Personal experiences of appropriate access to post-acute care services in acquired brain injury: a scoping review
Kirstyn Laurie
A B * , Michele Foster A B and Louise Gustafsson A B
A The Hopkins Centre: Research for Rehabilitation and Resilience,
B School of Health Sciences and Social Work,
Abstract
People with an acquired brain injury (ABI) experience substantial access inequalities and unmet health needs, with many experiencing insufficient access to appropriate rehabilitation in the community. To deepen our understanding of what appropriate access to post-acute care services is for this population, and to facilitate optimal recovery, there is a need to synthesise research from the service user perspective. A scoping review study was conducted to identify key characteristics of ‘appropriate’ access to post-acute care services, as defined by the personal experiences of adults with ABI. Electronic scientific databases Medline, PsycINFO, Proquest Central and CINAHL were searched for studies published between 2000 and 2020. The initial search identified 361 articles which, along with articles retrieved from reference list searches, resulted in 52 articles included in the final analysis. Results indicated that a majority of the studies sampled participants with an average of over 1 year post-injury, with some studies sampling participants ranging over 10 years in difference in time post-injury. A thematic synthesis was conducted and results indicated a number of dominant elements which relate to (1) the characteristics of services: provider expertise, interpersonal qualities, partnership and adaptability; (2) characteristics of the health system: navigable system, integrated care, adequacy, and opportunity. These findings provide some insight into what might be considered appropriate. However, rigorous research, focused on personalised access to post-acute care services, is recommended to verify and elaborate on these findings.
Keywords: Access, adequacy, rehabilitation, post-acute, lived experience.
References
Abrahamson V., Jensen J., Springett K., Sakel M. (2017) Experiences of patients with traumatic brain injury and their carers during transition from in-patient rehabilitation to the community: A qualitative study. Disability and Rehabilitation 39(17), 1683-1694.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Andelic N., Soberg H. L., Berntsen S., Sigurdardottir S., Roe C. (2014) Self-perceived health care needs and delivery of health care services 5 years after moderate-to-severe traumatic brain injury. Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation 6(11), 1013-1021.
| Google Scholar |
Arksey H., O’Malley L. (2005) Scoping studies: Towards a methodological framework. International Journal of Social Research Methodology 8(1), 19-32.
| Google Scholar |
Braaf S., Ameratunga S., Christie N., Teague W., Ponsford J., Cameron P. A., Gabbe B. J. (2019) Care coordination experiences of people with traumatic brain injury and their family members in the 4-years after injury: A qualitative analysis. Brain Injury 33(5), 574-583.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Brauer J., Hay C. C., Francisco G. (2011) A retrospective investigation of occupational therapy services received following a traumatic brain injury. Occupational Therapy Health Care 25(2-3), 119-130.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Brighton R., Traynor V., Moxham L., Curtis J. (2013) The needs of people with alcohol-related brain injury (ARBI): A review of the international literature. Drugs and Alcohol Today 13(3), 205-214.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Bryan-Hancock C., Harrison J. (2010) The global burden of disease project 2005 methods utilised by the injury expert group for estimating world-wide incidence and prevalence rates. Injury Prevention 16(Suppl 1), A99.
| Google Scholar |
Buntin M. B. (2007) Access to postacute rehabilitation. Archives of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation 88(11), 1488-1493.
| Google Scholar |
Chamberlain D. J. (2006) The experience of surviving traumatic brain injury. Journal of Advanced Nursing 54(4), 407-417.
| Google Scholar |
Chan J. (2008) What do people with acquired brain injury think about respite care and other support services? International Journal of Rehabilitation Research 31(1), 3-11.
| Google Scholar |
Collie A., Prang K. (2013) Patterns of healthcare service utilisation following severe traumatic brain injury: An idiographic analysis of injury compensation claims data. Injury 44(11), 1514-1520.
