Register      Login
Environmental Chemistry Environmental Chemistry Society
Environmental problems - Chemical approaches
RESEARCH ARTICLE

The role of oxygen vacancy over ZnCr-layered double oxide in enhancing solar light-driven photocatalytic degradation of bisphenol A

Meiqing Chen A B , Pingxiao Wu orcid.org/0000-0002-8335-6971 A B C D E , Qianqian Wei A B , Yajie Zhu A B , Shanshan Yang A B , Liting Ju A B , Nengwu Zhu A B C and Zhang Lin A B C
+ Author Affiliations
- Author Affiliations

A School of Environment and Energy, South China University of Technology, Guangzhou 510006, China.

B The Key Lab of Pollution Control and Ecosystem Restoration in Industry Clusters, Ministry of Education, Guangzhou 510006, China.

C Guangdong Provincial Engineering and Technology Research Center for Environmental Risk Prevention and Emergency Disposal, South China University of Technology, Guangzhou Higher Education Mega Centre, Guangzhou 510006, China.

D Guangdong Engineering and Technology Research Center for Environmental Nanomaterials, Guangzhou 510006, China.

E Corresponding author. Email: pppxwu@scut.edu.cn

Environmental Chemistry 15(4) 226-235 https://doi.org/10.1071/EN18014
Submitted: 16 January 2018  Accepted: 27 March 2018   Published: 3 July 2018

Environmental context. An important goal in attempts to degrade environmental organic pollutants is the development of a photocatalyst that is responsive to visible light. We report a facile method for preparing a zinc-based photocatalyst with oxygen vacancies that efficiently degrades bisphenol A under solar light irradiation. The study will stimulate further investigations into the efficacy of other metal oxide nanostructures for the photocatalytic degradation of organic pollutants.

Abstract. Two ZnCr-layered double oxides (ZnCr-LDO) were fabricated via different thermal treatment of the ZnCr-layered double hydroxide (ZnCr-LDH) precursor. ZnCr-V-700 and ZnCr-A-700 were obtained at 700 °C under vacuum and air, respectively. As X-ray diffraction revealed, both ZnCr-V-700 and ZnCr-A-700 were made up of ZnO and ZnCr2O4 spinel, and ZnCr-V-700 displayed a lower crystallinity and many uniform particles with oxygen vacancies. Scanning electron microscopy and transmission electron microscopy revealed that the particle size of ZnCr-V-700 was ~30 nm and its disordered crystallinity suggested the existence of oxygen vacancies. Notably, the ZnCr-LDO materials showed remarkably enhanced photocatalytic activity compared to the ZnCr-LDH precursor. ZnCr-V-700 was the most active material and more than 90 % of BPA was degraded after irradiation for 200 min with high mineralisation (up to 37 %). The results of Brunauer–Emmett–Teller surface area analysis, X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy, Raman and UV-vis spectroscopy and electron paramagnetic resonance spectroscopy showed that oxygen vacancies incorporated into ZnCr-V-700 played a key role in improving the photocatalytic performance by enhancing interfacial charge transfer and restricting the charge recombination. In addition, the uniform particle size, larger surface area and the coexistence of ZnO and ZnCr2O4 also played a synergistic role. In conclusion, this work not only provides a facile and low-cost method to prepare photocatalysts for treatment of wastewater containing BPA, but also supplies a new idea for improving the performance of photocatalysts.

Additional keywords: interfacial charge transfer, photocatalysts.


