued increases in soil-moisture drought frequency in the south-west of Western Australia. A continuing decline in rainfall pattern is likely to influence not only the suitability of the environment to particular land uses but also the attainable SOC targets associated with declining net primary productivity. Although the movement from pasture systems to continuous cropping could have a significant impact on carbon storage, the declining rainfall is likely to be a primary driver of changes in SOC and profit in the Albany Sand Plain catchment and other dryland farming areas.
In order to assess land-use and climate impacts on changes in SOC, the aims of this study were to (i) determine which climatic and soil physio-chemical variables helped explain actual SOC levels; (ii) quantify actual SOC storage under continuous cropping, mixed cropping, and both annual and perennial pasture based farming systems; and (iii) model attainable SOC levels for these soils to determine whether there is further capacity in these soils to sequester carbon under current land-use and future climate scenarios.
Materials and methods
The Albany Sand Plain, in the south-west of Western Australia (Fig. 1), comprises a level to very gently undulating landscape, internally drained to the east and dissected by the Kalgan River to the west. Deep sands, sandy duplex (i.e. texture-contrast) soils, and shallow sand overlying sodic clay (Tenosols, Podosols, Sodosols; Isbell 1996) dominate the region and typify common soil groups throughout the Western Australian agricultural region (Schoknecht 2002). Dominant land uses, defined by the previous 5–10-year paddock history, include continuous cropping (predominantly barley, canola, and lupin), mixed cropping in rotation with annual pasture, permanent annual pasture (with the livestock enterprise mainly sheep-based), and permanent perennial pasture. Closer to the coast, beef production dominates, with most producers using a perennial pasture base to feed livestock during summer and autumn. Annual pastures are grass-dominated swards comprising ryegrass (Lolium spp.), brome grass (Bromus spp.), and barley grass (Hordeum spp.), with either clover (Trifolium spp.) or serradella (Ornithopus spp.) as the legume component. Perennial kikuyu pastures have also been used to a limited extent for the past 35 years, typically as a mixed sward of kikuyu with either clover or serradella. Perennial pastures have longer survival, deeper rooting, and greater plant biomass during summer.
Site selection and soil sampling
Sampling sites were distributed over an area of 2250 km2, spanning a rainfall gradient ranging from 421 to 747 mm (Fig. 1). In total, 261 sites that were determined in the field to be either Tenosol (i.e. deep sand >0.9 m) or Sodosol (shallow duplex, depth to clay <0.4 m, sodic subsoil) were targeted under four primary land uses: (i) continuous cropping, (ii) mixed cropping, (iii) permanent annual pasture, or (iv) permanent perennial pasture systems (Table 1). After subsequent soil textural analysis in the laboratory, 19 sites were reclassified as loamy duplex and retained as a separate group (Table 1). Sampling was undertaken to provide a random representation of the management–soil type combination (n = 25) under investigation.
Soil collection occurred during the dry summer period (2010–11) while fallow and before a crop or annual pasture was established. As the soil was naturally field-dry (<2% gravimetric water content), soils could be stored without chilling (Gonzalez-Quiñones et al. 2011). Therefore, sampling at this time of the year avoided problems associated with (i) biological activity resulting in SOM decomposition, and (ii) plant roots passing through the sieve and confounding the analysis of soil carbon fractions.
Sites representing a specific soil type–land use combination were selected, and a grid 25 m by 25 m orientated north–south and east–west was laid out and subdivided into grid cells 5 m by 5 m (Sanderman et al. 2011). Soil was collected to a depth of 0.3 m in 0.1-m increments using a hand-held sand auger (0.05 m diameter) at 10 randomly selected grid nodes. The 30 samples per site (three depths, 10 profile locations) were kept separate for 5% of the sites (to enable an assessment of the within-site variance); at the remaining sites, the samples were composited by depth. A soil pit was dug at the south-west corner of the grid and described in detail, and soil was classified according to the Australian Soil Classification (Isbell 1996) and Western Australian Soil Group (WASG) (Schoknecht 2002); a marker was buried for future relocation.
For each separate soil sample, buried plant residue (BPR), root material, and gravel >2 mm retained on the sieve were collected and their percentages determined (data not presented). Total carbon was determined on oven-dried, finely ground soil (<2 mm) by total combustion using a Vario EL Elementar analyser (Elementar Analysensysteme, Hanau, Germany) and total SOC stock adjusted on a volumetric basis using bulk density (BD) and percentage gravel values for each 0.1-m soil increment. Soil BD (g/cm3) was determined for each of the three soil depths using a gamma-neutron density meter (Blake and Hartge 1986), which has been shown for Western Australian soils to result in the same SOC stock estimates as found with use of traditional BD ring or clod methods (Holmes et al. 2011).
Because the primary net productivity of a given site influences SOC, other soil properties known to constrain plant production for the region were also measured (Table 2). Electrical conductivity (EC, used to indicate dry land salinity) and soil pH were determined in 1 : 5 (v/v) soil : water CaCl2 extracts, respectively. Water repellence of soil was measured using the molarity of ethanol droplet test (MED; King 1981). Particle size analysis (sand, silt, clay percentage) was determined by sedimentation (McKenzie et al. 2002).