| Google Scholar |
Conneeley A. L. (2012) Transitions and brain injury: A qualitative study exploring the journey of people with traumatic brain injury. Brain Impairment 13(1), 72-84.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Copley A., McAllister L., Wilson L. (2013) We finally learnt to demand: Consumers’ access to rehabilitation following traumatic brain injury. Brain Impairment 14(3), 436-449.
| Google Scholar |
Dams-O’Connor K., Landau A., Hoffman J., De Lore J. S. (2018) Patient perspectives on quality and access to healthcare after brain injury. Brain Injury 32(4), 431-441.
| Google Scholar |
de Koning M. E., Spikman J. M., Coers A., Schönherr M. C., van der Naalt J. (2015) Pathways of care the first year after moderate and severe traumatic brain injury—Discharge destinations and outpatient follow-up. Brain Injury 29(4), 423-429.
| Google Scholar |
Doig E., Fleming J., Cornwell P., Kuipers P. (2011) Comparing the experience of outpatient therapy in home and day hospital settings after traumatic brain injury: Patient, significant other and therapist perspectives. Disability and Rehabilitation 33(13-14), 1203-1214.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Dwyer A., Heary C., Ward M., MacNeela P. (2019) Adding insult to brain injury: Young adults’ experiences of residing in nursing homes following acquired brain injury. Disability and Rehabilitation 41(1), 33-43.
| Google Scholar |
Eliacin J., Fortney S., Rattray N. A., Kean J. (2018) Access to health services for moderate to severe TBI in Indiana: Patient and caregiver perspectives. Brain Injury 32(12), 1510-1517.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Fleminger S., Ponsford J. (2005) Long term outcome after traumatic brain injury. British Medical Journal 331(7530), 1419-1420.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Foster M., Allen S., Fleming J. (2015) Unmet health and rehabilitation needs of people with long-term neurological conditions in Queensland. Australia Health & Social Care in the Community 23(3), 292-303.
| Google Scholar |
Foster M., Fleming J., Tilse C., Rosenman L. (2000) Referral to post-acute care following traumatic brain injury (TBI) in the Australian context. Brain Injury 14(12), 1035-1045.
| Google Scholar |
Foster M., Henman P., Tilse C., Fleming J., Allen S., Harrington R. (2016) Reasonable and necessary’care: The challenge of operationalising the NDIS policy principle in allocating disability care in Australia. Australian Journal of Social Issues 51(1), 27-46.
| Google Scholar |
Gill I. J., Wall G., Simpson J. (2012) Clients’ perspectives of rehabilitation in one acquired brain injury residential rehabilitation unit: A thematic analysis. Brain Injury 26(7-8), 909-920.
| Google Scholar |
Glintborg C., Thomsen A. S., Hansen T. G. B. (2018) Beyond broken bodies and brains: A mixed methods study of mental health and life transitions after brain injury. Brain Impairment 19(3), 215-227.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Graff H. J., Christensen U., Poulsen I., Egerod I. (2018) Patient perspectives on navigating the field of traumatic brain injury rehabilitation: A qualitative thematic analysis. Disability and Rehabilitation 40(8), 926-934.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Grant M. J., Booth A. (2009) A typology of reviews: An analysis of 14 review types and associated methodologies. Health Information & Libraries Journal 26(2), 91-108.
| Google Scholar |
Halas G., Schultz A. S., Rothney J., Goertzen L., Wener P., Katz A. (2015) A scoping review protocol to map the research foci trends in tobacco control over the last decade. BMJ Open 5(1), e006643.