References

Ansari SA, Khan MM, Kalathil S, Nisar A, Lee J, Cho MH (2013). Oxygen vacancy induced band gap narrowing of ZnO nanostructures by an electrochemically active biofilm. Nanoscale 5, 9238–9246.
Oxygen vacancy induced band gap narrowing of ZnO nanostructures by an electrochemically active biofilmCrossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |

Baliarsingh N, Mohapatra L, Parida K (2013). Design and development of a visible light harvesting Ni-Zn/Cr-CO32− LDH system for hydrogen evolution. Journal of Materials Chemistry A: Materials for Energy and Sustainability 1, 4236–4243.
Design and development of a visible light harvesting Ni-Zn/Cr-CO32− LDH system for hydrogen evolutionCrossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |

Baliarsingh N, Parida KM, Pradhan GC (2014). Effects of Co, Ni, Cu, and Zn on photophysical and photocatalytic properties of carbonate intercalated M-II/Cr LDHs for enhanced photodegradation of methyl orange. Industrial & Engineering Chemistry Research 53, 3834–3841.
Effects of Co, Ni, Cu, and Zn on photophysical and photocatalytic properties of carbonate intercalated M-II/Cr LDHs for enhanced photodegradation of methyl orangeCrossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |

Carriazo D, Del Arco M, Garcia-Lopez E, Marci G, Martin C, Palmisano L, Rives V (2011). ZnAl hydrotalcites calcined at different temperatures: Preparation, characterization and photocatalytic activity in gas-solid regime. Journal of Molecular Catalysis A: Chemical 342–343, 83–90.
ZnAl hydrotalcites calcined at different temperatures: Preparation, characterization and photocatalytic activity in gas-solid regimeCrossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |

Chang H, Chu E, Yeh Y, Wu Y, Lo F, Wang W, Chern M, Chiu H (2017). Influence of oxygen vacancies on the frictional properties of nanocrystalline zinc oxide thin films in ambient conditions. Langmuir 33, 8362–8371.
Influence of oxygen vacancies on the frictional properties of nanocrystalline zinc oxide thin films in ambient conditionsCrossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |

Chiba H, Kawashima T, Washio K (2017). Optical and structural properties of CuCrO2 thin films on c-face sapphire substrate deposited by reactive RF magnetron sputtering. Materials Science in Semiconductor Processing 70, 234–238.
Optical and structural properties of CuCrO2 thin films on c-face sapphire substrate deposited by reactive RF magnetron sputteringCrossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |

Chong B, Zhu W, Hou X (2017). Epitaxial hetero-structure of CdSe/TiO2 nanotube arrays with PEDOT as a hole transfer layer for photoelectrochemical hydrogen evolution. Journal of Materials Chemistry A: Materials for Energy and Sustainability 5, 6233–6244.
Epitaxial hetero-structure of CdSe/TiO2 nanotube arrays with PEDOT as a hole transfer layer for photoelectrochemical hydrogen evolutionCrossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |

Deva Kumar ET, Thirumalai K, Balachandran S, Aravindhan R, Swaminathan M, Raghava Rao J (2017). Solar light driven degradation of post tanning water at heterostructured BiVO4-ZnO mixed oxide catalyst interface. Surfaces and Interfaces 8, 147–153.
Solar light driven degradation of post tanning water at heterostructured BiVO4-ZnO mixed oxide catalyst interfaceCrossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |

Dhiman P, Naushad M, Batoo KM, Kumar A, Sharma G, Ghfar AA, Kumar G, Singh M (2017). Nano FeXZn1-XO as a tuneable and efficient photocatalyst for solar powered degradation of bisphenol A from aqueous environment. Journal of Cleaner Production 165, 1542–1556.
Nano FeXZn1-XO as a tuneable and efficient photocatalyst for solar powered degradation of bisphenol A from aqueous environmentCrossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |

Duan X, Ao Z, Li D, Sun H, Zhou L, Suvorova A, Saunders M, Wang G, Wang S (2016). Surface-tailored nanodiamonds as excellent metal-free catalysts for organic oxidation. Carbon 103, 404–411.
Surface-tailored nanodiamonds as excellent metal-free catalysts for organic oxidationCrossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |

Game O, Singh U, Kumari T, Banpurkar A, Ogale S (2014). ZnO(N)-Spiro-MeOTAD hybrid photodiode: an efficient self-powered fast-response UV (visible) photosensor. Nanoscale 6, 503–513.
ZnO(N)-Spiro-MeOTAD hybrid photodiode: an efficient self-powered fast-response UV (visible) photosensorCrossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |

Golunski SE, Hatcher HA, Rajaram RR, Truex TJ (1995). Origins of low-temperature three-way activity in Pt/CeO 2. Applied Catalysis B: Environmental 5, 367–376.
Origins of low-temperature three-way activity in Pt/CeO 2Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |

Hou J, Cao S, Wu Y, Liang F, Sun Y, Lin Z, Sun L (2017). Simultaneously efficient light absorption and charge transport of phosphate and oxygen-vacancy confined in bismuth tungstate atomic layers triggering robust solar CO2 reduction. Nano Energy 32, 359–366.
Simultaneously efficient light absorption and charge transport of phosphate and oxygen-vacancy confined in bismuth tungstate atomic layers triggering robust solar CO2 reductionCrossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |

Joseph L, Zaib Q, Khan IA, Berge ND, Park Y, Saleh NB, Yoon Y (2011). Removal of bisphenol A and 17 alpha-ethinyl estradiol from landfill leachate using single-walled carbon nanotubes. Water Research 45, 4056–4068.
Removal of bisphenol A and 17 alpha-ethinyl estradiol from landfill leachate using single-walled carbon nanotubesCrossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |

Koilraj P, Kannan S (2013). Aqueous fluoride removal using ZnCr layered double hydroxides and their polymeric composites: Batch and column studies. Chemical Engineering Journal 234, 406–415.
Aqueous fluoride removal using ZnCr layered double hydroxides and their polymeric composites: Batch and column studiesCrossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |

Kong J, Lai X, Rui Z, Ji H, Ji S (2016). Multichannel charge separation promoted ZnO/P25 heterojunctions for the photocatalytic oxidation of toluene. Chinese Journal of Catalysis 37, 869–877.
Multichannel charge separation promoted ZnO/P25 heterojunctions for the photocatalytic oxidation of tolueneCrossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |

Kumar A, Naushad M, Rana A, Inamuddin , Preeti , Sharma G, Ghfar AA, Stadler FJ, Khan MR (2017a). ZnSe-WO3 nano-hetero-assembly stacked on Gum ghatti for photo-degradative removal of Bisphenol A: Symbiose of adsorption and photocatalysis. International Journal of Biological Macromolecules 104, 1172–1184.
ZnSe-WO3 nano-hetero-assembly stacked on Gum ghatti for photo-degradative removal of Bisphenol A: Symbiose of adsorption and photocatalysisCrossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |

Kumar A, Kumar A, Sharma G, Naushad M, Stadler FJ, Ghfar AA, Dhiman P, Saini RV (2017b). Sustainable nano-hybrids of magnetic biochar supported g-C3N4/FeVO4 for solar powered degradation of noxious pollutants – Synergism of adsorption, photocatalysis & photo-ozonation. Journal of Cleaner Production 165, 431–451.
Sustainable nano-hybrids of magnetic biochar supported g-C3N4/FeVO4 for solar powered degradation of noxious pollutants – Synergism of adsorption, photocatalysis & photo-ozonationCrossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |

Kumar A, Kumar A, Sharma G, Al-Muhtaseb AH, Naushad M, Ghfar AA, Stadler FJ (2018). Quaternary magnetic BiOCl/g-C3N4/Cu2O/Fe3O4 nano-junction for visible light and solar powered degradation of sulfamethoxazole from aqueous environment. Chemical Engineering Journal 334, 462–478.
Quaternary magnetic BiOCl/g-C3N4/Cu2O/Fe3O4 nano-junction for visible light and solar powered degradation of sulfamethoxazole from aqueous environmentCrossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |

Li C, Jiang B, Miyamoto N, Kim JH, Malgras V, Yamauchi Y (2015a). Surfactant-directed synthesis of mesoporous Pd films with perpendicular mesochannels as efficient electrocatalysts. Journal of the American Chemical Society 137, 11558–11561.
Surfactant-directed synthesis of mesoporous Pd films with perpendicular mesochannels as efficient electrocatalystsCrossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |

Li H, Ren F, Liu J, Wang Q, Li Q, Yang J, Wang Y (2015b). Endowing single-electron-trapped oxygen vacancy self-modified titanium dioxide with visible-light photocatalytic activity by grafting Fe(III) nanocluster. Applied Catalysis B: Environmental 172–173, 37–45.
Endowing single-electron-trapped oxygen vacancy self-modified titanium dioxide with visible-light photocatalytic activity by grafting Fe(III) nanoclusterCrossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |

Li C, Vaynzof Y, Lakhwani G, Beirne GJ, Wang J, Greenham NC (2017a). Observation of oxygen vacancy migration in memory devices based on ZnO nanoparticles. Journal of Applied Physics 121, 144503–144506.
Observation of oxygen vacancy migration in memory devices based on ZnO nanoparticlesCrossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |

Li H, Li W, Gu S, Wang F, Liu X, Ren C (2017b). Forming oxygen vacancies inside in lutetium-doped Bi2MoO6 nanosheets for enhanced visible-light photocatalytic activity. Molecular Catalysis 433, 301–312.
Forming oxygen vacancies inside in lutetium-doped Bi2MoO6 nanosheets for enhanced visible-light photocatalytic activityCrossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |

Liu C, Huang H, Du X, Zhang T, Tian N, Guo Y, Zhang Y (2015). In situ co-crystallization for fabrication of g-C3N4/Bi5O7I heterojunction for enhanced visible-light photocatalysis. The Journal of Physical Chemistry C 119, 17156–17165.
In situ co-crystallization for fabrication of g-C3N4/Bi5O7I heterojunction for enhanced visible-light photocatalysisCrossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |

Liu S, Wu P, Chen M, Yu L, Kang C, Zhu N, Dang Z (2017). Amphoteric modified vermiculites as adsorbents for enhancing removal of organic pollutants: Bisphenol A and Tetrabromobisphenol A. Environmental Pollution 228, 277–286.
Amphoteric modified vermiculites as adsorbents for enhancing removal of organic pollutants: Bisphenol A and Tetrabromobisphenol ACrossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |

Luo C, Li D, Wu W, Yu C, Li W, Pan C (2015). Preparation of 3D reticulated ZnO/CNF/NiO heteroarchitecture for high-performance photocatalysis. Applied Catalysis B: Environmental 166–167, 217–223.
Preparation of 3D reticulated ZnO/CNF/NiO heteroarchitecture for high-performance photocatalysisCrossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |

Lv Y, Pan C, Ma X, Zong R, Bai X, Zhu Y (2013). Production of visible activity and UV performance enhancement of ZnO photocatalyst via vacuum deoxidation. Applied Catalysis B: Environmental 138–139, 26–32.
Production of visible activity and UV performance enhancement of ZnO photocatalyst via vacuum deoxidationCrossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |

Mousavi Z, Soofivand F, Esmaeili-Zare M, Salavati-Niasari M, Bagheri S (2016). ZnCr2O4 nanoparticles: facile synthesis, characterization, and photocatalytic properties. Scientific Reports 6, 20071
ZnCr2O4 nanoparticles: facile synthesis, characterization, and photocatalytic propertiesCrossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |

Palanisamy B, Babu CM, Sundaravel B, Anandan S, Murugesan V (2013). Sol-gel synthesis of mesoporous mixed Fe2O3/TiO2 photocatalyst: Application for degradation of 4-chlorophenol. Journal of Hazardous Materials 252–253, 233–242.
Sol-gel synthesis of mesoporous mixed Fe2O3/TiO2 photocatalyst: Application for degradation of 4-chlorophenolCrossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |

Parida K, Mohapatra L (2012). Recent progress in the development of carbonate-intercalated Zn/Cr LDH as a novel photocatalyst for hydrogen evolution aimed at the utilization of solar light. Dalton Transactions 41, 1173–1178.
Recent progress in the development of carbonate-intercalated Zn/Cr LDH as a novel photocatalyst for hydrogen evolution aimed at the utilization of solar lightCrossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |

Patnaik S, Sahoo DP, Mohapatra L, Martha S, Parida K (2017). ZnCr2O4@ZnO/g-C3N4: A triple-junction nanostructured material for effective hydrogen and oxygen evolution under visible light. Energy Technology 5, 1687–1701.
ZnCr2O4@ZnO/g-C3N4: A triple-junction nanostructured material for effective hydrogen and oxygen evolution under visible lightCrossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |

Pausova S, Krysa J, Jirkovsky J, Forano C, Mailhot G, Prevot V (2015). Insight into the photocatalytic activity of ZnCr-CO3 LDH and derived mixed oxides. Applied Catalysis B: Environmental 170–171, 25–33.
Insight into the photocatalytic activity of ZnCr-CO3 LDH and derived mixed oxidesCrossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |

Prince J, Tzompantzi F, Mendoza-Damian G, Hernandez-Beltran F, Valente JS (2015). Photocatalytic degradation of phenol by semiconducting mixed oxides derived from Zn(Ga)Al layered double hydroxides. Applied Catalysis B: Environmental 163, 352–360.
Photocatalytic degradation of phenol by semiconducting mixed oxides derived from Zn(Ga)Al layered double hydroxidesCrossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |

Rajbongshi BM, Samdarshi SK (2014). Cobalt-doped zincblende-wurtzite mixed-phase ZnO photocatalyst nanoparticles with high activity in visible spectrum. Applied Catalysis B: Environmental 144, 435–441.
Cobalt-doped zincblende-wurtzite mixed-phase ZnO photocatalyst nanoparticles with high activity in visible spectrumCrossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |

Sangeeta M, Karthi KV, Ravishankar R, Anantharaju KS, Nagabhushana H, Jeetendra K, Vidya YS, Renuka L (2017). Synthesis of ZnO, MgO and ZnO/MgO by solution combustion method: characterization and photocatalytic studies. Materials Today: Proceedings 4, 11791–11798.
Synthesis of ZnO, MgO and ZnO/MgO by solution combustion method: characterization and photocatalytic studiesCrossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |

Song H, Li C, Lou Z, Ye Z, Zhu L (2017a). Effective formation of oxygen vacancies in black TiO2 nanostructures with efficient solar-driven water splitting. ACS Sustainable Chemistry & Engineering 5, 8982–8987.
Effective formation of oxygen vacancies in black TiO2 nanostructures with efficient solar-driven water splittingCrossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |

Song H, Laudenschleger D, Carey JJ, Ruland H, Nolan M, Muhler M (2017b). Spinel-structured ZnCr2O4 with excess Zn is the active ZnO/Cr2O3 catalyst for high-temperature methanol synthesis. ACS Catalysis 7, 7610–7622.
Spinel-structured ZnCr2O4 with excess Zn is the active ZnO/Cr2O3 catalyst for high-temperature methanol synthesisCrossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |

Starukh G (2017). Photocatalytically enhanced cationic dye removal with Zn-Al layered double hydroxides. Nanoscale Research Letters 12, 391–398.

Tang Y, Zhou H, Zhang K, Ding J, Fan T, Zhang D (2015). Visible-light-active ZnO via oxygen vacancy manipulation for efficient formaldehyde photodegradation. Chemical Engineering Journal 262, 260–267.
Visible-light-active ZnO via oxygen vacancy manipulation for efficient formaldehyde photodegradationCrossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |

Venugopal A, Sarkari R, Anjaneyulu C, Krishna V, Kumar MK, Narender N, Padmasri AH (2014). Influence of acid-base sites on ZnO-ZnCr2O4 catalyst during dehydrocyclization of aqueous glycerol and ethylenediamine for the synthesis of 2-methylpyrazine: Kinetic and mechanism studies. Applied Catalysis A: General 469, 398–409.
Influence of acid-base sites on ZnO-ZnCr2O4 catalyst during dehydrocyclization of aqueous glycerol and ethylenediamine for the synthesis of 2-methylpyrazine: Kinetic and mechanism studiesCrossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |

Vines F, Lamiel-Garcia O, Illas F, Bromley ST (2017). Size dependent structural and polymorphic transitions in ZnO: from nanocluster to bulk. Nanoscale 9, 10067–10074.
Size dependent structural and polymorphic transitions in ZnO: from nanocluster to bulkCrossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |

Wang ZW, Lazor P, Saxena SK, Artioli G (2002). High-pressure Raman spectroscopic study of spinel (ZnCr2O4). Journal of Solid State Chemistry 165, 165–170.
High-pressure Raman spectroscopic study of spinel (ZnCr2O4)Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |

Waseem S, Anjum S, Mustafa L, Dar A, Bashir F, Zia R (2015). Effects of Cr and Fe co-doping on structural, optical, electrical and magnetic properties of titanium dioxide (TiO2). Materials Science Poland 33, 508–514.
Effects of Cr and Fe co-doping on structural, optical, electrical and magnetic properties of titanium dioxide (TiO2)Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |

Wu J, Luo C, Li D, Fu Q, Pan C (2017). Preparation of Au nanoparticle-decorated ZnO/NiO heterostructure via nonsolvent method for high-performance photocatalysis. Journal of Materials Science 52, 1285–1295.
Preparation of Au nanoparticle-decorated ZnO/NiO heterostructure via nonsolvent method for high-performance photocatalysisCrossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |

Xiao Z, Wang Y, Huang Y, Wei Z, Dong C, Ma J, Shen S, Li Y, Wang S (2017). Filling the oxygen vacancies in Co3O4 with phosphorus: an ultra-efficient electrocatalyst for overall water splitting. Energy & Environmental Science 10, 2563–2569.
Filling the oxygen vacancies in Co3O4 with phosphorus: an ultra-efficient electrocatalyst for overall water splittingCrossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |

Xie YP, Yang Y, Wang G, Liu G (2017). Oxygen vacancies promoted interfacial charge carrier transfer of CdS/ZnO heterostructure for photocatalytic hydrogen generation. Journal of Colloid and Interface Science 503, 198–204.
Oxygen vacancies promoted interfacial charge carrier transfer of CdS/ZnO heterostructure for photocatalytic hydrogen generationCrossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |

Yang R, Lu X, Huang X, Chen Z, Zhang X, Xu M, Song Q, Zhu L (2015). Bi-component Cu2O-CuCl composites with tunable oxygen vacancies and enhanced photocatalytic properties. Applied Catalysis B: Environmental 170–171, 225–232.
Bi-component Cu2O-CuCl composites with tunable oxygen vacancies and enhanced photocatalytic propertiesCrossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |

Yao Y, Guan L, Ma Y, Yao M (2017). Ce-S codoped TiO2-SiO2 composite nanocrystalline film with visible light photocatalytic activity. Journal of Materials Science Materials in Electronics 28, 3013–3019.
Ce-S codoped TiO2-SiO2 composite nanocrystalline film with visible light photocatalytic activityCrossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |

Zhang QY, Ashfaq JM, Hu BC, Wang JY, Zhou N (2016). Enhanced resonant Raman scattering and optical emission of ZnO/ZnMgO multiple quantum wells. Journal of Alloys and Compounds 680, 232–236.
Enhanced resonant Raman scattering and optical emission of ZnO/ZnMgO multiple quantum wellsCrossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |

Zhang T, Shen Y, Qin Y, Liu Y, Xiong R, Shi J, Wei J (2017). Facial Synthesis and Photoreaction Mechanism of BiFeO3/Bi2Fe4O9 Heterojunction Nanofibers. ACS Sustainable Chemistry & Engineering 5, 4630–4636.
Facial Synthesis and Photoreaction Mechanism of BiFeO3/Bi2Fe4O9 Heterojunction NanofibersCrossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |