Culture, kastom and conservation in Melanesia: what happens when worldviews collide?Stacy Jupiter
Wildlife Conservation Society, Melanesia Program, 11 Ma’afu Street, Suva, Fiji. Email: firstname.lastname@example.org
Pacific Conservation Biology - https://doi.org/10.1071/PC16031
Submitted: 24 July 2016 Accepted: 5 February 2017 Published online: 28 February 2017
Melanesia is one of the most biologically and culturally diverse regions on earth, yet its species and ecosystems are fundamentally threatened by rapidly growing and modernising populations that drive increased demands for natural resource extraction. Despite good intentions, many conservation projects in Melanesia have not succeeded, largely due to a failure on the part of researchers and practitioners to understand underlying differences between western and indigenous worldviews and issues surrounding land and marine tenure arrangements. Learning from these failures is critical in order to improve odds for future project effectiveness and sustainability. Here I present lessons from attempts across Melanesia at establishing protected areas, conservation agreements, ecotourism initiatives and research-action arenas. These showcase challenges and conflicts when worldviews collide and opportunities that arise when mutual expectations are clarified early on during planning processes. Factors that contribute to more successful outcomes include: respecting international protocols for free, prior and informed consent; co-creating research and management agendas with local communities; clearly articulating realistic expected benefits; and establishing locally perceived equitable and transparent benefits sharing mechanisms.
Additional keywords: conservation agreements, conservation finance, ecotourism, protected areas, research engagement, tenure.
ReferencesAalbersberg, B., Avosa, M., James, R., Lauwin, C., Lokani, P., Opu, J., Siwatibau, S., Tuiwawa, M., Waqa-Sakiti, H., and Tordoff, A. W. (2012). Ecosystem profile: East Melanesian islands biodiversity hotspot. University of the South Pacific for the Critical Ecosystem Partnership Fund, Suva.
Agrawal, A., and Gibson, C. C. (1999). Enchantment and disenchantment: the role of community in natural resource conservation. World Development 27, 629–649.
| Enchantment and disenchantment: the role of community in natural resource conservation.CrossRef |
Bell, J. D., Kronen, M., Vunisea, A., Nash, W. J., Keeble, G., Demmke, A., Pontifex, S., and Andrefouet, S. (2009). Planning the use of fish for food security in the Pacific. Marine Policy 33, 64–76.
| Planning the use of fish for food security in the Pacific.CrossRef |
Bellwood, D. R., Hoey, A. S., and Choat, J. H. (2003). Limited functional redundancy in high diversity systems: resilience and ecosystem function on coral reefs. Ecology Letters 6, 281–285.
| Limited functional redundancy in high diversity systems: resilience and ecosystem function on coral reefs.CrossRef |
Bennett, J. A. (1987). ‘Wealth of the Solomons: A History of a Pacific Archipelago, 1800–1978.’ Pacific Islands Monograph Series, No. 3. (University of Hawaii Press: Honolulu.)
Berkes, F. (2004). Rethinking community-based conservation. Conservation Biology 18, 621–630.
| Rethinking community-based conservation.CrossRef |
Bickel, G., Nord, M., Price, C., Hamilton, W., and Cook, J. (2000). Guide to measuring household food security, Revised 2000. US Department of Agriculture, Food and Nutrition Service, Alexandria, Virginia.
Carrier, J. G. (1987). Marine tenure and conservation in Papua New Guinea. In ‘The Question of the Commons: the Culture and Ecology of Communal Resources’. (Eds B. J. McCay and J. M. Acheson.) pp. 142–167. (The University of Arizona Press: Tuscon.)
Chape, S. (2012). Natural world heritage in Oceania: challenges and opportunities. In ‘World Heritage in a Sea of Islands. Pacific 2009 Programme. World Heritage Papers 34’. (Ed. A. Smith.) pp. 40–45. (UNESCO: Paris.)
Cochran, P. A. L., Marshall, C. A., Garcia-Downing, C., Kendall, E., Cook, D., McCubbin, L., and Gover, R. M. S. (2008). Indigenous ways of knowing: implications for participatory research and community. American Journal of Public Health 98, 22–27.
| Indigenous ways of knowing: implications for participatory research and community.CrossRef |
Cook, J., and Kofana, G. E. (2008). Recording land rights and boundaries in Auluta Basin, Solomon Islands. In ‘Making Land Work. Volume 2. Case Studies on Customary Land and Development in the Pacific’. pp. 47–64. (Australian Agency for International Development: Canberra.)