Soil organic carbon stock is a measure of the mass of carbon per area over a specified thickness of soil (Ellert et al. 2001), calculated as:
where SOCstock is the SOC stock (t/ha of carbon), d is the sampling thickness (cm), C% is the total SOC concentration (%), BDfe is the BD of the fine earth fraction (g/cm3), and CF is the soil coarse fraction so that (1 – CF) is the fine earth fraction (unitless). The SOC stock was calculated in two ways: (1) total stock over 0–0.3 m (SOCstock), and (2) total stock over a soil thickness equivalent to a soil mass of 0.4 t/m2 (SOCeq). The equivalent mass method provides the most accurate baseline possible for assessing differences in stocks between soil types of different BD (Gifford and Roderick 2003; Allen et al. 2010), but it was not significantly different from the SOCstock for this dataset. This paper reports actual SOC values as determined by SOCstock, as the 0–0.3 m volume relates directly to attainable SOC values derived from Roth-C modelling.
Linear mixed models using the restricted maximum likelihood (REML) procedure in Genstat for Windows (Edition 14, www.genstat.com) were fitted to evaluate the absolute and relative importance of depth, land use, ASC, and WASG on actual SOC stock values. REML allows for estimation of variance components and adjusted mean effects of the factors of interest and can handle unequal numbers of sites in the various strata in the study design. After preliminary analysis of the data the variation of residuals was not uniform. Hence, log10 transformations were used to stabilise the variance. The total (0–0.3 m) actual SOC stock variance was estimated across sites (composite samples) and within site (the 5% of sites where samples were not composited). REML was used to predict data group means, the standard error of the difference, and the least significant difference (l.s.d.) detectable P = 0.05.
After fitting the initial model and calculating diagnostics, REML models were fitted to the transformed (log10) actual SOC data for assessment of statistical significance using log-likelihood ratio tests. Group mean values and l.s.d.s were calculated (for the fixed effects in the model). We assumed that Rainfall, Land use, and Depth were fixed terms in the model; ASC and WASG were considered as random terms to compare the methods of classification as assessed by the change in deviance terms or changes in the REML log-likelihood as discussed in Payne et al. (2011).
The covariates (EC, pH, MED, sand percentage) taken at each depth were also examined once the base model of Rainfall, Land use, and best soil classification (WASG) was fitted. These were added as random effects in the model and tested in a similar way using changes in deviance with a chi-square test. The detailed Genstat code used is presented in Appendix 1.
Soil carbon modelling
The Roth-C model (version 26.3) operating in Excel© was used to model attainable SOC values in non-waterlogged soils as described by Jenkinson (1990). Roth-C has previously been validated for use in dryland agricultural systems by Janik et al. (2002) and, more recently, for use with perennial pastures (Sanderman et al. 2013a) in southern Australia. To initiate the model, SOC is partitioned into six pools (Janik et al. 2002): decomposable plant material (DPM), resistant plant material pool (RPM), fast and slow microbial biomass pools (BIOF and BIOS), humified organic matter (HUM), and inert carbon (IOM, which includes the char fraction). Reported allocations for SOC pool values within Roth-C for Australian soils (Janik et al. 2007) were used—1%, 20%, 2%, 0.2%, 60%, 17% for DPM, RPM, BIOF, BIOS, HUM, and IOM, respectively. Janik et al. (2002) report that errors in estimates of the IOM, HUM, and RPM pools contribute to uncertainty in the modelled total soil carbon, with the RPM pool demonstrating most sensitivity in model outputs.
Climate data (lat. –34.91, long. 117.99) used to initiate the Roth-C model for the Albany Sand Plain included long-term (1889–2005) average monthly rainfall (mm), open-pan evaporation (mm), and temperature (°C). Other site-dependent variables included plant residue inputs (net removal of dry matter (DM) from paddock via grazing; percentage of stubble retained), measured actual SOC stock (SOC, t C/ha), and clay content (%) (Table 2). We also ran model scenarios to determine likely changes in attainable SOC stocks over a 100-year period based on a projected 30% decline in rainfall (Crimp et al. 2008).
Representative land-use scenarios were constructed to initialise Roth-C to determine the attainable SOC storage. Permanent perennial pasture systems were modelled to determine the maximal attainable SOC storage value for each soil type assuming 12 months of DM production, no grazing, and the retention of all plant residues. A root to shoot ratio of 1 : 1 (determined from the average of seven perennial grass species grown over two seasons; Bolinder et al. 2002) was used with an above ground DM production of 16 kg/mm available water. In this example, available water was calculated as annual rainfall minus a nominal loss of 50 mm. Four further land-use scenarios were modelled to reflect attainable SOC values for each representative land-use category:
Perennial pasture—root to shoot ratio 1.1, 33.5% net removal of DM, 100% water-use efficiency (WUE), slope 16 kg DM/mm available water, 12 months DM production, 95% stubble retention; available water as above.
Annual pasture system—root to shoot ratio 1.1, 33.5% net removal of DM, 100% WUE, slope 20 kg DM/mm available water, 7 months DM production from May, 95% stubble retention. In this scenario, available water was calculated as growing season rainfall (GSRF, April–October) minus a 50-mm loss.
