Do koalas really get the blues? Critique of ‘Aversive behaviour by koalas (Phascolarctos cinereus) during the course of a music festival in northern New South Wales, Australia’Sean I. FitzGibbon A D , Amber K. Gillett A B , Ben J. Barth A , Brendan Taylor C and William A. Ellis A
A Koala Ecology Group, The University of Queensland, Brisbane, Qld 4072, Australia.
B FaunaVet, Glasshouse Mountains, Qld 4518, Australia.
C PO Box 73, New Brighton, NSW 2483, Australia.
D Corresponding author. Email: firstname.lastname@example.org
Australian Mammalogy 39(1) 108-112 https://doi.org/10.1071/AM16016
Submitted: 19 April 2016 Accepted: 3 July 2016 Published: 19 July 2016
It is imperative that the reported results of scientific studies are based on sound data analyses and unbiased interpretation, especially where they may be used to guide government policy and regulation. A recent paper by Phillips (2016) evaluated the behavioural response of radio-collared koalas to an inaugural large music festival held in 2010 in northern New South Wales. The study concluded that six of seven koalas showed an aversive response. However, we regard the paper as misleading because it contains serious errors in the examination of koala home ranges and in the subsequent assessment of ‘aversive behaviour’ during the music festival. We conclude that Phillips’ paper is based on sufficient data to state that three, not six, of the koalas he studied displayed a short-term behavioural response to the music festival. These koalas temporarily moved outside of their estimated ranges during the festival period (10–80 m). Further, Phillips fails to report crucial ecological data regarding the high level of disease and mortality he recorded, which are presented in their entirety in the author’s prior, unpublished report. For the two deaths that are reported, no mention is made that these koalas had pre-existing disease. Rather, the author raises the possibility that the mortalities may have been related to festival-induced stress. The omission of such key data is prejudicial to the interpretation of results. The reported short-term impact of the festival upon some of the study animals is indeed noteworthy; however, it is apparent that the impact has been considerably overstated due to errors of analysis and the omission of critical ecological data. Our critique highlights our concerns by drawing on the author’s unpublished report as well as our own research at the same site over the past five years. Our aim is to ensure that debate over the impact of music festivals on wildlife is based on sound data analyses and unbiased interpretation, to provide guidance to relevant regulators and land managers.
Additional keywords: anthropogenic impacts, conservation, disease, habitat use, radio telemetry, wildlife management.
ReferencesBrown, A. S., Girjes, A. A., Lavin, M. F., Timms, P., and Woolcock, J. B. (1987). Chlamydial disease in koalas. Australian Veterinary Journal 64, 346–350.
| Chlamydial disease in koalas.CrossRef | 1:STN:280:DyaL1c7pt1Grtw%3D%3D&md5=851a7ca460f888e9e2ecbacaae87c2b5CAS | 3328978PubMed |
Byron Shire Council (2015). Draft Byron Coast Comprehensive Koala Plan of Management. Byron Shire Council. Available at: http://www.byron.nsw.gov.au/public-exhibition/2014/03/21/draft-byron-coast-comprehensive-koala-plan-of-management-public-exhibit [accessed 30 May 2016].
Colvin, I., and FitzGibbon, S. (2015). Lots 103–105 DP1023126 Old Pacific Highway, Tyagarah; Revised Koala Plan of Management. Prepared for Bluesfest Pty Ltd. Australian Wetlands Consulting Pty Ltd.
Davies, N., Gillett, A., McAlpine, C., Seabrook, L., Baxter, G., Lunney, D., and Bradley, A. (2013). The effect of ACTH upon faecal glucocorticoid excretion in the koala. The Journal of Endocrinology 219, 1–12.
| The effect of ACTH upon faecal glucocorticoid excretion in the koala.CrossRef | 1:CAS:528:DC%2BC3sXhs1Ohs7zK&md5=0d77d7af76e747ddd23505b866d04928CAS | 23838520PubMed |
Ellis, W., Melzer, A., and Bercovitch, F. B. (2009). Spatiotemporal dynamics of habitat use by koalas: the checkerboard model. Behavioral Ecology and Sociobiology 63, 1181–1188.
| Spatiotemporal dynamics of habitat use by koalas: the checkerboard model.CrossRef |
Hopkins, M., and Phillips, S. (2010). Koala habitat assessment and monitoring program 2010. Final report to Bluesfest Pty Ltd. Biolink Ecological Consultants. Available at: http://www.bluesfest.com.au/pages/?ParentPageID=2&PageID=222 [accessed 11 July 2016].