Descola, P., and Pálsson, G. (1996). ‘Nature and Society.’ (Routledge: London.)
Diamond, J. M., and Mayr, E. (1976). Species-area relation for birds of the Solomon Archipelago. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 73, 262–266.
| Species-area relation for birds of the Solomon Archipelago.CrossRef | 1:STN:280:DC%2BC3cngslGhtw%3D%3D&md5=02d592015927ea2d1c1e21b355565645CAS |
FAO (2011). State of the World’s Forests 2011. Food and Agriculture Organization, Rome.
Foale, S. (2001). Where’s our development. The Asia Pacific Journal of Anthropology 2, 44–67.
| Where’s our development.CrossRef |
Foale, S., Cohen, P., Januchowski-Hartley, S., Wenger, A., and Macintyre, M. (2011). Tenure and taboos: origins and implications for fisheries in the Pacific. Fish and Fisheries 12, 357–369.
| Tenure and taboos: origins and implications for fisheries in the Pacific.CrossRef |
Foale, S., Dyer, M., and Kinch, J. (2016). The value of tropical biodiversity in rural Melanesia. Valuation Studies 4, 11–39.
| The value of tropical biodiversity in rural Melanesia.CrossRef |
Foukona, J. D. (2007). Legal aspects of customary land administration in Solomon Islands. Journal of South Pacific Law 11, 64–72.
GoF (2007). Fiji biodiversity strategy and action plan. Department of Environment, Government of Fiji, Suva.
GoPNG (2010). Papua New Guinea’s fourth national report to the Convention on Biological Diversity. Department of Environment and Conservation, Port Moresby.
Govan, H. (2011). Good coastal management practices in the Pacific: experiences from the field. Secretariat of the Pacific Regional Environment Programme, Apia.
Govan, H., and Jupiter, S. (2013). Can the IUCN 2008 protected areas management categories support Pacific island approaches to conservation? Parks 19, 73–80.
| Can the IUCN 2008 protected areas management categories support Pacific island approaches to conservation?CrossRef |
Govan, H., Tawake, A., Tabunakawai, K., Jenkins, A., Lasgorceix, A., Schwarz, A.-M., Aalbersberg, B., Manele, B., Vieux, C., Notere, D., Afzal, D., Techera, E., Rasalato, E. T., Sykes, H., Walton, H., Tafea, H., Korovulavula, I., Comley, J., Kinch, J., Feehely, J., Petit, J., Heaps, L., Anderson, P., Cohen, P., Ifopo, P., Vave, R., Hills, R., Tawakelevu, S., Alefaio, S., Meo, S., Troniak, S., Malimali, S., Kukuian, S., George, S., Tauaefa, T., and Obed, T. (2009). Status and potential of locally-managed marine areas in the South Pacific: meeting nature conservation and sustainable livelihood targets through wide-spread implementation of LMMAs. SPREP/WWF/WorldFish-Reefbase/CRISP, Suva.
Gutiérrez, N., Hilborn, R., and DeFeo, O. (2011). Leadership, social capital and incentives promote successful fisheries. Nature 470, 386–389.
| Leadership, social capital and incentives promote successful fisheries.CrossRef |
Haden, R. (2009). ‘Food Culture in the Pacific Islands.’ (Greenwood Press: Santa Barbara, CA).
Haila, Y. (2000). Beyond the nature–culture dualism. Biology & Philosophy 15, 155–175.
| Beyond the nature–culture dualism.CrossRef |
Hviding, E. (1996). ‘Guardians of Marovo Lagoon: Practice, Place, and Politics in Maritime Melanesia.’ (University of Hawaii Press: Honolulu.)
Hviding, E., and Bayliss-Smith, T. (2000). ‘Islands of Rainforest: Agroforestry, Logging and Eco-tourism in Solomon Islands.’ (Ashgate: London.)
Hyndman, D. (1993). Sea tenure and the management of living marine resources in Papua New Guinea. Pacific Studies 16, 99–114.
Igoe, J., and Brockington, D. (2007). Neoliberal conservation: a brief introduction. Conservation & Society 5, 432–449.
Ingold, T. (2000). ‘The Perception of the Environment: Essays on Livelihood, Dwelling and Skill.’ (Routledge: London.)
