Implementing Indigenous community control in health care: lessons from Canada
Josée G. Lavoie A C and Judith Dwyer BA Manitoba First Nations Centre for Aboriginal Health Research, University of Manitoba, #715, 727 McDermot Avenue, Winnipeg MB, R3E 3P5, Canada.
B Health Care Management, Flinders University, Health Sciences Building (2.38), GPO Box 2100, Adelaide, SA 5001, Australia. Email: judith.dwyer@flinders.edu.au
C Corresponding author. Email: josee.lavoie@umanitoba.ca
Australian Health Review 40(4) 453-458 https://doi.org/10.1071/AH14101
Submitted: 2 July 2014 Accepted: 27 August 2015 Published: 10 November 2015
Journal Compilation © AHHA 2016
Abstract
Objective Over past decades, Australian and Canadian Indigenous primary healthcare policies have focused on supporting community controlled Indigenous health organisations. After more than 20 years of sustained effort, over 89% of eligible communities in Canada are currently engaged in the planning, management and provision of community controlled health services. In Australia, policy commitment to community control has also been in place for more than 25 years, but implementation has been complicated by unrealistic timelines, underdeveloped change management processes, inflexible funding agreements and distrust. This paper discusses the lessons from the Canadian experience to inform the continuing efforts to achieve the implementation of community control in Australia.
Methods We reviewed Canadian policy and evaluation grey literature documents, and assessed lessons and recommendations for relevance to the Australian context.
Results Our analysis yielded three broad lessons. First, implementing community control takes time. It took Canada 20 years to achieve 89% implementation. To succeed, Australia will need to make a firm long term commitment to this objective. Second, implementing community control is complex. Communities require adequate resources to support change management. And third, accountability frameworks must be tailored to the Indigenous primary health care context to be meaningful.
Conclusions We conclude that although the Canadian experience is based on a different context, the processes and tools created to implement community control in Canada can help inform the Australian context.
What is known about the topic? Although Australia has promoted Indigenous control over primary healthcare (PHC) services, implementation remains incomplete. Enduring barriers to the transfer of PHC services to community control have not been addressed in the largely sporadic attention to this challenge to date, despite significant recent efforts in some jurisdictions.
What does this paper add? The Canadian experience indicates that transferring PHC from government to community ownership requires sustained commitment, adequate resourcing of the change process and the development of a meaningful accountability framework tailored to the sector.
What are the implications for practitioners? Policy makers in Australia will need to attend to reform in contractual arrangements (towards pooled or bundled funding), adopt a long-term vision for transfer and find ways to harmonise the roles of federal and state governments. The arrangements achieved in some communities in the Australian Coordinated Care Trials (and still in place) provide a model.
References
[1] Starfield B, Shi L, Macinko J. Contribution of primary care to health systems and health. Milbank Q 2005; 83 457–502.| Contribution of primary care to health systems and health.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 16202000PubMed |
[2] World Health Organization. Primary health care: now more than ever. 2008. Available at: http://www.who.int/topics/primary_health_care/en/ [verified 23 November 2014].
[3] World Health Organization (WHO) Commission on Social Determinants of Health. Closing the gap in a generation: health equity through action on the social determinants of health. Final report of the Commission on Social Determinants of Health. Geneva: WHO; 2008.
[4] Baum F. Envisioning a healthy and sustainable future: essential to closing the gap in a generation. Glob Health Promot Educ 2009; 16 72–80.
| Envisioning a healthy and sustainable future: essential to closing the gap in a generation.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
[5] Browne AJ, Varcoe CM, Wong ST, Smye VL, Lavoie J, Littlejohn D, Tu D, Godwin O, Krause M, Khan KB, Fridkin A, Rodney P, O’Neil J, Lennox S. Closing the health equity gap: evidence-based strategies for primary health care organizations. Int J Equity Health 2012; 11 59
| Closing the health equity gap: evidence-based strategies for primary health care organizations.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 23061433PubMed |
[6] Lavoie JG, Kaufert J, Browne A, Mah S, O’Neil J. Negotiating barriers, navigating the maze: First Nation peoples’ experience of medical relocation. Can Public Adm 2015; 58 295–314.
| Negotiating barriers, navigating the maze: First Nation peoples’ experience of medical relocation.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
[7] Lavoie JG, O’Neil J, Sanderson L, Elias B, Mignone J, Bartlett J, Forget E, Burton R, Schmeichel C, MacNeil D. The evaluation of the First Nations and Inuit health transfer policy. Winnipeg: MFN-Centre of Aboriginal Health Research; 2005.
[8] Dwyer J, O’Donnell K, Lavoie J, Marlina U, Sullivan P. The overburden project: funding and regulation of primary health care for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people. Melbourne: Lowitja Institute; 2009.
[9] Dwyer J, Lavoie JG, Sullivan P, O’Donnell K. Contracting for Indigenous health care: towards mutual accountability. Aust J Public Adm 2011; 70 34–46.
| Contracting for Indigenous health care: towards mutual accountability.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
[10] Waldram JB, Herring DA, Young TK. Aboriginal health in Canada: historical, cultural and epidemiological perspectives. 2nd edn. Toronto: University of Toronto Press; 2006.
[11] Boyer Y. Discussion paper series on Aboriginal health, legal issues: no. 3, the international right to health for Indigenous Peoples in Canada. Ottawa: National Aboriginal Health Organization; 2004.
[12] Leslie JF. Indian Act: an historical perspective. Canadian parliamentary review. 2002; 25: 2.