Continuous cropping—barley, root to shoot ratio 0.5, harvest index 0.4, 60% WUE, slope 17.5 grain and 30 kg DM/mm available water, 7 months DM production from May; available water calculated as GSRF – (0.33 × GSRF).
Mixed crop and livestock—barley (as above), canola, annual pasture (as above) rotation; canola as per barley but with a slope 10 kg grain and 20 kg DM/mm available water.
Actual SOC stock values
The main factors of Depth, Land use, and Rainfall were all significant (P < 0.001) in the determination of the log10 actual SOC stock values (Table 3). Depth × Land use and Depth × Rainfall interactions were also significant in the REML analysis. Using the log10 of actual SOC stock values (0–0.3 m) as the response variate, and with land-use scenarios and long-term average rainfall terms in the statistical model, the WASG classification (Schoknecht 2002) was found to better explain the variation of the actual SOC stock values than did ASC (deviance test: 14.01 on 6 d.f., P < 0.03; 0.00 on 6 d.f., P > 0.99, for WASG and ASC, respectively). Further examination of the log10 actual SOC stock values by fixed depth with the base model of WASG, land use, and rainfall terms showed a significant linear decrease in actual SOC with depth and interactions with land use and rainfall. The spatial distribution of sites showed a stronger relationship with average annual rainfall (calculated from 1975 to 2005) and land use (Fig. 1) than with WASG.
The other soil properties (sand content (%), EC, soil pH, and severity of non-wetting (MED)) were examined but did not improve the base model (data not presented).
Actual SOC stock was consistently highest in the perennial pasture systems across all soil types (Table 4). Annual pasture systems also had greater actual SOC stock values than either mixed cropping or continuous cropping systems (P < 0.001). The REML analysis of log10 actual SOC stock (0–0.3 m) for the base model (Table 4) showed that land use and soil classification (WASG) significantly (P < 0.001) influenced SOC stock, with depth and rainfall being the dominant drivers of changes in SOC stock. A significant (P < 0.001) interaction in actual SOC storage between land-use systems and soil depth was observed. Actual SOC values under perennial pasture (average rainfall 650 mm) were 60, 22, and 12 t C/ha for the 0–0.1, 0.1–0.2, and 0.2–0.3 m depths, respectively. The corresponding values under annual pasture (average rainfall 625 mm) were 52, 18, and 11 t C/ha; continuous cropping (average rainfall 500 mm) 26, 11, and 6 t C/ha; and mixed cropping systems (average rainfall 500 mm) 26, 10, and 6 t C/ha. The 0–0.1 m soil depth contains on average 63% (61–65%) of the actual SOC stock within the top 0.3 m of the soil. This concentration of SOC in the surface layer was consistent across all land uses and soil types. The 0.1–0.2 m depth contained on average 24% (21–27%) of the actual SOC and the 0.2–0.3 m depth 13% (11–15%).
Modelled attainable SOC values
Comparative differences in actual SOC stocks between land use and soil type were also reflected in long-term (100-year) attainable SOC model simulations (Table 4). For the majority of sites, actual SOC storage (0-0.3 m) was less than the attainable SOC values modeled of 59 t C/ha (deep sand, CC) to 140 t C/ha (loamy duplex, PP) within 100 years (Table 4, Figs 2–4). Modelling realistic management scenarios over 100 years suggested that, on average, the soils under historical cropping systems have greater capacity to store additional SOC (24 t C/ha); the equivalent of 35% of the attainable SOC stock value is still to be sequestered. Depending on the specific land use–soil type combination, the additional storage capacity ranged between 5 and 45% (7–27 t C/ha). Annual and perennial pasture systems had reached 83 and 88% of their attainable SOC stock, respectively (averaged across soil types), with a further 15–18 t C/ha still able to be sequestered. Across all land uses, modelling suggests that ~78% of the attainable SOC could be captured by the next generation of landholders (i.e. over 50 years). This means that at these sites, a theoretical increase in actual SOC stock values of 5–22 t C/ha is possible over 50 years if this carbon can be sequestered. This represents a small annual increase in soil carbon storage of 0.1–0.3 t C/ha.year over this period.
The additional SOC storage capacity (i.e. attainable SOC – actual SOC) over a 0.3 m soil profile was 54–56 t C/ha when assessed by WASG (Fig. 2) and 16–25 t C/ha when assessed by land use (data not shown). However, when each depth (0.1-m increment) was modelled independently using actual clay content and BD values, data suggest that the upper 0.1 m is largely saturated (Fig. 3a, b) in terms of its additional SOC storage capacity. In many cases, there is more carbon in this depth than can be theoretically maintained (i.e. >100%), with the additional capacity for SOC sequestration located in the 0.1–0.2 m layer (currently at 50% capacity) and the 0.2–0.3 m depth (currently at 29% capacity) for all land uses and soil types. The pasture systems appear closer to their theoretical carbon saturation than cropping systems (Fig. 3a, b).
Actual and attainable SOC stock values were plotted against the long-term average annual rainfall for individual sites (using SILO interpolation of latitude and longitude for climatic data, www.longpaddock.qld.gov.au/silo/) in the Albany Sand Plain region (Fig. 4). This comparison emphasises (i) the dominance of pasture systems in the high-rainfall area, some of which are nearing (or in some cases beyond) their theoretical storage capacity; and (ii) that the greatest gain in future SOC sequestration is in soils currently under continuous and mixed cropping, even though these sites are located towards the lower end of the rainfall gradient.
