Sympatric ray species show different temporal patterns for accessing provisioned food

Joni Pini-Fitzsimmons; Molly White; Nathan A. Knott; Culum Brown

doi:10.1071/WR24207

RESEARCH ARTICLE (Open Access)

Previous Next Contents Vol 52(6)

Sympatric ray species show different temporal patterns for accessing provisioned food

Joni Pini-Fitzsimmons

^A ^B ^* , Molly White ^C , Nathan A. Knott ^D and Culum Brown ^A

+ Author Affiliations

- Author Affiliations

^A School of Natural Sciences, Macquarie University, North Ryde, NSW, Australia.

^B Research Institute for the Environment and Livelihoods, Charles Darwin University, Darwin, NT, Australia.

^C School of Psychology, Charles Sturt University, Bathurst, NSW, Australia.

^D NSW Department of Primary Industries and Regional Development, Marine Ecosystems, Fisheries Research, Huskisson, NSW, Australia.

^* Correspondence to: joni.pini-fitzsimmons@mq.edu.au

Handling Editor: Charlie Huveneers

Wildlife Research 52, WR24207 https://doi.org/10.1071/WR24207

Submitted: 18 December 2024 Accepted: 16 May 2025 Published: 5 June 2025

© 2025 The Author(s) (or their employer(s)). Published by CSIRO Publishing. This is an open access article distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License (CC BY-NC-ND)

Abstract

Context

Food provisioning is widely used in elasmobranch tourism to elicit encounters between tourists and these typically elusive species. Wildlife tourism operations usually target a single species, although behavioural responses of these species often differ among provisioning locations. Likewise, provisioned foods are often consumed by multiple non-target species, which may also differ in their behavioural responses despite being exposed to the same provisioning event. Few studies have compared behaviour and movement patterns of multiple species in response to provisioning, particularly of those occupying similar niches.

Aims

This study aimed to compare the movement patterns of two sympatric ray species, the smooth stingray (Bathythosia brevicaudata) and the southern eagle ray (Myliobatis tenuicaudatus), around a site where they are fed as part of an unregulated but popular tourist attraction in south-eastern Australia.

Methods

Using passive acoustic telemetry, we compared the presence, duration of visits, and space use around the provisioning site for the two ray species.

Key results

Both species responded to provisioning at the site, but in different ways, suggesting different temporal use of the provisioning site (i.e. time-sharing). Southern eagle rays exhibited stronger attachment to the site, potentially indicating habituation to regular provisioning and a greater risk of being negatively affected than were smooth stingrays. Conversely, smooth stingrays appeared to focus their use of the site on periods of higher provisioning activity (i.e. daytime and on weekends) and may temporarily displace the smaller eagle rays during these times. Despite their attachment, both species made movements out of the study area, suggesting limited impacts on broader-scale behaviours.

Conclusions

Smooth stingrays and southern eagle rays exhibited distinct temporal patterns of site use in response to food provisioning, reflecting differences in their behavioural responses. These patterns suggest that even closely related and co-occurring species may adopt different approaches to accessing the same anthropogenic resource.

Implications

This research has highlighted the need for a broader approach to assessing and managing wildlife provisioning activities, that takes into account species-specific responses and interspecific interactions.

Keywords: acoustic telemetry, Batoidea, food provisioning, human-wildlife interactions, interspecific interactions, sympatric species, temporal space use, wildlife tourism.

References

Bates D, Mächler M, Bolker B, Walker S (2015) Fitting linear mixed-effects models using lme4. Journal of Statistical Software 67, 1-48.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |

Brena PF, Mourier J, Planes S, Clua E (2015) Shark and ray provisioning: functional insights into behavioral, ecological and physiological responses across multiple scales. Marine Ecology Progress Series 538, 273-283.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |

Bruce BD, Bradford RW (2013) The effects of shark cage-diving operations on the behaviour and movements of white sharks, Carcharodon carcharias, at the Neptune Islands, South Australia. Marine Biology 160, 889-907.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |

Brunnschweiler JM (2010) The Shark Reef Marine Reserve: a marine tourism project in Fiji involving local communities. Journal of Sustainable Tourism 18, 29-42.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |

Brunnschweiler JM, Barnett A (2013) Opportunistic visitors: long-term behavioural response of bull sharks to food provisioning in Fiji. PLoS ONE 8, e58522.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |

Brunnschweiler JM, Abrantes KG, Barnett A (2014) Long-term changes in species composition and relative abundances of sharks at a provisioning site. PLoS ONE 9, e86682.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |

Burgin S, Hardiman N (2015) Effects of non-consumptive wildlife-oriented tourism on marine species and prospects for their sustainable management. Journal of Environmental Management 151, 210-220.
| Crossref | Google Scholar | PubMed |

Cadwallader H (2020) The ecology of ray species in an urbanised estuary: seasonality, habitat use and pollutant exposure in Tauranga harbour. PhD thesis, the University of Waikato, New Zealand.

Campbell HA, Watts ME, Dwyer RG, Franklin CE (2012) V-Track: software for analysing and visualising animal movement from acoustic telemetry detections. Marine and Freshwater Research 63, 815-820.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |

Clarke CR, Lea JSE, Ormond RFG (2013) Changing relative abundance and behaviour of silky and grey reef sharks baited over 12 years on a Red Sea reef. Marine and Freshwater Research 64, 909-919.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |

Clua E, Buray N, Legendre P, Mourier J, Planes S (2011) Business partner or simple catch? The economic value of the sicklefin lemon shark in French Polynesia. Marine and Freshwater Research 62, 764-770.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |

Corcoran MJ, Wetherbee BM, Shivji MS, Potenski MD, Chapman DD, Harvey GM (2013) Supplemental feeding for ecotourism reverses diel activity and alters movement patterns and spatial distribution of the southern stingray, Dasyatis americana. PLoS ONE 8, e59235.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |

Crook KA, Sheaves M, Barnett A (2022) Species-specific foraging behaviors define the functional roles of sympatric stingrays. Limnology and Oceanography 67, 219-230.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |

DeLorenzo J, Techera EJ (2019) Ensuring good governance of marine wildlife tourism: a case study of ray-based tourism at Hamelin Bay, Western Australia. Asia Pacific Journal of Tourism Research 24, 121-135.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |

Dubois S, Fraser D (2013) A framework to evaluate wildlife feeding in research, wildlife management, tourism and recreation. Animals 3, 978-994.
| Crossref | Google Scholar | PubMed |

Dulvy NK, Fowler SL, Musick JA, Cavanagh RD, Kyne PM, Harrison LR, Carlson JK, Davidson LNK, Fordham SV, Francis MP, Pollock CM, Simpfendorfer CA, Burgess GH, Carpenter KE, Compagno LJV, Ebert DA, Gibson C, Heupel MR, Livingstone SR, Sanciangco JC, Stevens JD, Valenti S, White WT (2014) Extinction risk and conservation of the world’s sharks and rays. eLife 3, e00590.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |

Every SL, Fulton CJ, Pethybridge HR, Kyne PM, Crook DA (2019) A seasonally dynamic estuarine ecosystem provides a diverse prey base for elasmobranchs. Estuaries and Coasts 42, 580-595.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |

Ferguson AM, Harvey ES, Taylor MD, Knott NA (2013) A herbivore knows its patch: luderick, Girella tricuspidata, exhibit strong site fidelity on shallow subtidal reefs in a temperate marine park. PLoS ONE 8, e65838.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |

Fetterplace LC (2017) The ecology of temperate soft sediment fishes: implications for fisheries management and marine protected area design. PhD thesis, University of Wollongong.

Finger R, Lehmann N (2012) Modeling the sensitivity of outdoor recreation activities to climate change. Climate Research 51, 229-236.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |

Flávio H, Baktoft H (2020) actel: Standardised analysis of acoustic telemetry data from animals moving through receiver arrays. Methods in Ecology and Evolution 12, 196-203.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |

Flynn DJH, Lynch TP, Barrett NS, Wong LSC, Devine C, Hughes D (2018) Gigapixel big data movies provide cost-effective seascape scale direct measurements of open-access coastal human use such as recreational fisheries. Ecology and Evolution 8, 9372-9383.
| Crossref | Google Scholar | PubMed |

Gallagher AJ, Hammerschlag N (2011) Global shark currency: the distribution, frequency, and economic value of shark ecotourism. Current Issues in Tourism 14, 797-812.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |

Gallagher AJ, Vianna GMS, Papastamatiou YP, Macdonald C, Guttridge TL, Hammerschlag N (2015) Biological effects, conservation potential, and research priorities of shark diving tourism. Biological Conservation 184, 365-379.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |

Gaspar C, Chateau O, Galzin R (2008) Feeding sites frequentation by the pink whipray Himantura fai in Moorea (French Polynesia) as determined by acoustic telemetry. Cybium 32, 153-164.
| Google Scholar |