[13] Lavoie JG, O’Neil JD, Jeff R. Community healing and Aboriginal self-government. In: Belanger YD, editor. Aboriginal self-government in Canada: current trends and issues. 3rd edn. Saskatoon: Purich Publishing; 2009. pp. 172–205.
[14] Health Canada. Contribution agreements. Ottawa: Health Canada; 2012.
[15] Health Canada. Transfer status as of March 2008. Ottawa: Health Canada; 2008.
[16] Health Canada. Transfer of health programs to First Nations and Inuit communities, handbook 1: an introduction to three approaches. Ottawa: Health Canada; 2004.
[17] Lavoie JG, Forget E, Prakash T, Dahl M, Martens P, O’Neil JD. Have investments in on-reserve health services and initiatives promoting community control improved First Nations’ health in Manitoba? Soc Sci Med 2010; 71 717–24.
| Have investments in on-reserve health services and initiatives promoting community control improved First Nations’ health in Manitoba?Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 20554364PubMed |
[18] Office of the Auditor General of Canada. Chapter 13: Health Canada – First Nations health. In 1997 October Report of the Auditor General of Canada. Ottawa: OAGC; 1997. Available at: www.oag-bvg.gc.ca/domino/reports.nsf/html/ch9713e.html/ [verified 5 March 2013].
[19] Office of the Auditor General of Canada. Chapter 15: Health Canada – First Nations health: follow-up. In 2000 October Report of the Auditor General of Canada. Ottawa: OAGC; 2000. Available at: http://www.oag-bvg.gc.ca/internet/English/parl_oag_200010_15_e_11202.html/ [verified 23 November 2014].
[20] Office of the Auditor General of Canada. Chapter 1, Streamlining First Nations reporting to federal organizations. Ottawa: OAGC; 2002. Available at: http://www.oag-bvg.gc.ca/internet/English/parl_oag_200212_01_e_12395.html [verified 23 November 2014].
[21] Yourk D. Auditor cites gun registry as ‘inexcusable failure’. Globe and Mail, 3 December 2002. Available at: http://www3.sympatico.ca/d.senni/AuditorGeneralArticleDec302.htm [verified 12 September 2013].
[22] Lankin F, Clark I. From red tape to clear results: the report of the Independent Blue Ribbon Panel on grants and contribution programs. Ottawa: Treasury Board of Canada Secretariat; 2006.
[23] Health Canada. Health funding arrangements (HFA), the new approach to funding. Ottawa: Health Canada; 2008.
[24] Health Canada. Community-based reporting: a guide for First Nations and Inuit. Ottawa: Health Canada; 2008.
[25] Health Canada. The revision of the community-based reporting template. Ottawa: Health Canada; 2011.
[26] Howse G, Dwyer J. Legally invisible: stewardship for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander health. Aust N Z J Public Health 2015;
| Legally invisible: stewardship for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander health.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 25903648PubMed |
[27] Commonwealth of Australia. Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Health Plan, 2013–2023. Canberra: Commonwealth of Australia; 2013.
[28] Roberts D. Self-determination and the struggle for Aboriginal equality. In: Bourke C, Bourke E, editors. Aboriginal Australia. University of Queensland Press: St Lucia, Qld; 1994. pp. 212–36.
[29] Altman J. Indigenous policy. In: Miller C, Orchard L, editors. Australian public policy: progressive ideas in the neoliberal ascendency. Bristol, UK: Policy Press; 2014. pp. 115–32.
[30] Lavoie JG, Gervais L, Toner J, Bergeron O, Thomas G. Aboriginal health policies in Canada: the Policy Synthesis Project. Prince George, BC: National Collaborating Centre for Aboriginal Health; 2013.
[31] Northern Territory Aboriginal Health Forum. Pathways to community control: an agenda to further promote Aboriginal community control in the provision of primary health care services. Darwin: Government of the Northern Territory; 2009.
[32] Dwyer J, Martini A, Brown C, Tilton E, Devitt J, Myott P, Pekarsky B. The road is made by walking: towards a better primary health care system for Australia’s First Peoples. Melbourne: Lowitja Institute; 2015.
[33] Lavoie JG, Boulton AF, Dwyer J. Analysing contractual environments: lessons from Indigenous health in Canada, Australia and New Zealand. Public Adm 2010; 88 665–79.
| Analysing contractual environments: lessons from Indigenous health in Canada, Australia and New Zealand.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
[34] Moran M, Porter D, Curth-Bibb J. Funding Indigenous organisations: improving governance performance through innovations in public finance management in remote Australia. Canberra: Australian Institute of Health and Welfare; 2014.
[35] Tenbensel T, Dwyer J, Lavoie JG. How not to kill the golden goose? Reconceptualising acocuntability relationships in community-based third sector organisations. Public Adm Rev 2013; 16 925–44.
| How not to kill the golden goose? Reconceptualising acocuntability relationships in community-based third sector organisations.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
[36] Katherine West Health Board. Something special: the inside story of the Katherine West Health Board. Katherine: Katherine West Health Board; 2003.
[37] National Health and Hospitals Reform Commission. A healthier future for all Australians: final report June 2009. Canberra: National Health and Hospitals Reform Commission; 2009.
[38] Australian Institute of Health and Welfare (AIHW). National key performance indicators for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander primary health care: first national results June 2012 to June 2013. Canberra: Australian Institute of Health and Welfare; 2014.