Decreasing annual rainfall by 30% to reflect predicted future climate change brings a moderate decline in attainable SOC stock values (Fig. 5a, b) associated with decreasing net primary productivity. This decline in attainable SOC was double in the higher input pasture system (~20 t C/ha) compared with the cropping systems (~10 t C/ha).
Our findings highlight the need for new management practices or land-use options that enable SOC to be stored deeper in the soil profile. Annual legume-based pasture in rotation with cereal production that includes widespread adoption of minimal soil disturbance (reduced/zero tillage cultivation; Cookson et al. 2008) and retention of stubble (instead of burning; Hoyle et al. 2006) is currently considered the most practical management approach to mitigate SOC decline (Grace et al. 1998) in the south-west of Western Australia, but it targets inputs to the soil surface. This is reflected in SOC stocks measured to depth, where 85% of SOC in the upper 1.0 m of soil was in the top 0.3 m (data not presented). Within this uppermost layer (0–0.3 m profile), we found that about two-thirds of actual SOC is within the top 0.1 m in these agricultural systems, as this is where plant residue returns are concentrated. By modelling the attainable SOC stock value for each depth of soil separately (in 0.1-m increments), it was determined that for the majority of sites there is only limited capacity in the soil 0–0.1 m layer to sequester further carbon, whereas further storage capacity was possible in the subsoil (Fig. 3a, b), especially of gradational/duplex soils where clay content increases with depth. Increased clay content at depth supports a higher potential SOC capacity, while rates of SOM decomposition decline exponentially with soil depth (Murphy et al. 1998; Kemmitt et al. 2008). However, there are limitations to delivering organic matter to the subsoil cost-effectively (Kragt et al. 2012).
Approaches currently being investigated by the agricultural sector include: (i) the adoption of high root biomass crop and pasture species; (ii) inversion of soil to bury the original carbon-saturated surface soil layer, providing a new surface of soil from depth with additional carbon-sequestration capacity; and (iii) injection of organic materials including compost and biochar to depth. Many of these approaches are based on increasing the proportional allocation of organic matter below ground, where it is more likely to remain protected. In exploring these solutions, care must be taken to define any potential negative outcomes (e.g. yield decline, cost of technology adoption).
Improving the capacity of plants to increase their below-ground biomass allocations while maintaining harvest index (i.e. grain yields) provides a viable approach to carbon storage in soils without negatively affecting the profitability of the farming system. An alternative approach may be achieved via genetic solutions to environmental constraints that result in an increase in net primary productivity. Engineered soils, and in particular soil inversion, offer landholders an effective method for the management of weed seed-banks and surface non-wetting. As a result, changes in both the distribution and amount of organic carbon in soils can be observed. This study suggests that the surface layer of soils is largely saturated and it has limited potential to sequester further organic carbon stores. Therefore, it is conceivable that creating a ‘new’ soil layer lower in SOC might increase the potential for building SOC stocks. Risks associated with this type of approach include increased erosion on exposed soils with little or no cover, the possibility of bringing up ‘sour’ soils (e.g. subsoil acidity), or effectively repositioning the barrier to production at depth. Amendment of soils with organic materials including, but not limited to, compost and biochar requires consideration of product composition, rate of application, and resulting changes in soil function. In many instances, the rate of application is insignificant against background SOC stocks and while some amendments may provide a nominal change in measurable organic carbon, the cost of application is such that additional benefits are also required to underpin a profitable production system. To date the agronomic benefits of many of these amendments is highly variable and relatively small compared with the cost of application.
Modelled attainable SOC values were not constrained by practical limitations to plant growth (i.e. subsoil constraints such as soil acidity, toxicities, compaction, nutrient deficiency), which can restrict the ability of a plant root to access soil resources and thus constrain biomass production. Within the agricultural zone of the south-west of Western Australia, 32% of the total land area is classed as having multiple constraints including low soil pH, poor soil water storage, subsurface compaction, erosion, and, in the higher rainfall zones, waterlogging (van Gool 2011). Therefore, to increase carbon storage in soil it is important that management practices remove these constraints to plant growth, where it is cost-effective to do so. For example, on transitional soils in the high-rainfall environment, transient waterlogging can influence grain yields by 20–50% (McFarlane and Cox 1992; Zhang et al. 2004). Our modelling (data not shown) suggests that removal of waterlogging could increase the long-term (100-year) carbon sequestration potential by 27%. In addition, the low soil pH measured on many of the soil profiles reported in this study suggest a subsoil constraint on net primary productivity associated with acid soils (and possibly aluminium toxicity). Management of these constraints would assist with ‘closing the gap’ between actual and potential SOC stock values under cropping based systems, which are further from their attainable SOC target than the pasture systems (Fig. 4).
We predicted a theoretical attainable SOC increase of 0.07–0.27 t C/ha.year (over 100 years) in these soils if additional organic matter was sequestered. Extrapolating this rate across the 18 Mha of semi-arid land within the grain-growing region of Western Australia, a potential storage of ~1.3–4.9 Mt organic carbon/year is indicated. This rate of potential for accumulation of SOC through land-management practices that maximise conversion of rainfall to net primary production (i.e. 100% WUE) and preserve existing SOM is similar to that estimated for Australia (0.35 t C/ha.year; Luo et al. 2010).
