Do observer fatigue and taxon bias compromise visual encounter surveys for small vertebrates?
Björn Lardner A , Amy A. Yackel Adams
B D , Adam J. Knox B C , Julie A. Savidge A and Robert N. Reed B
A Department of Fish, Wildlife and Conservation Biology, Colorado State University, Fort Collins, CO 80523, USA.
B U.S. Geological Survey, Fort Collins Science Center, 2150 Centre Avenue, Building C, Fort Collins, CO 80526, USA.
C Present address: Maui Invasive Species Committee, PO Box 983, Makawao, HI 96768, USA.
D Corresponding author. Email: yackela@usgs.gov
Wildlife Research 46(2) 127-135 https://doi.org/10.1071/WR18016
Submitted: 30 January 2018 Accepted: 4 November 2018 Published: 18 March 2019
Journal Compilation © CSIRO 2019 Open Access CC BY-NC-ND
Abstract
Context: Visual encounter surveying is a standard animal inventory method, modifications of which (e.g. distance sampling and repeated count surveys) are used for modelling population density. However, a variety of factors may bias visual survey counts.
Aims: The aim of the present study was to evaluate three observer-related biases: (1) whether fatigue compromises detection rate as a survey occasion progresses; (2) whether long-term fatigue or boredom compromise detection rates over the course of a survey period; and (3) whether observers exhibit biases in detection rates of different animal taxa.
Methods: We analysed >2.3 × 104 observations of lizards and small mammals from nocturnal pedestrian visual encounter surveys, each 4 h in duration, conducted by a pool of 29 observers, each of whom surveyed for up to 31 nights.
Key results: Detections of sleeping (diurnal) emerald tree skinks (Lamprolepis smaragdina) exhibited a small but statistically verified decline as the evening progressed, whereas detections of sleeping (diurnal) green anoles (Anolis carolinensis) increased as the evening progressed. Detections of nocturnal geckos (several species pooled) showed a weak and non-significant declining trend. Small mammal sightings (rats, shrews and mice pooled) declined strongly over the course of an evening. The participants saw greater or equal numbers of animals the more nights they surveyed. Most participants exhibited statistically significant, and often strong, taxonomic detection bias compared with the pool of peer observers. The skills of some observers appeared to be consistently above average; others consistently below average.
Conclusions: Data on sleeping lizards suggest that neither short-term nor long-term observer fatigue is of much concern for 4-h visual searches. On the contrary, differences among observers in taxonomic bias and overall detection skills pose a problem for data interpretation.
Implications: By comparing temporal detection patterns of immobile (e.g. sleeping) with actively moving animal taxa, sampling biases attributable to searcher fatigue versus the animals’ circadian rhythm can be disentangled and, if need be, statistically corrected for. Observer skill differences and observer-specific taxonomic biases may hamper efforts to statistically evaluate survey results, unless explicitly included as covariates in population models.
Additional keywords: applied ecology, conservation, invasive species, wildlife management.
References
Anderson, A. S., Marques, T. A., Shoo, L. P., and Williams, S. E. (2015). Detectability in audio-visual surveys of tropical rainforest birds: The influence of species, weather and habitat characteristics. PLoS One 10, e0128464.| Detectability in audio-visual surveys of tropical rainforest birds: The influence of species, weather and habitat characteristics.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 26147212PubMed |
Carlton, F. C. (1903). The color changes in the skin of the so-called Florida chameleon, Anolis carolinensis Cuv. Proceedings of the American Academy of Arts and Sciences 39, 259–276.
| The color changes in the skin of the so-called Florida chameleon, Anolis carolinensis Cuv.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Christy, M. T., Yackel Adams, A. A., Rodda, G. H., Savidge, J. A., and Tyrrell, C. L. (2010). Modelling detection probabilities to evaluate management and control tools for an invasive species. Journal of Applied Ecology 47, 106–113.
| Modelling detection probabilities to evaluate management and control tools for an invasive species.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Diefenbach, D. R., Brauning, D. W., and Mattice, J. A. (2003). Variability in grassland bird counts related to observer differences and species detection rates. The Auk 120, 1168–1179.
| Variability in grassland bird counts related to observer differences and species detection rates.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Foster, M. S., Guyer, C., and Donnelly, M. A. (2012). Standard techniques for inventory and monitoring. In ‘Reptile Biodiversity: Standard Methods for Inventory and Monitoring’. (Eds M. Foster, R. McDiarmid, M. Foster, C. Guyer, J. Gibbons and N. Chernoff.) pp. 205–272. (University of California Press: Oakland, CA.)