| Google Scholar |
Hall A., Grohn B., Nalder E., Worrall L., Fleming J. (2012) A mixed methods study of the experience of transition to the community of working-aged people with non-traumatic brain injury. Brain Impairment 13(1), 85-98.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Harrington R., Foster M., Fleming J. (2015) Experiences of pathways, outcomes and choice after severe traumatic brain injury under no-fault versus fault-based motor accident insurance. Brain Injury 13(14), 1561-1571.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Harrison A. L., Hunter E. G., Thomas H., Bordy P., Stokes E., Kitzman P. (2017) Living with traumatic brain injury in a rural setting: Supports and barriers across the continuum of care. Disability and Rehabilitation 39(20), 2071-2080.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Hooson J. M., Coetzer R., Stew G., Moore A. (2013) Patients’ experience of return to work rehabilitation following traumatic brain injury: A phenomenological study. Neuropsychological Rehabilitation 23(1), 19-44.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Hyatt K., Davis L. L., Barroso J. (2014) Chasing the care: Soldiers experience following combat-related mild traumatic brain injury. Military Medicine 179(8), 849-855.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Jackson K., Hamilton S., Jones S., Barr S. (2019) Patient reported experiences of using community rehabilitation and/or support services whilst living with a long-term neurological condition: A qualitative systematic review and meta-aggregation. Disability and Rehabilitation 41(23), 2731-2749.
| Google Scholar |
Jolliffe L., Lannin N. A., Cadilhac D. A., Hoffmann T. (2018) Systematic review of clinical practice guidelines to identify recommendations for rehabilitation after stroke and other acquired brain injuries. BMJ Open 8(2), e018791.
| Google Scholar |
Jumisko E., Lexell J., Soderberg S. (2007) The experiences of treatment from other people as narrated by people with moderate or severe traumatic brain injury and their close relatives. Disability Rehabilitation 29(19), 1535-1543.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Keightley M., Kendall V., Jang S. H., Parker C., Agnihotri S., Colantonio A., et al. (2011) From health care to home community: An Aboriginal community-based ABI transition strategy. Brain Injury 25(2), 142-152.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Kivunja S., River J., Gullick J. (2018) Experiences of giving and receiving care in traumatic brain injury: An integrative review. Journal of Clinical Nursing 27(7-8), 1304-1328.
| Google Scholar |
Kumar R., Kumar A., Singh A. K. (2019) Psychosocial impact of brain injury: A review. Indian Journal of Neurosurgery 8(01), 011-015.
| Google Scholar |
Lefebvre H., Levert M. J. (2012) The needs experienced by individuals and their loved ones following a traumatic brain injury. Journal of Trauma Nursing 19(4), 197-207.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Lefebvre H., Pelchat D., Swaine B., Gelinas I., Levert M. (2005) The experiences of individuals with a traumatic brain injury, families, physicians and health professionals regarding care provided throughout the continuum. Brain Injury 19(8), 585-597.
| Google Scholar |
Leith K. H., Phillips L., Sample P. L. (2004) Exploring the service needs and experiences of persons with TBI and their families: The South Carolina experience. Brain Injury 18(12), 1191-1208.
| Google Scholar |
Levesque J. F., Harris M. F., Russell G. (2013) Patient-centred access to health care: Conceptualising access at the interface of health systems and populations. International Journal for Equity in Health 12, 18.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Lexell E. M., Alkhed A.-K., Olsson K. (2013) The group rehabilitation helped me adjust to a new life: Experiences shared by persons with an acquired brain injury. Brain Injury 27(5), 529-537.
| Google Scholar |
Maratos M., Huynh L., Tan J., Lui J., Jarus T. (2016) Picture this: Exploring the lived experience of high-functioning stroke survivors using photovoice. Qualitative Health Research 26(8), 1055-1066.
| Google Scholar |
Martin R., Levack W. M., Sinnott K. A. (2015) Life goals and social identity in people with severe acquired brain injury: An interpretative phenomenological analysis. Disability and Rehabilitation 37(14), 1234-1241.