An average wheat yield in Western Australian of 2 t/ha and harvest index of ~40% produces 5 t/ha of total above-ground plant biomass. Assuming a root/shoot ratio for grain crops of 0.5 and a plant carbon content of 45%, this means that a wheat plant in this environment currently grows 3.4 t C/ha.year. Improving WUE for wheat in this environment (currently 40–60%) through a combination of agronomic management and genetic improvement to capture and utilise water more effectively (i.e. improved water infiltration and storage, removed soil constraints to plant growth, plant breeding to improve root architecture for water and nutrient capture) would result in greater net primary productivity. Grace et al. (2006) defined the extent of organic carbon that is retained in soil as a function of cation exchange capacity (CEC, used as an analogue to clay). For low CEC soils (<25 mmol/kg), which are typical for the Western Australian agricultural region (see fig. 4 in Gonzalez-Quiñones et al. 2011), this function would indicate that, at most, 20–25% of applied organic carbon could be retained in the soil. Using these estimates, sufficient additional plant inputs to meet the modelled theoretical attainable increase of 0.1–0.3 t C/ha.year could be achieved where subsoil constraints are managed.
Based on forecast climate variability (Crimp et al. 2008), modelled declines in attainable SOC for this region could be in the order of 5–10 t C/ha over the next 100 years (average 0.075 t C/ha decline per year; Fig. 5). Assuming that WUE can be increased (as discussed above), the loss of SOC from declining rainfall can be offset through an increase net primary productivity. However, while Western Australia has experienced a decline in winter rainfall (Allan and Haylock 1993), trend analysis suggests that summer rainfall events that occur outside of the period of crop and annual pasture growth are increasing (Alexander et al. 2007). Higher and more frequent summer rainfall is likely to increase SOM mineralisation rates and associated CO2 emissions (Hoyle et al. 2006), as surface soil temperatures are high (30–40°C). A shift from winter to more summer rainfall was not included in current carbon modelling scenarios but warrants further consideration; especially given that these summer rainfall events cause approximately half of the nitrous oxide (N2O) emissions from this region (Barton et al. 2008).
By gaining a quantitative understanding of the actual (measured) and attainable (modelled upper limits) SOC stock values for these typical agricultural systems, we can provide a moderate level of confidence for future soil carbon scenarios and manage landholder and industry expectations appropriately. Comparison of actual v. attainable SOC stock values highlight that: (i) the additional carbon sequestration capacity in these soils is below the surface 0.1 m depth, and (ii) the gap between actual and attainable SOC stock values decreases as rainfall increases. This has major implications for future management of carbon inputs to these agricultural systems, which currently concentrate plant residue returns at or close to the soil surface.
Data collection was funded from the Australian Government Department of Agriculture, Fisheries and Forestry under its Climate Change Research Program in association with the Grains Research and Development Corporation, the Department of Agriculture and Food Western Australia and the University of Western Australia. Professor D.V. Murphy contributed to data analysis and manuscript writing while the recipient of an Australian Research Council Future Fellowship (project number FT110100246). Support of staff time from the University of Western Australia and the Department of Agriculture and Food Western Australia is also acknowledged. We thank Andrew Wherrett, Richard Bowles, and Xiaodi Li for their field and laboratory assistance, Karen Holmes for statistical support, Jeff Baldock who provided useful training and discussions on carbon modelling, and Louise Barton who provided valuable suggestions.
ReferencesAlexander LV, Hope P, Collins D, Trewin B, Lynch A, Nicholls N (2007) Trends in Australia’s climate means and extremes: A global context. Australian Meteorological Magazine 56, 1–18.
Allan RJ, Haylock MR (1993) Circulation features associated with the winter rainfall decrease in southwestern Australia. Journal of Climate 6, 1356–1367.
| Circulation features associated with the winter rainfall decrease in southwestern Australia.CrossRef |
Allen DE, Pringle MJ, Page KL, Dalal RC (2010) A review of sampling designs for the measurement of soil organic carbon in Australian grazing lands. The Rangeland Journal 32, 227–246.
| A review of sampling designs for the measurement of soil organic carbon in Australian grazing lands.CrossRef |
Álvaro-Fuentes J, Easter M, Paustian K (2012) Climate change effects on organic carbon storage in agricultural soils of northeastern Spain. Agriculture, Ecosystems & Environment 155, 87–94.
| Climate change effects on organic carbon storage in agricultural soils of northeastern Spain.CrossRef |
Baldock JA, Skjemstad JO (2000) Role of the soil matrix and minerals in protecting natural organic materials against biological attack. Organic Geochemistry 31, 697–710.
| Role of the soil matrix and minerals in protecting natural organic materials against biological attack.CrossRef | 1:CAS:528:DC%2BD3cXmsFSqu70%3D&md5=7807fbdd530ca37c288cd9c5d4f62eb2CAS |
Barton L, Kiese R, Gatter D, Butterbach-Bahl K, Buck R, Hinz C, Murphy DV (2008) Nitrous oxide emissions from a cropped soil in a semi-arid climate. Global Change Biology 14, 177–192.
