Historical changes in marine communities uncovered in diverse data sources highlight impacts over half a century
John W. Turnbull
A B C * , David J. Booth D and Graeme F. Clark A B C
A
B
C
D
Abstract
Historical records and citizen scientist data are a useful resource for long-term ecological studies, yet their quality and validity have been challenged.
We aimed to investigate how traditional structured surveys and unstructured, opportunistic data sources can be used to understand historical ecological change over half a century.
We studied ~6000 records between 1965 and 2020 from the Shiprock site in the Sydney region, to understand ecological changes and insights that could be derived from these diverse data sources.
We report the local disappearance of some fish and invertebrate species, declines in the abundance of many taxa including kelp, potential impacts of the implementation of a marine reserve and range extensions consistent with climate change. Structured surveys provided broadly scientifically useful ecological information, whereas unstructured opportunistic data provided long-term retrospective community information and species presence information.
We have described scientifically and managerially relevant insights encompassing foundation, threatened, protected and invasive species, community shifts and the impacts of local and global processes over historical timescales.
Unstructured, opportunistic data sources can document long-term ecological changes arising from local and global processes, but are limited in the ability to provide population and community structure information.
Keywords: citizen science, climate change, historical marine ecology, invasive species, marine protected areas, protected species, Shiprock, threatened species.
References
Aceves-Bueno E, Adeleye AS, Feraud M, Huang Y, Tao M, Yang Y, Anderson SE (2017) The accuracy of citizen science data: a quantitative review. The Bulletin of the Ecological Society of America 98(4), 278-290.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Althaus F, Hill N, Edwards L, Ferrari R, Case M, Colquhoun J (2013) CATAMI Classification Scheme for scoring marine biota and substrata in underwater imagery – a pictorial guide to the collaborative and annotation tools for analysis of marine imagery and video (CATAMI) classification scheme. Version 1.4 – December 2014. (CATAMI) Available at https://catami.org/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2023/03/CATAMI_class_PDFGuide_V4_20141218.pdf
Alyazichi YM, Qasim AK, Jones BG, McLean E, Murad J, Aljawi A (2021) Geochemistry, spatial distribution, and sources of trace element pollution in the surface sediments of Port Hacking, southern Sydney, Australia. Anthropocene Coasts 4(1), 1-16.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Balée W (2006) The research program of historical ecology. Annual Review of Anthropology 35, 75-98.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Basford AJ, Feary DA, Truong G, Steinberg PD, Marzinelli EM, Vergés A (2015) Feeding habits of range-shifting herbivores: tropical surgeonfishes in a temperate environment. Marine and Freshwater Research 67(1), 75-83.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Bates D, Mächler M, Bolker B, Walker S (2015) Fitting linear mixed-effects models using lme4. Journal of Statistical Software 67(1), 1-48.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Beijbom O, Edmunds PJ, Kline DI, Mitchell BG, Kriegman D (2012) Automated annotation of coral reef survey images. In ‘2012 IEEE Conference on Computer Vision and Pattern Recognition’, 16–21 June 2012, Providence, RI, USA. pp. 1170–1177. (IEEE) 10.1109/CVPR.2012.6247798
Beller EE, McClenachan L, Zavaleta ES, Larsen LG (2020) Past forward: recommendations from historical ecology for ecosystem management. Global Ecology and Conservation 21, e00836.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Birch GF, Lee J-H, Gunns T (2021) Baseline assessment of anthropogenic change and ecological risk of an estuary bordered by an urbanized catchment and a pristine national park (Port Hacking estuary, Australia). Marine Pollution Bulletin 162, 111822.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Blasi M, Carrié R, Fägerström C, Svensson E, Persson AS (2023) Historical and citizen-reported data show shifts in bumblebee phenology over the last century in Sweden. Biodiversity and Conservation 32(5), 1523-1547.