| Google Scholar |
Matérne M., Lundqvist L.-O., Strandberg T. (2017) Opportunities and barriers for successful return to work after acquired brain injury: A patient perspective. Work 56(1), 125-134.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Mbakile-Mahlanza L., Manderson L., Ponsford J. (2015) The experience of traumatic brain injury in Botswana. Neuropsychological Rehabilitation 25(6), 936-958.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
McCusker K., Gunaydin S. (2015) Research using qualitative, quantitative or mixed methods and choice based on the research. Perfusion 30(7), 537-542.
| Google Scholar |
Mellick D., Gerhart K. A., Whiteneck G. G. (2003) Understanding outcomes based on the post-acute hospitalization pathways followed by persons with traumatic brain injury. Brain Injury 17(1), 55-71.
| Google Scholar |
Mitsch V., Curtin M., Badge H. (2014) The provision of brain injury rehabilitation services for people living in rural and remote New South Wales. Australia Brain Injury 28(12), 1504-1513.
| Google Scholar |
Morrow-Howell N., Proctor E. K., Dore P. (1998) Adequacy of care: The concept and its measurement. Research on Social Work Practice 8(1), 86-102.
| Google Scholar |
Muenchberger H., Kendall E., Collings C. (2011) Beyond crisis care in brain injury rehabilitation in Australia: A conversation worth having. Journal of Primary Care and Community Health 2(1), 60-64.
| Google Scholar |
Nalder E., Fleming J., Foster M., Cornwell P., Shields C., Khan A. (2012) Identifying factors associated with perceived success in the transition from hospital to home after brain injury. The Journal of Head Trauma Rehabilitation 27(2), 143-153.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
O'Callaghan A., McAllister L., Wilson L. (2012) Healthcare consumers’ need for brain-injury services: the critical importance of timing in planning future services. Brain Impairment 13(3), 316-332.
| Google Scholar |
O’Callaghan A., McAllister L., Wilson L. (2012) Insight vs readiness: Factors affecting engagement in therapy from the perspectives of adults with TBI and their significant others. Brain Injury 13(14), 1599-1610.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
O’Callaghan A. M., McAllister L., Wilson L. (2010) Experiences of care reported by adults with traumatic brain injury. International Journal of Speech-Language Pathology 12(2), 107-123.
| Google Scholar |
Pickelsimer E. E., Selassie A. W., Sample P. L., Heinemann W., Gu A., J. K., Veldheer L. C. (2007) Unmet service needs of persons with traumatic brain injury. The Journal of Head Trauma Rehabilitation 22(1), 1-13.
| Google Scholar |
Prang K.-H., Ruseckaite R., Collie A. (2012) Healthcare and disability service utilization in the 5-year period following transport-related traumatic brain injury. Brain Injury 26(13-14), 1611-1620.
| Google Scholar |
Roozenbeek B., Maas A. I., Menon D. K. (2013) Changing patterns in the epidemiology of traumatic brain injury. Nature Reviews Neurology 9(4), 231-236.
| Google Scholar |
Rotondi A. J., Sinkule J., Balzer K., Harris J., Moldovan R. (2007) A qualitative needs assessment of persons who have experienced traumatic brain injury and their primary family caregivers. The Journal of Head Trauma Rehabilitation 22(1), 14-25.
| Google Scholar |
Rusconi S., Turner-Stokes L. (2003) An evaluation of aftercare following discharge from a specialist in-patient rehabilitation service. Disability and Rehabilitation 25(22), 1281-1288.
| Google Scholar |
Schulz-Heik R., Poole J. H., Dahdah M. N., Sullivan C., Adamson M. M., Date E. S., et al. (2017) Service needs and barriers to care five or more years after moderate to severe TBI among veterans. Brain Injury 31(10), 1287-1293.
| Google Scholar |
Simpson G., Mohr R., Redman A. (2000) Cultural variations in the understanding of traumatic brain injury and brain injury rehabilitation. Brain Injury 14(2), 125-140.
| Google Scholar |
Simpson G., Secheny T., Lane-Brown A., Strettles B., Ferry K., Phillips J. (2004) Post-Acute rehabilitation for people With traumatic brain injury: A model description and evaluation of the Liverpool Hospital transitional living program. Brain Impairment 5(1), 67-80.