Jackson, R. T. (2002). Capacity building in Papua New Guinea for community maintenance during and after mine closure. International Institute for Environment and Development (IIED) and World Business Council for Sustainable Development (WBCSD), London.
Jupiter, S. D., Jenkins, A. P., Lee Long, W. J., Maxwell, S. L., Carruthers, T. J. B., Hodge, K. B., Govan, H., Tamelander, J., and Watson, J. E. M. (2014a). Principles for integrated island management in the tropical Pacific. Pacific Conservation Biology 20, 193–205.
| Principles for integrated island management in the tropical Pacific.CrossRef |
Jupiter, S. D., Mangubhai, S., and Kingsford, R. T. (2014b). Conservation of biodiversity in the Pacific Islands of Oceania: challenges and opportunities. Pacific Conservation Biology 20, 206–220.
| Conservation of biodiversity in the Pacific Islands of Oceania: challenges and opportunities.CrossRef |
Keppel, G., Morrison, C., Watling, D., Tuiwawa, M. V., and Rounds, I. A. (2012a). Conservation in tropical Pacific Island countries: why most current approaches are failing. Conservation Letters 5, 256–265.
| Conservation in tropical Pacific Island countries: why most current approaches are failing.CrossRef |
Keppel, G., Morrison, C., Hardcastle, J., Rounds, I. A., Wilmott, I. K., Hurahura, F., and Shed, P. K. (2012b). Conservation in tropical Pacific island countries: case studies of successful programmes. Parks 18, 111–124.
| Conservation in tropical Pacific island countries: case studies of successful programmes.CrossRef |
Keppel, G., Morrison, C., Meyer, J.-Y., and Boehmer, H. J. (2014). Isolated and vulnerable: the history and future of Pacific Island terrestrial biodiversity. Pacific Conservation Biology 20, 136–145.
| Isolated and vulnerable: the history and future of Pacific Island terrestrial biodiversity.CrossRef |
Kingsford, R. T., Watson, J. E. M., Lundquist, C. J., Venter, O., Hughes, L., Johnston, E. L., Atherton, J., Gawel, M., Keith, D. A., Mackey, B. G., Morley, C., Possingham, H. P., Raynor, B., Recher, H. F., and Wilson, K. A. (2009). Major conservation policy issues for biodiversity in Oceania. Conservation Biology 23, 834–840.
| Major conservation policy issues for biodiversity in Oceania.CrossRef | 1:STN:280:DC%2BD1MrgsVersQ%3D%3D&md5=1b64a26fd2c7ea3ec9ea2f05e7755e98CAS |
Lees, A., Garnett, M., and Wright, S. (1991). A representative protected forests system for the Solomon Islands. Maruia Society for the Australian Parks and Wildlife Service, Nelson.
Lynch, J., and Crowley, T. (2001). ‘Languages of Vanuatu.’ (Pacific Linguists: Canberra.)
Mace, G. M. (2014). Whose conservation? Science 345, 1558–1560.
| Whose conservation?CrossRef | 1:CAS:528:DC%2BC2cXhsl2iu7fJ&md5=59e480816af51b6cacefadfe851f7785CAS |
Macintyre, M., and Foale, S. (2007). Land and marine tenure, ownership and new forms of entitlement on Lihir: Changing notions of property in the context of a goldmining project. Human Organization 66, 49–59.
Milne, S., and Niesten, E. (2009). Direct payments for biodiversity conservation in developing countries: practical insights for design and implementation. Oryx 43, 530–541.
| Direct payments for biodiversity conservation in developing countries: practical insights for design and implementation.CrossRef |
Mittermeier, R. A., Turner, W. R., Larsen, F. W., Brooks, T. M., and Gascon, C. (2011). Global biodiversity conservation: the critical role of hotspots. In ‘Biodiversity Hotspots’. (Eds F. E. Zachos and J. C. Habel.) pp. 3–22. (Springer-Verlag: Berlin.)
Muroa, G. M. S. (1999). The extent of constitutional protection of land rights in Papua New Guinea. Melanesian Law Journal 4. Available at: http://www.paclii.org/journals/MLJ/1998/1994.html [accessed 22 July 2016].
Ruddle, K., Hviding, E., and Johannes, R. E. (1992). Marine resource management in the context of customary tenure. Marine Resource Economics 7, 249–273.
| Marine resource management in the context of customary tenure.CrossRef |
Sillitoe, P. (2009). ‘Local Science vs. Global Science: Approaches to Indigenous Knowledge in International Development.’ (Berghahn Books: New York.)
