The nectar of Protea inflorescences attracts sugarbirds (Promeropidae) as well as a large diversity of arthropods. In addition to feeding on nectar, sugarbirds feed on arthropods; but do sugarbirds feed on the arthropods within Protea inflorescences? Through the use of arthropod collections from within Protea inflorescences and diet sampling data from previous studies together with arthropod samples collected during the current study, we investigated whether sugarbirds fed on arthropods found inside Protea inflorescences or whether most arthropods taken were flying arthropods, seldom found in Protea inflorescences. Cape (Promerops cafer) and Gurney’s (Promerops gurneyi) Sugarbirds showed a strong preference for flying insects, tourist or visitor species to Protea inflorescences, particularly Scarabaeidae and Apidae. Cape Sugarbirds showed a preference for Diptera and Gurney’s Sugarbirds showed a preference for Heteroptera. Small arthropods found within Protea inflorescences, for example ants, may be eaten accidentally while the sugarbirds are feeding on nectar. The results of this study support the hypothesis that sugarbirds feed on arthropods by hawking rather than obtaining them from within Protea inflorescences.