| Google Scholar |
Simpson G., Simons M., McFadyen M. (2002) The challenges of a hidden disability: Social work practice in the field of traumatic brain injury. Australian Social Work 55(1), 24-37.
| Google Scholar |
Snell D. L., Martin R., Surgenor L. J., Siegert R. J., Hay-Smith E. J. C. (2017) What’s wrong with me? Seeking a coherent understanding of recovery after mild traumatic brain injury. Disability and Rehabilitation 39(19), 1968-1975.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Soeker M. S., Van Rensburg V., Travill A. (2012) Are rehabilitation programmes enabling clients to return to work? Return to work perspectives of individuals with mild to moderate brain injury in South Africa. Work 43(2), 171-182.
| Google Scholar |
Solovieva T. I., Walls R. T. (2014) Barriers to traumatic brain injury services and supports in rural setting. Journal of Rehabilitation 80(4), 10-18.
| Google Scholar |
Strandberg T. (2009) Adults with acquired traumatic brain injury: Experiences of a changeover process and consequences in everyday life. Social Work in Health Care 48(3), 276-297.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Ta’eed G., Skilbeck C. E., Slatyer M. (2013) Which factors determine who is referred for community rehabilitation following traumatic brain injury? Brain Impairment 14(2), 222-234.
| Google Scholar |
Thomas J., Harden A. (2008) Methods for the thematic synthesis of qualitative research in systematic reviews. BMC Medical Research Methodology 8(1), 45.
| Google Scholar |
Toor G. K., Harris J. E., Escobar M., Yoshida K., Velikonja D., Rizoli S., et al. (2016) Long-term health service outcomes among women with traumatic brain injury. Archives of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation 97(2), S54-S63.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Turner B., Fleming J., Cornwell P., Haines T., Ownsworth T. (2009) Profiling early outcomes during the transition from hospital to home after brain injury. Brain Injury 23(1), 51-60.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Turner B., Fleming J., Cornwell P., Worrall L., Ownsworth T., Haines T., et al. (2007) A qualitative study of the transition from hospital to home for individuals with acquired brain injury and their family caregivers. Brain Injury 21(11), 1119-1130.
| Google Scholar |
Turner B., Fleming J., Ownsworth T., Cornwell P. (2008) The transition from hospital to home for individuals with acquired brain injury: A literature review and research recommendations. Disability Rehabilitation 30(16), 1153-1176.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Turner B., Fleming J., Ownsworth T., Cornwell P. (2011) Perceived service and support needs during transition from hospital to home following acquired brain injury. Disability Rehabilitation 33(10), 818-829.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Turner B., Fleming J., Ownsworth T., Cornwell P. (2011) Perceptions of recovery during the early transition phase from hospital to home following acquired brain injury: A journey of discovery. Neuropsychological Rehabilitation 21(1), 64-91.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Turner-Stokes L., Pick A., Nair A., Disler P. B., Wade D. T. (2015) Multi-disciplinary rehabilitation for acquired brain injury in adults of working age. The Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews 12,.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Umeasiegbu V. I., Waletich B., Whitten L. A., Bishop M. (2013) Community-based rehabilitation needs: Perceptions of individuals with brain injury and their families in the midwestern United States. The Australian Journal of Rehabilitation Counselling 19(2), 155-163.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Winkler D., Farnworth L., Sloan S., Brown T. (2011) Moving from aged care facilities to community-based accommodation: Outcomes and environmental factors. Brain Injury 25(2), 153-168.
| Google Scholar |
Wyse J. J., Pogoda T. K., Mastarone G. L., Gilbert T., Carlson K. F. (2020) Employment and vocational rehabilitation experiences among veterans with polytrauma/traumatic brain injury history. Psychological Services 17(1), 65-74.
| Google Scholar |
