Community safety during the 2009 Australian ‘Black Saturday’ bushfires: an analysis of household preparedness and responseJoshua Whittaker A D , Katharine Haynes B , John Handmer A and Jim McLennan C
A Centre for Risk and Community Safety, School of Mathematical and Geospatial Sciences, RMIT University, GPO Box 2476, Melbourne, Vic, 3001, Australia.
B Risk Frontiers, Macquarie University, North Ryde, NSW, 2109, Australia.
C School of Psychological Science, La Trobe University, Melbourne, Vic. 3086, Australia.
D Corresponding author. Email: firstname.lastname@example.org
International Journal of Wildland Fire 22(6) 841-849 https://doi.org/10.1071/WF12010
Submitted: 13 January 2012 Accepted: 11 February 2013 Published: 31 May 2013
On Saturday 7 February 2009, 173 people lost their lives and more than 2000 houses were destroyed in bushfires (wildfires) in the Australian State of Victoria. The scale of life and property loss raised fundamental questions about community bushfire safety in Australia, in particular the appropriateness of the ‘Prepare, stay and defend or leave early’ policy. This paper presents findings from research undertaken as part of the Australian Bushfire Cooperative Research Centre’s (CRC) ‘2009 Victorian Bushfires Research Taskforce’. The research examined factors influencing patterns of life and property loss and survival across the fires through mail surveys (n = 1314) of fire affected households. Just over half of the respondents (53%) stayed to defend their homes and properties, whereas the remainder left before or when the fires arrived (43%) or sheltered in a house, structure, vehicle, or outside (4%). Results reveal a survival rate of 77% for houses that were defended by one or more household members, compared to 44% for unattended houses. The paper identifies inadequate planning and preparedness and the tendency for people to wait until they are directly threatened before taking action as major factors leading to late evacuation, failed defence and passive shelter.
Additional keywords: community safety, emergency response, evacuation, wildfire.
ReferencesAustralasian Fire Authorities Council (2005) Position paper on bushfires and community safety. (AFAC Limited: East Melbourne)
Australasian Fire Authorities Council (2009) Prepare. Act. Survive. Available at http://knowledgeweb.afac.com.au/research/community/documents/prepareactsurvive.pdf [Verified 24 January 2013]
Australian Associated Press (2009a) Black Saturday data reveals where victims died. The Age, 28 May 2009. Available at http://www.theage.com.au/national/black-saturday-data-reveals-where-victims-died-20090528-borp.html [Verified 11 January 2012]
Australian Associated Press (2009b) ‘Stay or go’ policy to be reviewed: Brumby. The Age, 9 February 2009. Available at http://www.theage.com.au/national/stay-or-go-policy-to-be-reviewed-brumby-20090209-81ek.html [Verified 11 January 2012]
Beringer J (2000) Community fire safety at the urban/rural interface: the bushfire risk. Fire Safety Journal 35, 1–23.
| Community fire safety at the urban/rural interface: the bushfire risk.CrossRef |
Blanchi R, Leonard J (2008) Property safety: judging structural safety. In ‘Community Bushfire Safety’. (Eds J Handmer, K Haynes) pp. 77–85. (CSIRO Publishing: Melbourne)
Blanchi R, Lucas C, Leonard J, Finkele K (2010) Meteorological conditions and wildfire-related house loss in Australia. International Journal of Wildland Fire 19, 914–926.
Bradfield A, Wells GL (2005) Not the same old hindsight bias: outcome information distorts a broad range of retrospective judgements. Memory & Cognition 33, 120–130.
| Not the same old hindsight bias: outcome information distorts a broad range of retrospective judgements.CrossRef |
Bradstock RA, Gill AM (2001) Living with fire and biodiversity at the urban edge: in search of a sustainable solution to the human protection problem in southern Australia. Journal of Mediterranean Ecology 2, 179–195.
Bushnell S, Balcombe L, Cottrell A (2007) Community and fire service perceptions of bushfire issues in Tamborine Mountain: what’s the difference. The Australian Journal of Emergency Management 22, 3–9.
Cohen J (2000) Preventing disaster: home ignitability in the wildland-urban interface. Journal of Forestry 98, 15–21.