Johnston, S. D., Booth, R. A., Pyne, M. J., Keeley, T., Mackie, J. T., Hulse, L., and Ellis, W. (2013). Is faecal cortisol or corticosterone a reliable index of acute serum cortisol secretion in the koala (Phascolarctos cinereus)? Australian Veterinary Journal 91, 534–537.
| Is faecal cortisol or corticosterone a reliable index of acute serum cortisol secretion in the koala (Phascolarctos cinereus)?CrossRef | 1:CAS:528:DC%2BC3sXhvVGrs7rE&md5=a718555ed800a2a94a1612da1f46f5b1CAS |
McAlpine, C. A., Lunney, D., Melzer, A., Menkhorst, P., Phillips, S., Phelan, D., Ellis, W., Foley, W. J., Baxter, G., de Villiers, D., Kavanagh, R., Adams-Hosking, C., Todd, C., Whisson, D., Molsher, R., Walter, M., Lawler, I., and Close, R. (2015). Conserving koalas: a review of regional trends, outlooks and policy challenges. Biological Conservation 192, 226–236.
| Conserving koalas: a review of regional trends, outlooks and policy challenges.CrossRef |
McFarland, D. (2006). ‘A Dictionary of Animal Behaviour.’ (Oxford University Press: Oxford.)
Melzer, A., Ellis, W., and FitzGibbon, S. (2013). A pathway to koala conservation in central Queensland. In ‘Conserving Central Queensland’s Koalas’. (Eds N. Flint, N. and A. Melzer.) pp. 1–3. (Koala Research Centre of Central Queensland, Central Queensland University: Rockhampton.)
Moyal, A. (2008). ‘Koala: A Historical Biography.’ (CSIRO Publishing: Melbourne.)
Narayan, E., Webster, K., Nicolson, V., Mucci, A., and Hero, J. (2013). Non-invasive evaluation of physiological stress in an iconic Australian marsupial: the koala (Phascolarctos cinereus). General and Comparative Endocrinology 187, 39–47.
| Non-invasive evaluation of physiological stress in an iconic Australian marsupial: the koala (Phascolarctos cinereus).CrossRef | 1:CAS:528:DC%2BC3sXot1Oiu7g%3D&md5=d389f37a08a822d0e9b24b8c48a4f0f5CAS | 23583768PubMed |
O’Donnell, S., Webb, J. K., and Shine, R. (2010). Conditioned taste aversion enhances the survival of an endangered predator imperilled by a toxic invader. Journal of Applied Ecology 47, 558–565.
| Conditioned taste aversion enhances the survival of an endangered predator imperilled by a toxic invader.CrossRef |
Pead, S. (2016). Byron Bay festival gives koalas the blues as furry neighbours look to escape racket. Available at: http://www.smh.com.au/environment/animals/byron-bay-festival-gives-koalas-the-blues-as-furry-neighbours-look-to-escape-racket-20160120-gmaem3.html [accessed 13 April 2016].
Pearce, J. (2008). ‘Animal Learning and Cognition: An Introduction.’ (Taylor & Francis Ltd: Hove, UK.)
Phillips, S. (2016). Aversive behaviour by koalas (Phascolarctos cinereus) during the course of a music festival in northern New South Wales, Australia. Australian Mammalogy 38, XXX–XXX.
| Aversive behaviour by koalas (Phascolarctos cinereus) during the course of a music festival in northern New South Wales, Australia.CrossRef |
Rhodes, J. R., Ng, C. F., de Villiers, D. L., Preece, H. J., McAlpine, C. A., and Possingham, H. P. (2011). Using integrated population modelling to quantify the implications of multiple threatening processes for a rapidly declining population. Biological Conservation 144, 1081–1088.
| Using integrated population modelling to quantify the implications of multiple threatening processes for a rapidly declining population.CrossRef |
Ryan, M. A., Whisson, D. A., Holland, G. J., and Arnould, J. P. Y. (2013). Activity patterns of free-ranging koalas (Phascolarctos cinereus) revealed by accelerometry. PLoS One 8, e80366.
| Activity patterns of free-ranging koalas (Phascolarctos cinereus) revealed by accelerometry.CrossRef | 1:CAS:528:DC%2BC3sXhslGisb7F&md5=6f162bf8258a9da62b3e2a13d8009e53CAS | 24224050PubMed |
Slezak, M. (2016). Byron Bay Bluesfest noise has destroyed local koala population, says ecologist. Available at: https://www.theguardian.com/science/2016/jan/20/noise-from-byron-bay-bluesfest-destroys-local-koala- population-says-ecologist [accessed 12 April 2016].
Walsh, J. C., Dicks, L. V., and Sutherland, W. J. (2015). The effect of scientific evidence on conservation practitioners’ management decisions. Conservation Biology 29, 88–98.
| The effect of scientific evidence on conservation practitioners’ management decisions.CrossRef | 25103469PubMed |
Wilson, D. P., Craig, A. P., Hanger, J., and Timms, P. (2015). The paradox of euthanizing koalas (Phascolarctos cinereus) to save populations from elimination. Journal of Wildlife Diseases 51, 833–842.
| The paradox of euthanizing koalas (Phascolarctos cinereus) to save populations from elimination.CrossRef | 26280878PubMed |