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Brook BW, Sodhi NS, Bradshaw CJA (2008) Synergies among extinction drivers under global change. Trends in Ecology & Evolution 23(8), 453-460.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Brown ED, Williams BK (2019) The potential for citizen science to produce reliable and useful information in ecology. Conservation Biology 33(3), 561-569.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Callaghan CT, Poore AGB, Major RE, Rowley JJL, Cornwell WK (2019) Optimizing future biodiversity sampling by citizen scientists. Proceedings of the Royal Society of London – B. Biological Sciences 286(1912), 20191487.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Callaghan CT, Roberts JD, Poore AGB, Alford RA, Cogger H, Rowley JJL (2020) Citizen science data accurately predicts expert-derived species richness at a continental scale when sampling thresholds are met. Biodiversity and Conservation 29, 1323-1337.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Callaghan CT, Poore AGB, Mesaglio T, Moles AT, Nakagawa S, Roberts C, et al. (2021) Three frontiers for the future of biodiversity research using citizen science data. Bioscience 71(1), 55-63.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Castro N, Ramalhosa P, Cacabelos E, Costa JL, Canning-Clode J, Gestoso I (2021) Winners and losers: prevalence of non-indigenous species under simulated marine heatwaves and high propagule pressure. Marine Ecology Progress Series 668, 21-38.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Concepcion GT, Kahng SE, Crepeau MW, Franklin EC, Coles SL, Toonen RJ (2010) Resolving natural ranges and marine invasions in a globally distributed octocoral (genus Carijoa). Marine Ecology Progress Series 401, 113-127.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Cook PA, Warnock B, Gillies CL, Hams AB (2021) Historical abundance and distribution of the native flat oyster (Ostrea angasi) in estuaries of the Great Southern region of Western Australia help to prioritise potential sites for contemporary oyster reef restoration. Marine and Freshwater Research 73(1), 48-56.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Crall AW, Newman GJ, Jarnevich CS, Stohlgren TJ, Waller DM, Graham J (2010) Improving and integrating data on invasive species collected by citizen scientists. Biological Invasions 12, 3419-3428.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Dickinson JL, Zuckerberg B, Bonter DN (2010) Citizen science as an ecological research tool: challenges and benefits. Annual Review of Ecology, Evolution, and Systematics 41, 149-172.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Edgar GJ, Stuart-Smith RD (2009) Ecological effects of marine protected areas on rocky reef communities – a continental-scale analysis. Marine Ecology Progress Series 388, 51-62.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Edgar GJ, Stuart-Smith RD (2014) Systematic global assessment of reef fish communities by the Reef Life Survey program. Scientific Data 1, 140007.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Edgar GJ, Stuart-Smith RD, Willis TJ, Kininmonth S, Baker SC, Banks S, et al. (2014) Global conservation outcomes depend on marine protected areas with five key features. Nature 506(7487), 216-220.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Edgar GJ, Stuart-Smith RD, Heather FJ, Barrett NS, Turak E, Sweatman H, et al. (2023) Continent-wide declines in shallow reef life over a decade of ocean warming. Nature 615(7954), 858-865.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Ellis RD (2019) Red grouper (Epinephelus morio) shape faunal communities via multiple ecological pathways. Diversity 11(6), 89.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Filbee-Dexter K, Feehan CJ, Scheibling RE (2016) Large-scale degradation of a kelp ecosystem in an ocean warming hotspot. Marine Ecology Progress Series 543, 141-152.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Flood M, Stobutzki I, Andrews J, Ashby C, Begg G, Fletcher R, Galeano D, Gardner C, Gibson B, Gray C, Hone P, Horvat P, McDonald B, Quinn R, Rowling K, Sainsbury K, Saunders T, Sloan S, Smith T, Ward T (2012) Status of key Australian fish stocks reports 2012. The inaugural process of production and lessons learned. Fisheries Research and Development Corporation Project number 2011-513. (Australian Bureau of Agricultural and Resource Economics and Sciences: Canberra, ACT, Australia)