Siurua, H. (2006). Nature above people: Rolston and “fortress” conservation in the South. Ethics and the Environment 11, 71–96.
| Nature above people: Rolston and “fortress” conservation in the South.CrossRef |
Techera, E. J. (2012). ‘Marine Environmental Governance: From International Law to Local Practice.’ (Routledge: Abingdon, UK.)
Turner, N. J., Gregory, R., Brooks, C., Failing, L., and Satterfield, T. (2008). From invisibility to transparency: identifying the implications. Ecology and Society 13, art7.
| From invisibility to transparency: identifying the implications.CrossRef |
Van Helden, F. (1998). Between cash and conviction. The social context of the Bismarck-Ramu integrated conservation and development project. Monograph 33. Papua New Guinea National Research Institute, Waigani, Papua New Guinea.
Veron, J. E. N., DeVantier, L. M., Turak, E., Green, A. L., Kininmonth, S., Stafford-Smith, M., and Peterson, N. (2009). Delineating the Coral Triangle. Galaxea, Journal of Coral Reef Studies 11, 91–100.
| Delineating the Coral Triangle.CrossRef |
Vukikomoala, K., Jupiter, S., Erasito, E., and Chand, K. (2012). An analysis of international law, national legislation, judgements, and institutions as they interrelate with territories and areas conserved by indigenous peoples and local communities. Report No. 19, Fiji. Natural Justice and Kalpavriksh, Bangalore and Delhi.
Walter, M. A. H. B. (1978). Analysis of Fijian traditional social organization: the confusion of local and descent grouping. Ethnology 17, 351–356.
| Analysis of Fijian traditional social organization: the confusion of local and descent grouping.CrossRef |
Walter, R. K., and Hamilton, R. J. (2014). A cultural landscape approach to community-based conservation in Solomon Islands. Ecology and Society 19, art41.
| A cultural landscape approach to community-based conservation in Solomon Islands.CrossRef |
Ward, R. G. (1995). Land, law and custom: diverging realities in Fiji. In ‘Land, Custom and Practice in the South Pacific’. (Eds R. G. Ward and E. Kingdon.) pp. 198–249. (Cambridge University Press: Cambridge.)
West, P. (2006). ‘Conservation is Our Government Now: The Politics of Ecology in Papua New Guinea.’ (Duke University Press: Durham, NC.)
West, P. (2016). ‘Dispossession and the Environment. Rhetoric and Inequality in Papua New Guinea.’ (Columbia University Press: New York.)
West, P., and Kale, E. (2015). The fate of Crater Mountain: forest conservation in the Eastern Highlands of Papua New Guinea. In ‘Tropical Forests of Oceania: Anthropological Perspectives’. Asia-Pacific Environment Monograph. (Eds J. Bell, P. West and C. Filer.) pp. 155–178. (ANU Press: Canberra.)
West, P., Igoe, J., and Brockington, D. (2006). Parks and peoples: the social impact of protected areas. Annual Review of Anthropology 35, 251–277.
| Parks and peoples: the social impact of protected areas.CrossRef |
Whitmore, N. (2015). Harnessing local ecological knowledge for conservation decision making via Wisdon of Crowds: the case of the Manus green tree snail Papustyla pucherrima. Oryx , .
| Harnessing local ecological knowledge for conservation decision making via Wisdon of Crowds: the case of the Manus green tree snail Papustyla pucherrima.CrossRef |
Whitmore, N., Lamaris, J., Takendu, W., Charles, D., Chuwek, T., Mohe, B., Kanau, L., and Pe-eu, S. (2016). The context and potential sustainability of traditional terrestrial periodic tambu areas: insights from Manus Island, Papua New Guinea. Pacific Conservation Biology 22, 151–158.
| The context and potential sustainability of traditional terrestrial periodic tambu areas: insights from Manus Island, Papua New Guinea.CrossRef |
Winslow, J. H. (Ed.) (1977). ‘The Melanesian Environment.’ (The Australian National University: Canberra.)
Wurm, S. A. (2007). Threatened languages in the Western Pacific Area from Taiwan to, and including, Papua New Guinea. In ‘Language Diversity Endangered’. (Ed. M. Brenzinger.) pp. 374–390. (Walter de Gruyter GmbH & Co.: Berlin.)