Fritts, T. H., and Rodda, G. H. (1998). The role of introduced species in the degradation of island ecosystems: a case history of Guam. Annual Review of Ecology and Systematics 29, 113–140.
| The role of introduced species in the degradation of island ecosystems: a case history of Guam.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Gordon, C., and Fox, W. (1960). The normal daily rhythm of color changes in the lizard, Anolis carolinensis, when exposed to the contrasting background color. Herpetologica 16, 233–235.
Henke, S. E. (1998). The effect of multiple search items and item abundance on the efficiency of human observers. Journal of Herpetology 32, 112–115.
| The effect of multiple search items and item abundance on the efficiency of human observers.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Kanary, L., Locke, A., and Watmough, J. (2010). Evaluating the effectiveness of SCUBA-based visual searches for an invasive tunicate, Ciona intestinalis, in a Prince Edward Island estuary. Aquatic Invasions 5, 41–47.
| Evaluating the effectiveness of SCUBA-based visual searches for an invasive tunicate, Ciona intestinalis, in a Prince Edward Island estuary.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Kleinholz, L. H. (1938). Studies in reptilian color changes. II. The pituitary and adrenal glands in the regulation of the melanophores of Anolis carolinensis. The Journal of Experimental Biology 15, 474–491.
Lardner, B., Savidge, J. A., and Rodda, G. H. (2007). Spotting cryptic animals in the dark: what light properties should a good headlamp have? In ‘Managing Vertebrate Invasive Species: Proceedings of an International Symposium’. (Eds G. W. Witmer, W. C. Pitt and K. A. Fagerstone.) pp. 234–245. (National Wildlife Research Center: Fort Collins, CO.)
Lardner, B., Rodda, G. H., Yackel Adams, A. A., Savidge, J. A., and Reed, R. N. (2015). Detection rates of geckos in visual surveys: turning confounding variables into useful knowledge. Journal of Herpetology 49, 522–532.
| Detection rates of geckos in visual surveys: turning confounding variables into useful knowledge.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Mahler, D. L. (2010). Natural history observations for two montane anole species from the Dominican Republic. Anolis Newsletter VI, 115–124.
Ransom, J. I. (2012). Detection probability in aerial surveys of feral horses. The Journal of Wildlife Management 76, 299–307.
| Detection probability in aerial surveys of feral horses.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Rodda, G. H. (1993). Where’s Waldo (and the snakes)? Herpetological Review 24, 44–45.
Rodda, G. H., and Fritts, T. H. (1992). Sampling techniques for an arboreal snake, Boiga irregularis. Micronesica 25, 23–40.
Rodda, G. H., Dean-Bradley, K., Campbell, E. W., Fritts, T. H., Lardner, B., Yackel Adams, A. A., and Reed, R. N. (2015). Stability of detectability over 17 years at a single site and other lizard detection comparisons from Guam. Journal of Herpetology 49, 513–521.
| Stability of detectability over 17 years at a single site and other lizard detection comparisons from Guam.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Smith, D. R., Reinecke, K. J., Conroy, M. J., Brown, M. W., and Nassar, J. R. (1995). Factors affecting visibility rate of waterfowl surveys in the Mississippi alluvial valley. The Journal of Wildlife Management 59, 515–527.
| Factors affecting visibility rate of waterfowl surveys in the Mississippi alluvial valley.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Stanford, J. W., and Rodda, G. H. (2007). The brown treesnake rapid response team. In ‘Managing Vertebrate Invasive Species: Proceedings of an International Symposium’. (Eds G. W. Witmer, W. C. Pitt and K. A. Fagerstone.) pp. 175–217. (National Wildlife Research Center: Fort Collins, CO.)
Stern, J. A., and Bynum, J. A. (1970). Analysis of visual search activity in skilled and novice helicopter pilots. Aerospace Medicine 41, 300–305.
| 5417370PubMed |
Thompson, A. A., and Mapstone, B. D. (1997). Observer effects and training in underwater visual surveys of reef fishes. Marine Ecology Progress Series 154, 53–63.
| Observer effects and training in underwater visual surveys of reef fishes.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Tyrrell, C. L., Christy, M. T., Rodda, G. H., Yackel Adams, A. A., Ellingson, A. R., Savidge, J. A., Dean-Bradely, K., and Bischof, R. (2009). Evaluation of trap capture in a geographically closed population of brown treesnakes on Guam. Journal of Applied Ecology 46, 128–135.
| Evaluation of trap capture in a geographically closed population of brown treesnakes on Guam.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