Francis MP, Harasti D, Malcolm HA (2016) Surviving under pressure and protection: a review of the biology, ecology and population status of the highly vulnerable grouper Epinephelus daemelii. Marine and Freshwater Research 67(8), 1215-1228.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Gajdzik L, DeCarlo TM, Koziol A, Mousavi-Derazmahalleh M, Coghlan M, Power MW, et al. (2021) Climate-assisted persistence of tropical fish vagrants in temperate marine ecosystems. Communications Biology 4(1), 1231.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Harasti D, Malcolm H (2013) Distribution, relative abundance and size composition of the threatened serranid Epinephelus daemelii in New South Wales, Australia. Journal of Fish Biology 83(2), 378-395.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Jackson JBC, Kirby MX, Berger WH, Bjorndal KA, Botsford LW, Bourque BJ, Bradbury RH, Cooke R, Erlandson J, Estes JA, Hughes TP, Kidwell S, Lange CB, Lenihan HS, Pandolfi JM, Peterson CH, Steneck RS, Tegner MJ, Warner RR (2001) Historical overfishing and the recent collapse of coastal ecosystems. Science 293(5530), 629-637.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Jennett C, Kloetzer L, Schneider D, Iacovides I, Cox A, Gold M, et al. (2016) Motivations, learning and creativity in online citizen science. Journal of Science Communication 15(3), A05.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Lawler CJ (1998) The subtidal flora and fauna at Shiprock, Port Hacking, New South Wales during 1965–1970. Wetlands Australia Journal 17(2), 41-59.
| Google Scholar |
Lepczyk CA, Boyle OD, Vargo TL, Gould P, Jordan R, Liebenberg L, et al. (2009) Symposium 18: citizen science in ecology: the intersection of research and education. The Bulletin of the Ecological Society of America 90(3), 308-317.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Madrigal-Mora S, Hannes Eisele M, Espinoza M (2022) Do reef fish assemblages benefit from a marine protected area in the north Pacific coast of Costa Rica? Environmental Biology of Fishes 105(5), 541-559.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
McClenachan L, Ferretti F, Baum JK (2012) From archives to conservation: why historical data are needed to set baselines for marine animals and ecosystems. Conservation Letters 5(5), 349-359.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
McKinley AC, Ryan L, Coleman MA, Knott NA, Clark G, Taylor MD, Johnston EL (2011) Putting marine sanctuaries into context: a comparison of estuary fish assemblages over multiple levels of protection and modification. Aquatic Conservation: Marine and Freshwater Ecosystems 21(7), 636-648.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Meehan AJ, West RJ (2002) Experimental transplanting of Posidonia australis seagrass in Port Hacking, Australia, to assess the feasibility of restoration. Marine Pollution Bulletin 44(1), 25-31.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Mesaglio T, Callaghan CT (2021) An overview of the history, current contributions and future outlook of iNaturalist in Australia. Wildlife Research 48(4), 289-303.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Micheli F, Carlton J, Pearse J, Selgrath J, Elahi R, Watanabe J, et al. (2020) Field stations as sentinels of change. Frontiers in Ecology and the Environment 18(6), 320-322.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Moffitt EA, Botsford LW, Kaplan DM, O’Farrell MR (2009) Marine reserve networks for species that move within a home range. Ecological Applications 19(7), 1835-1847.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Parker LM, Ross PM, O’Connor WA, Pörtner HO, Scanes E, Wright JM (2013) Predicting the response of molluscs to the impact of ocean acidification. Biology 2(2), 651-692.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Pereira RRC, Scanes E, Parker LM, Byrne M, Cole VJ, Ross PM (2019) Restoring the flat oyster Ostrea angasi in the face of a changing climate. Marine Ecology Progress Series 625, 27-39.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Pickholtz RSM, Kiflawi M, Friedlander AM, Belmaker J (2018) Habitat utilization by an invasive herbivorous fish (Siganus rivulatus) in its native and invaded range. Biological Invasions 20, 3499-3512.