Blake GR, Hartge KH (1986) Bulk density. In ‘Methods of soil analysis. Part I: Physical and mineralogical methods’. Vol. 9. 2nd edn (Ed. A Klute) pp. 363–375. (American Society of Agronomy: Madison, WI)
Bolinder MA, Angers DA, Bélanger G, Michaud R, Laverdière MR (2002) Root biomass and shoot to root ratios of perennial forage crops in eastern Canada. Canadian Journal of Plant Science 82, 731–737.
| Root biomass and shoot to root ratios of perennial forage crops in eastern Canada.CrossRef |
Chan KY, Conyers MK, Li GD, Helyar KR, Poile G, Oates A, Barchia IM (2011) Soil carbon dynamics under different cropping and pasture management in temperate Australia: Results of three long-term experiments. Soil Research 49, 320–328.
| Soil carbon dynamics under different cropping and pasture management in temperate Australia: Results of three long-term experiments.CrossRef |
Cookson WR, Abaye DA, Marschner P, Murphy DV, Stockdale EA, Goulding KWT (2005) The contribution of soil organic matter fractions to carbon and nitrogen mineralization and microbial community size and structure. Soil Biology & Biochemistry 37, 1726–1737.
| The contribution of soil organic matter fractions to carbon and nitrogen mineralization and microbial community size and structure.CrossRef | 1:CAS:528:DC%2BD2MXlsFGjs70%3D&md5=eec3f2c64d37971da3fc0330924cd9b2CAS |
Cookson WR, Murphy DV, Roper MM (2008) Characterising the relationships between soil organic matter components and microbial function and composition along a tillage disturbance gradient. Soil Biology & Biochemistry 40, 763–777.
| Characterising the relationships between soil organic matter components and microbial function and composition along a tillage disturbance gradient.CrossRef | 1:CAS:528:DC%2BD1cXisFKrsw%3D%3D&md5=a58256dd6f0a992ca8bccdcad68775b2CAS |
Crimp S, Howden M, Power B, Wang E, De Voil P (2008) Global climate change impacts on Australia’s wheat crops. Report prepared for The Garnaut climate change review. CSIRO Canberra. Available at: www.garnautreview.org.au/CA25734E0016A131/WebObj/01-BWheat/$File/01-B%20Wheat.pdf
Dalal RC, Chan KY (2001) Soil organic matter in rainfed cropping systems of the Australian cereal belt. Australian Journal of Soil Research 39, 435–464.
| Soil organic matter in rainfed cropping systems of the Australian cereal belt.CrossRef | 1:CAS:528:DC%2BD3MXks1Kqt7c%3D&md5=a0808765b25458ef717e39818258119cCAS |
Ellert BH, Janzen HH, McConkey BG (2001) Measuring and comparing soil carbon storage. In ‘Assessment methods for soil carbon’. (Eds R Lal, JM Kimble, RF Follett, BA Stewart) pp. 131–145. (Lewis Publishers: New York)
Gifford RM, Roderick ML (2003) Soil carbon stocks and bulk density: spatial or cumulative mass coordinates as a basis of expression? Global Change Biology 9, 1507–1514.
| Soil carbon stocks and bulk density: spatial or cumulative mass coordinates as a basis of expression?CrossRef |
Gonzalez-Quiñones V, Stockdale EA, Banning NC, Hoyle FC, Sawada Y, Wherrett AD, Jones DL, Murphy DV (2011) Soil microbial biomass-Interpretation and consideration for soil monitoring. Soil Research 49, 287–304.
| Soil microbial biomass-Interpretation and consideration for soil monitoring.CrossRef |
Grace PR, Post WM, Godwin DC, Bryceson KP, Truscott MA, Hennessy KJ (1998) Soil carbon dynamics in relation to soil surface management and cropping systems in Australian agroecosystems. In ‘Management of carbon sequestration in soil’. (Eds R Lal, JM Kimball, RF Follett, BA Stewart) pp. 173–193. (CRC Press: Boca Raton, FL)
Grace PR, Ladd JN, Phillip Robertson G, Gage SH (2006) SOCRATES–A simple model for predicting long-term changes in soil organic carbon in terrestrial ecosystems. Soil Biology & Biochemistry 38, 1172–1176.
| SOCRATES–A simple model for predicting long-term changes in soil organic carbon in terrestrial ecosystems.CrossRef | 1:CAS:528:DC%2BD28XjvFSisLo%3D&md5=b34d2eb2465cbe22156a1e3a06ad19f7CAS |
Guo LB, Gifford RM (2002) Soil carbon stocks and land use change: a meta analysis. Global Change Biology 8, 345–360.
| Soil carbon stocks and land use change: a meta analysis.CrossRef |
Hall DJM, Jones HR, Crabtree WL, Daniels TL (2010) Claying and deep ripping can increase crop yields and profits on water repellent sands with marginal fertility in southern Western Australia. Australian Journal of Soil Research 48, 178–187.
| Claying and deep ripping can increase crop yields and profits on water repellent sands with marginal fertility in southern Western Australia.CrossRef |
Harrison P, Pearce F (2000) ‘AAAS Atlas of population and environment.’ (University of California Press: Berkeley, CA)
Holmes KW, Wherrett A, Keating A, Murphy DV (2011) Meeting bulk density sampling requirements efficiently to estimate soil carbon stocks. Soil Research 49, 680–695.