Country Fire Authority (2012) About Fire Danger Ratings. (Country Fire Authority: Melbourne) Available at http://www.cfa.vic.gov.au/warnings-restrictions/about-fire-danger-ratings [Verified 24 January 2013]
Cova TJ, Drews FA, Siebeneck LK, Musters A (2009) Protective actions in wildfires: evacuation or shelter-in-place. Natural Hazards Review 10, 151–162.
| Protective actions in wildfires: evacuation or shelter-in-place.CrossRef |
Crompton RP, McAneney KJ, Chen K (2010) Influence of location, population, and climate on building damage and fatalities due to Australian bushfire: 1925–2009. Weather, Climate and Society 2, 300–310.
Decker D (1995) Last-minute evacuations save lives. Wildfire 4, 31
Eriksen C, Gill N (2010) Bushfire and everyday life: exploring the awareness-action ‘gap’ in changing rural landscapes. Geoforum 41, 814–825.
| Bushfire and everyday life: exploring the awareness-action ‘gap’ in changing rural landscapes.CrossRef |
Eriksen C, Gill N, Head L (2010) The gendered dimensions of bushfire in changing rural landscapes in Australia. Journal of Rural Studies 26, 332–342.
| The gendered dimensions of bushfire in changing rural landscapes in Australia.CrossRef |
Handmer J, Tibbits A (2005) Is staying at home the safest option during bushfires? Historical evidence for the Australian approach. Environmental Hazards 6, 81–91.
Handmer J, O’Neill S, Killalea D (2010) Review of fatalities in the 7 February 2009 bushfires. Available at http://www.bushfirecrc.com/managed/resource/review-fatalities-february-7.pdf [Verified 17 April 2013]
Haynes K, Handmer J, McAneney J, Tibbits A, Coates L (2010) Australian bushfire fatalities 1900–2008: exploring trends in relation to the ‘Prepare, stay and defend or leave early’ policy. Environmental Science & Policy 13, 185–194.
| Australian bushfire fatalities 1900–2008: exploring trends in relation to the ‘Prepare, stay and defend or leave early’ policy.CrossRef |
Johnson PF, Johnson CE, Sutherland S (2012) Stay or go? Human behaviour and decision making in bushfire and other emergencies. Fire Technology 48, 137–153.
| Stay or go? Human behaviour and decision making in bushfire and other emergencies.CrossRef |
Karoly DJ (2009) The recent bushfires and extreme heat wave in southeast Australia. Bulletin of the Australian Meteorological and Oceanographic Society 22, 10–13.
Krusel N, Petris SN (1992) A study of civilian deaths in the 1983 Ash Wednesday bushfires in Victoria, Australia. (Country Fire Authority: Melbourne)
Lazarus G, Elley, J (1984) A study of the effect of household occupancy during the Ash Wednesday bushfire in Upper Beaconsfield, Victoria, February 1983. (National Centre for Rural Fire Research: Melbourne)
Leonard J (2003) People and property: a researcher’s perspective. In ‘Australia burning: fire ecology, policy and management issues’. (Eds G Cary, D Lindenmayer, S Dovers) pp. 103–12. (CSIRO Publishing: Melbourne)
Leonard J, McArthur NA (1999). A history of research into building performance in Australian bushfires. In ‘Proceedings of the Australian Bushfire Conference’, 7–9 July 1999, Albury, NSW. (Eds I Lunt, DG Green) School of Environmental and Information Sciences, Charles Sturt University, pp. 219–25. (Charles Sturt University, School of Environmental & Information Sciences: Albury, NSW)
McArthur NA, Lutton P (1991) Ignition of exterior building details in bushfires: an experimental study. Fire and Materials 15, 59–64.
McCaffrey S, Rhodes A (2009) Public response to wildfire: is the Australian ‘Stay and defend or leave early’ approach an option for wildfire management in the United States? Journal of Forestry 107, 9–15.
McGee TK, Russell S (2003) ‘It’s just a natural way of life’: an investigation of wildfire preparedness in rural Australia. Environmental Hazards 5, 1–12.
| ‘It’s just a natural way of life’: an investigation of wildfire preparedness in rural Australia.CrossRef |
McMeekin MR (1995) Population protection: cooperation or confrontation. Wildfire 4, 32–34.
Moncrief M (2009) ‘Worst day in history’: Brumby warns of fire danger. The Age, 6 February 2009. Available at http://www.theage.com.au/national/worst-day-in-history-brumby-warns-of-fire-danger-20090206-7zf1.html [Verified 11 January 2012]
Mutch RW (2007) Faces: the story of the victims of Southern California’s 2003 fire siege. (Wildland Fire Lessons Learned Center: Tuscon, AZ) Available at http://www.wildfirelessons.net/documents/faces.pdf [Verified 11 January 2012]
Paveglio T, Carroll MS, Jakes PJ (2008) Alternatives to evacuation – protecting public safety during wildland fire. Journal of Forestry 106, 65–70.
