Insights from meta-analyses of incidents
Maureen Hassall A *A
Maureen Hassall is Professor and Director of the Minerals Industry Safety and Health Centre at the University of Queensland. She develops and delivers industry-focused research, training and expert consultancy projects that combine innovative and impactful human-centred design, risk management and safety engineering approaches to improve workers’ and companies’ health, safety, wellbeing and performance. Maureen’s academic work is motivated by 18 years working in a range of high hazard industries across a number of different countries. She holds Bachelors’ degrees in Engineering and Psychology, a Master’s in Business Administration and a PhD in Cognitive Systems Engineering. She is also a registered Professional and Chartered Engineer and a certified Ergonomist. |
Abstract
Across the world, process safety incidents continue to occur at an unacceptably high rate. This paper explores the application of bowtie and AcciMap analyses to perform meta-analyses of these incidents. Bowties are used to investigate what insights can be derived about causes, consequences and barrier performance. AcciMap analysis is used to investigate what insights can be derived about organisational contributions to barrier performance during incidents. Based on the findings from these analyses, recommendations are made about future directions to develop more timely and effective learning from incident systems.
Keywords: AcciMap, bowtie, incident, investigation, process safety, risk control, risk management, safety, safety barrier.
Maureen Hassall is Professor and Director of the Minerals Industry Safety and Health Centre at the University of Queensland. She develops and delivers industry-focused research, training and expert consultancy projects that combine innovative and impactful human-centred design, risk management and safety engineering approaches to improve workers’ and companies’ health, safety, wellbeing and performance. Maureen’s academic work is motivated by 18 years working in a range of high hazard industries across a number of different countries. She holds Bachelors’ degrees in Engineering and Psychology, a Master’s in Business Administration and a PhD in Cognitive Systems Engineering. She is also a registered Professional and Chartered Engineer and a certified Ergonomist. |
References
Acid Plant Database (2009) Acid plant database - Kemira. Available at http://www.sulphuric-acid.com/sulphuric-acid-on-the-web/acid%20plants/Kemira%20Kemi%20-%20Helsingborg.htm
COMAH (2011) Buncefield: why did it happen? Available at https://webarchive.nationalarchives.gov.uk/ukgwa/20220701173308mp_/https://www.hse.gov.uk/comah/buncefield/buncefield-report.pdf
CSB (2002) Motiva Enterprises Sulfuric Acid Tank Explosion. Available at https://www.csb.gov/motiva-enterprises-sulfuric-acid-tank-explosion/
CSB (2006) Marcus Oil and Chemical Tank Explosion. Available at https://www.csb.gov/marcus-oil-and-chemical-tank-explosion/
CSB (2007) Investigation report. Methanol tank explosion and fire. (US Chemical Safety and Hazard Investigation Board) Available at https://www.csb.gov/assets/1/20/bethune_final_report.pdf?13742
CSB (2008) Investigation report. Confined vapor cloud explosion. Available at https://www.csb.gov/assets/1/20/csbfinalreportcaiexplosion.pdf?13735
CSB (2009) Allied Terminals Fertilizer Tank Collapse. Available at https://www.csb.gov/allied-terminals-fertilizer-tank-collapse/
CSB (2010) Packaging Corporation Storage Tank Explosion. Avaiable at https://www.csb.gov/packaging-corporation-storage-tank-explosionn.
CSB (2014) CSB Chairperson Moure-Eraso Warns About Danger of Hot Work on Tanks Containing Biological or Organic Material. Available at https://www.csb.gov/csb-chairperson-moure-eraso-warns-about-danger-of-hot-work-on-tanks-containing-biological-or-organic-material/
CSB (2015a). Caribbean Petroleum Corporation (CAPECO) Refinery Tank Explosion and Fire. Available at https://www.csb.gov/caribbean-petroleum-refining-tank-explosion-and-fire/
CSB (2015b) E. I. DuPont De Nemours Co. Fatal Hotwork Explosion. Available at https://www.csb.gov/e-i-dupont-de-nemours-co-fatal-hotwork-explosion/
CSB (2017) Freedom Industries Chemical Release. Available at https://www.csb.gov/freedom-industries-chemical-release-/
CSB (2018) Packaging Corporation of America Hot Work Explosion. Available at https://www.csb.gov/packaging-corporation-of-america-hot-work-explosion-/
CSB (2019) Midland Resource Recovery Explosion. Available at https://www.csb.gov/midland-resource-recovery-explosion-/
CSB (2023) Intercontinental Terminals Company (ITC) Tank Fire. Available at https://www.csb.gov/intercontinental-terminals-company-itc-tank-fire/
DKL Engineering Inc. (2021) Storage tank failures. Available at http://www.sulphuric-acid.com/techmanual/plant_safety/safety_accidents-Archive.htm
DMP (2022) Tank failure a warning to industry. Available at https://www.dmp.wa.gov.au/News/Tank-failure-a-warning-to-30174.aspx
Energy Resources of Australia Ltd (2014) Leach tank incident update. Available at https://www.energyres.com.au/uploads/Releases/Media-Releases/20140326_leach_tank_update_media_release_FINAL.pdf
European Commision Joint Research Centre (2002) eNatech - Natural hazard-triggered technolocial accidents database. Available at https://enatech.jrc.ec.europa.eu/view/natech/41
Fire and Blast Information Group (2025) Industrial Accidents - Jaipur Oil Depot, India Facility. (The Indian Oil Corporation) Available at https://www.fabig.com/industrial-accidents/jaipur-oil-depot-india/
Hedlund FH, Selig RS, Kragh EK (2016) Large Steel Tank Fails and Rockets to Height of 30 meters – Rupture Disc Installed Incorrectly. Safety and Health at Work 7(2), 130-137.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Hydrogen Tools (2024) Lessons Learned: Fatal accident due to bacterial hydrogen production in atmospheric storage tank. Available at https://h2tools.org/lessons/fatal-accident-due-bacterial-hydrogen-production-atmospheric-storage-tank
NTSB (2004) Storage Tank Explosion and Fire in Glenpool, Oklahoma April 7, 2003 Pipeline Accident Report. Available at https://www.ntsb.gov/investigations/AccidentReports/Reports/PAR0402.pdf
Serrat O (2017). The Five Whys Technique. In ‘Knowledge Solutions: Tools, Methods, and Approaches to Drive Organizational Performance’. (Ed. O Serrat) pp. 307–310. (Springer: Singapore). 10.1007/978-981-10-0983-9_32
World Nuclear News (2014) Rössing eases in to restart. World Nuclear News, 20 January. Available at https://www.world-nuclear-news.org/Articles/Rossing-eases-in-to-restart