| Meeting bulk density sampling requirements efficiently to estimate soil carbon stocks.CrossRef |
Hoyle FC, Murphy DV (2006) Seasonal changes in microbial function and diversity associated with stubble retention versus burning. Australian Journal of Soil Research 44, 407–423.
| Seasonal changes in microbial function and diversity associated with stubble retention versus burning.CrossRef |
Hoyle FC, Murphy DV, Fillery IRP (2006) Temperature and stubble management influence microbial CO2-C evolution and gross N transformation rates. Soil Biology & Biochemistry 38, 71–80.
| Temperature and stubble management influence microbial CO2-C evolution and gross N transformation rates.CrossRef | 1:CAS:528:DC%2BD2MXhtlagsLbF&md5=491c208ce9c702b8ddc7903e39168748CAS |
Hoyle FC, Murphy DV, Brookes PC (2008) Microbial response to the addition of glucose in low-fertility soils. Biology and Fertility of Soils 44, 571–579.
| Microbial response to the addition of glucose in low-fertility soils.CrossRef | 1:CAS:528:DC%2BD1cXitFKns7Y%3D&md5=7685173b0a56554b1a54a0382ff1dd9bCAS |
Hoyle FC, Baldock JA, Murphy DV (2011) Soil organic carbon—Role in rainfed farming systems: with particular reference to Australian conditions. In ‘Rainfed farming systems’. (Eds P Tow, I Cooper, I Partridge, C Birch) pp. 339–361. (Springer Science International)
Ingram JSI, Fernandes ECM (2001) Managing carbon sequestration in soils: concepts and terminology. Agriculture, Ecosystems & Environment 87, 111–117.
| Managing carbon sequestration in soils: concepts and terminology.CrossRef |
Isbell RF (1996) ‘The Australian Soil Classification. Australian Soil and Land Survey Handbook. Vol. 4.’ (CSIRO Publishing: Melbourne)
Jackson LE, Roy J (1986) Growth-patterns of Mediterranean annual and perennial grasses under simulated rainfall regimes of southern France and California. Acta Oecologica-Oecologia Plantarum 7, 191–212.
Janik L, Spouncer L, Correll R, Skjemstad J (2002) Sensitivity analysis of the Roth-C soil carbon model (ver. 26.3 Excel). National Carbon Accounting System Technical Report No. 30, Australian Greenhouse Office, Canberra, ACT.
Janik LJ, Skjemstad JO, Shepherd KD, Spouncer LR (2007) The prediction of soil carbon fractions using mid-infrared-partial least square analysis. Australian Journal of Soil Research 45, 73–81.
| The prediction of soil carbon fractions using mid-infrared-partial least square analysis.CrossRef | 1:CAS:528:DC%2BD2sXjsFygurk%3D&md5=46cbb15b7ca591ae54ccfe50e4b25d57CAS |
Jenkinson DS (1990) The turnover of organic-carbon and nitrogen in soil. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London. Series B, Biological Sciences 329, 361–368.
| The turnover of organic-carbon and nitrogen in soil.CrossRef | 1:CAS:528:DyaK3MXkslSgtb0%3D&md5=2803bd174c62cf09e8eb9340677378f4CAS |
Kemmitt SJ, Wright D, Murphy DV, Jones DL (2008) Regulation of amino acid biodegradation in soil as affected by depth. Biology and Fertility of Soils 44, 933–941.
| Regulation of amino acid biodegradation in soil as affected by depth.CrossRef | 1:CAS:528:DC%2BD1cXos1WltLs%3D&md5=6e62e60e7fd013b08eadcba8610b353eCAS |
King PM (1981) Comparison of methods for measuring severity of water repellence of sandy soils and assessment of some factors that affect its measurement. Australian Journal of Soil Research 19, 275–285.
| Comparison of methods for measuring severity of water repellence of sandy soils and assessment of some factors that affect its measurement.CrossRef |
Kragt ME, Pannell DJ, Robertson MJ, Thamo T (2012) Assessing costs of soil carbon sequestration by crop-livestock farmers in Western Australia. Agricultural Systems 112, 27–37.
| Assessing costs of soil carbon sequestration by crop-livestock farmers in Western Australia.CrossRef |
Luo ZK, Wang EL, Sun OJ (2010) Soil carbon change and its responses to agricultural practices in Australian agro-ecosystems: A review and synthesis. Geoderma 155, 211–223.
| Soil carbon change and its responses to agricultural practices in Australian agro-ecosystems: A review and synthesis.CrossRef | 1:CAS:528:DC%2BC3cXitlWgtb0%3D&md5=d5dd038210f1cd57e58d00e7c583a487CAS |
Lynch JM (1983) Microbiological factors in crop productivity. In ‘Soil biotechnology’. (Blackwell Scientific: Oxford, UK)
McFarlane DJ, Cox JW (1992) Management of excess water in duplex soils. Australian Journal of Experimental Agriculture 32, 857–864.