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Roberts CJ, Vergés A, Callaghan CT, Poore AGB (2022) Many cameras make light work: opportunistic photographs of rare species in iNaturalist complement structured surveys of reef fish to better understand species richness. Biodiversity and Conservation 31(4), 1407-1425.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Scarborough C, Welch ZS, Wilson J, Gleason MG, Saccomanno VR, Halpern BS (2022) The historical ecology of coastal California. Ocean & Coastal Management 230, 106352.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Smale DA (2020) Impacts of ocean warming on kelp forest ecosystems. New Phytologist 225(4), 1447-1454.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Smith SM, Malcolm HA, Marzinelli EM, Schultz AL, Steinberg PD, Vergés A (2021) Tropicalization and kelp loss shift trophic composition and lead to more winners than losers in fish communities. Global Change Biology 27(11), 2537-2548.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Specht H, Lewandowski E (2018) Biased assumptions and oversimplifications in evaluations of citizen science data quality. The Bulletin of the Ecological Society of America 99(2), 251-256.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Stallings CD (2008) Indirect effects of an exploited predator on recruitment of coral-reef fishes. Ecology 89(8), 2090-2095.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Steffe AS, Murphy JJ (2011) Recreational fishing surveys in the Greater Sydney Region. Fisheries Final Report Series Number 131. (NSW Department of Primary Industries: Sydney, NSW, Australia) Available at https://www.dpi.nsw.gov.au/__data/assets/pdf_file/0008/545741/FFRS-131_Steffe-and-Murphy-2011.pdf
Theobald EJ, Ettinger AK, Burgess HK, DeBey LB, Schmidt NR, Froehlich HE, et al. (2015) Global change and local solutions: tapping the unrealized potential of citizen science for biodiversity research. Biological Conservation 181, 236-244.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Thurstan RH (2022) The potential of historical ecology to aid understanding of human–ocean interactions throughout the Anthropocene. Journal of Fish Biology 101(2), 351-364.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Thurstan RH, McClenachan L, Crowder LB, Drew JA, Kittinger JN, Levin PS, et al. (2015) Filling historical data gaps to foster solutions in marine conservation. Ocean & Coastal Management 115, 31-40.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Turnbull JW, Shah Esmaeili Y, Clark GF, Figueira WF, Johnston EL, Ferrari R (2018) Key drivers of effectiveness in small marine protected areas. Biodiversity and Conservation 27(9), 2217-2242.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Turnbull JW, Johnston EL, Kajlich L, Clark GF (2020) Quantifying local coastal stewardship reveals motivations, models and engagement strategies. Biological Conservation 249, 108714.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Turnbull JW, Johnston EL, Clark GF (2021) Evaluating the social and ecological effectiveness of partially protected marine areas. Conservation Biology 35, 921-932.
| Crossref | Google Scholar | PubMed |
Turnbull JW, Booth DJ, Vergés A, Clark G (2024) Historical marine ecology using non-traditional data sources reveals the impact of local and global processes over half a century. ResearchSquare 2024, ver. 1 [Preprint, published 4 August 2024].
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Vergés A, Tomas F, Cebrian E, Ballesteros E, Kizilkaya Z, Dendrinos P, et al. (2014) Tropical rabbitfish and the deforestation of a warming temperate sea. Journal of Ecology 102(6), 1518-1527.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Vergés A, Doropoulos C, Malcolm HA, Skye M, Garcia-Pizá M, Marzinelli EM, et al. (2016) Long-term empirical evidence of ocean warming leading to tropicalization of fish communities, increased herbivory, and loss of kelp. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 113(48), 13791-13796.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Vergés A, McCosker E, Mayer-Pinto M, Coleman MA, Wernberg T, Ainsworth T, Steinberg PD (2019) Tropicalisation of temperate reefs: implications for ecosystem functions and management actions. Functional Ecology 33(6), 1000-1013.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