Prior TD (2010) Householder bushfire preparation: decision-making and the implications for risk communication. PhD thesis, School of Psychology, University of Tasmania, Hobart.
Queen PL (1995) Evacuation at a wildland/urban interface fire. Wildfire 4, 22–23.
Ramsay GC, McArthur NA, Dowling VP (1987) Preliminary results from an examination of house survival in the 16 February 1983 bushfires in Australia. Fire and Materials 11, 49–51.
| Preliminary results from an examination of house survival in the 16 February 1983 bushfires in Australia.CrossRef |
Rhodes A (2005) Stay or go: what do people think of the choice? Available at http://www.bushfirecrc.com/managed/resource/stay_or_go_-_ar.pdf [Verified 13 April 2013] Bushfire CRC: East Melbourne.
Rhodes A (2007) The Australian ‘Stay or go’ approach: factors influencing householder decisions. In ‘Extended Abstracts from the 2nd Human Dimensions of Wildland Fire Conference’, 23–25 October 2007, Fort Collins, CO. pp. 70–71. (International Association of Wildland Fire: Fort Collins, CO) Available at http://www.iawfonline.org/pdf/HumanDimensionsExtendedAbstracts.pdf [Verified 5 October 2012]
Schorow S (2011) Stay or go? Available at http://www.nfpa.org/publicJournalDetail.asp?categoryID=2298&itemID=53549&src=NFPAJournal [Verified 24 January 2013]
State Coroner (2007) Inquest into the deaths of Starr Ellen Borlase, Jack Morley Borlase, Helen Kald Castle, Judith Maud Griffith, Jody Maria Kay, Graham Joseph Russell, Zoe Russell-Kay, Trent Alan Murnane and Neil George Richardson. (Courts Commission of South Australia: Adelaide<CA) Available at http://www.courts.sa.gov.au/CoronersFindings/Lists/Coroners%20Findings/Attachments/310/Wangary%20Fires%20Inquest%20-%20MODIFIED%20and%20FINAL%20February%202008.pdf [Verified 17 April 2013]
Stephens SL, Adams MA, Handmer J, Kearns FR, Leicester B, Leonard J, Moritz A (2009) Urban-wildland fires: how California and other regions of the US can learn from Australia. Environmental Research Letters 4, 014010
| Urban-wildland fires: how California and other regions of the US can learn from Australia.CrossRef |
Teague B, McLeod R, Pascoe S (2010) 2009 Victorian Bushfires Royal Commission final report: summary. (State Government of Victoria: Melbourne) Available at http://www.royalcommission.vic.gov.au/finaldocuments/summary/HR/VBRC_Summary_HR.pdf [Verified 11 January 2012]
Tibbits A, Whittaker J (2007) Stay and defend or leave early: policy problems and experiences during the 2003 Victorian bushfires. Environmental Hazards 7, 283–290.
| Stay and defend or leave early: policy problems and experiences during the 2003 Victorian bushfires.CrossRef |
Tibbits A, Handmer J, Haynes K, Lowe T, Whittaker J (2008) Prepare, stay and defend or leave early: evidence for the Australian approach. In ‘Community Bushfire Safety’. (Eds J Handmer, K Haynes) pp. 59–71 (CSIRO Publishing: Melbourne)
Whittaker J, Handmer J (2010) Community bushfire safety: a review of post-Black Saturday research. The Australian Journal of Emergency Management 25, 7–13.
Whittaker J, McLennan J, Elliot G, Gilbert J, Handmer J, Haynes K, Cowlishaw S (2009a) Victorian 2009 Bushfire Research Response: final report. (Bushfire CRC: Melbourne) Available at http://www.bushfirecrc.com/managed/resource/chapter-2-human-behaviour.pdf [Verified 11 January 2012]
Whittaker J, Haynes K, McLennan J, Handmer J, Towers B (2009b) Victorian 2009 Bushfire Research Response: household mail survey. (Bushfire CRC: Melbourne) Available at http://www.bushfirecrc.com/managed/resource/mail-survey-report-10-1-10-rt-2.pdf [Verified 11 January 2012]
Wilson AAG, Ferguson IS (1984) Fight or flee? A case study of the Mount Macedon bushfire. Australian Forestry 47, 230–236.
Wilson AAG, Ferguson IS (1986) Predicting the probability of house survival during bushfires. Journal of Environmental Management 23, 259–270.