| Management of excess water in duplex soils.CrossRef |
McKenzie N, Coughlan K, Cresswell H (2002) Particle size analysis. In ‘Soil physical measurement and interpretation for land evaluation’. pp. 224–239. (CSIRO Publishing: Melbourne)
Mpelasoka F, Hennessy K, Jones R, Bates B (2008) Comparison of suitable drought indices for climate change impacts assessment over Australia towards resource management. International Journal of Climatology 28, 1283–1292.
| Comparison of suitable drought indices for climate change impacts assessment over Australia towards resource management.CrossRef |
Murphy DV, Sparling GP, Fillery IRP (1998) Stratification of microbial biomass C and N and gross N mineralisation with soil depth in two contrasting Western Australian agricultural soils. Australian Journal of Soil Research 36, 45–55.
| Stratification of microbial biomass C and N and gross N mineralisation with soil depth in two contrasting Western Australian agricultural soils.CrossRef |
Murphy DV, Cookson WR, Braimbridge M, Marschner P, Jones DL, Stockdale EA, Abbott LK (2011) Relationships between soil organic matter and the soil microbial biomass (size, functional diversity, and community structure) in crop and pasture systems in a semi-arid environment. Soil Research 49, 582–594.
| Relationships between soil organic matter and the soil microbial biomass (size, functional diversity, and community structure) in crop and pasture systems in a semi-arid environment.CrossRef | 1:CAS:528:DC%2BC3MXhsV2kur3J&md5=57e03bd676ebfa24361cb80939f9e06cCAS |
Nicholls N (2003) Continued anomalous warming in Australia. Geophysical Research Letters 30, 1370
| Continued anomalous warming in Australia.CrossRef |
Nicholls N (2010) Local and remote causes of southern Australian autumn-winter rainfall decline, 1958–2007. Climate Dynamics 34, 835–845.
| Local and remote causes of southern Australian autumn-winter rainfall decline, 1958–2007.CrossRef |
Nie ZN, Miller S, Moore GA, Hackney BF, Boschma SP, Reed KFM, Mitchell M, Albertsen TO, Clark S, Craig AD, Kearney G, Li GD, Dear BS (2008) Field evaluation of perennial grasses and herbs in southern Australia. 2. Persistence, root characteristics and summer activity. Australian Journal of Experimental Agriculture 48, 424–435.
| Field evaluation of perennial grasses and herbs in southern Australia. 2. Persistence, root characteristics and summer activity.CrossRef |
Payne R, Welham S, Harding S (2011) ‘A guide to REML in Genstat.’ (VSN International: Hemel Hempstead, UK) Available at: www.vsni.co.uk/software/genstat?ref=genstat.com
Sanderman J, Farquharson R, Baldock JA (2010) Soil carbon sequestration potential: A review for Australian agriculture. A report to the Australian Department of Climate Change. pp. 1–82. Available at: www.csiro.au/resources/Soil-Carbon-Sequestration-Potential-Report.html
Sanderman J, Baldock J, Hawke B, Macdonald L, Massis-Puccini A, Szarvas S (2011) National Soil Carbon Research Programme: Field and laboratory methodologies. A report to the Australian Department of Agriculture, Fisheries and Forestry. Available at: www.clw.csiro.au/publications/science/2011/SAF-SCaRP-methods.pdf
Sanderman J, Fillery IRP, Jongepier R, Massalsky A, Roper MM, Macdonald LM, Maddern T, Murphy DV, Baldock JA (2013a) Carbon sequestration under subtropical perennial pastures II: Carbon dynamics. Soil Research 51, 771–780.
Sanderman J, Fillery IRP, Jongepier R, Massalsky A, Roper MM, Macdonald LM, Maddern T, Murphy DV, Wilson BR, Baldock JA (2013b) Carbon sequestration under subtropical perennial pastures I: Overall trends. Soil Research 51, 760–770.
Sauer TJ, James DE, Cambardella CA, Hernandez-Ramirez G (2012) Soil properties following reforestation or afforestation of marginal cropland. Plant and Soil 360, 375–390.
| Soil properties following reforestation or afforestation of marginal cropland.CrossRef | 1:CAS:528:DC%2BC38XhsFWisbzM&md5=aa7bfb8f70651ef6123234465dbfbb62CAS |
Schoknecht N (2002) ‘Soil groups of Western Australia—A guide to the main soils of Western Australia.’ 3rd edn. Resource Management Technical Report 246. (Agriculture Western Australia: South Perth, W. Aust.)
Six J, Conant RT, Paul EA, Paustian K (2002) Stabilisation mechanisms of soil organic matter: Implications for C saturation of soils. Plant and Soil 241, 155–176.
| Stabilisation mechanisms of soil organic matter: Implications for C saturation of soils.CrossRef | 1:CAS:528:DC%2BD38XltV2jsbo%3D&md5=3f33136cdd70b1fe36e6a0aec34d506eCAS |
van Gool D (2011) Wheat yield potential and land management constraints in the south west of Western Australia. Resource Management Technical Report 376. pp. 1–71. Department of Agriculture and Food, South Perth, W. Aust.
Zhang H, Turner NC, Poole ML (2004) Yield of wheat and canola in the high rainfall zone of south-western Australia in years with and without a perched transient water table. Australian Journal of Agricultural Research 55, 461–470.
| Yield of wheat and canola in the high rainfall zone of south-western Australia in years with and without a perched transient water table.CrossRef |