Guttridge TL, Myrberg AA, Porcher IF, Sims DW, Krause J (2009) The role of learning in shark behaviour. Fish and Fisheries 10, 450-469.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |

Hammerschlag N, Gallagher AJ, Wester J, Luo J, Ault JS (2012) Don’t bite the hand that feeds: assessing ecological impacts of provisioning ecotourism on an apex marine predator. Functional Ecology 26, 567-576.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |

Hammerschlag N, Skubel RA, Sulikowski J, Irschick DJ, Gallagher AJ (2018) A comparison of reproductive and energetic states in a marine apex predator (the Tiger Shark, Galeocerdo cuvier). Physiological and Biochemical Zoology 91, 933-942.
| Crossref | Google Scholar | PubMed |

Hartill BW (1989) The influence of behaviour on the distribution and abundance of Myliobatis tenuicaudatus. MSc thesis (Zoology), University of Auckland.

Healy TJ, Hill NJ, Barnett A, Chin A (2020) A global review of elasmobranch tourism activities, management and risk. Marine Policy 118, 103964.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |

Heinrich DDU, Vila Pouca C, Brown C, Huveneers C (2020) Effects of reward magnitude and training frequency on the learning rates and memory retention of the Port Jackson shark Heterodontus portusjacksoni. Animal Cognition 23, 939-949.
| Crossref | Google Scholar | PubMed |

Heinrich D, Dhellemmes F, Guttridge TL, Smukall M, Brown C, Rummer J, Gruber S, Huveneers C (2021) Short-term impacts of daily feeding on the residency, distribution and energy expenditure of sharks. Animal Behaviour 172, 55-71.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |

Hoenner X, Huveneers C, Steckenreuter A, Simpfendorfer C, Tattersall K, Jaine F, Atkins N, Babcock R, Brodie S, Burgess J, Campbell H, Heupel M, Pasquer B, Proctor R, Taylor MD, Udyawer V, Harcourt R (2018) Australia’s continental-scale acoustic tracking database and its automated quality control process. Scientific Data 5, 170206.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |

Huveneers C, Rogers PJ, Beckmann C, Semmens JM, Bruce BD, Seuront L (2013) The effects of cage-diving activities on the fine-scale swimming behaviour and space use of white sharks. Marine Biology 160, 2863-2875.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |

Jaine F, Jonsen I, Udyawer V, Dwyer R, Scales K, Maron-Perez F, Hoenner X, Huveneers C, Harcourt R (2021) remora: rapid extraction of marine observations for roving animals. Version 0.7.1. Available at https://imos-animaltracking.github.io/remora

Kendall MS, Williams BL, Winship AJ, Carson M, Grissom K, Rowell TJ, Stanley J, Roberson KW (2021) Winds, waves, warm waters, weekdays, and which ways boats are counted influence predicted visitor use at an offshore fishing destination. Fisheries Research 237, 105879.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |

Kinney MJ, Hussey NE, Fisk AT, Tobin AJ, Simpfendorfer CA (2011) Communal or competitive? Stable isotope analysis provides evidence of resource partitioning within a communal shark nursery. Marine Ecology Progress Series 439, 263-276.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |

Knip DM, Heupel MR, Simpfendorfer CA (2012) Habitat use and spatial segregation of adult spottail sharks Carcharhinus sorrah in tropical nearshore waters. Journal of Fish Biology 80, 767-784.
| Crossref | Google Scholar | PubMed |

Kranstauber B, Kays R, Lapoint SD, Wikelski M, Safi K (2012) A dynamic Brownian bridge movement model to estimate utilization distributions for heterogeneous animal movement. Journal of Animal Ecology 81, 738-746.
| Crossref | Google Scholar | PubMed |

Laroche RK, Kock AA, Dill LM, Oosthuizen WH (2007) Effects of provisioning ecotourism activity on the behaviour of white sharks Carcharodon carcharias. Marine Ecology Progress Series 338, 199-209.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |

Last P, White W, De Carvalho M, Séret B, Stehmann M, Naylor G (2016) ‘Rays of the world.’ (CSIRO Publishing: Melbourne, Vic, Australia)

Lenth RV (2024) emmeans: Estimated Marginal Means, aka Least-Squares Means. R package version 1.10.2. Available at https://CRAN.R-project.org/package=emmeans

Le Port A, Lavery S (2012) Population structure and phylogeography of the short-tailed stingray, Dasyatis brevicaudata (Hutton 1875), in the southern hemisphere. Journal of Heredity 103, 174-185.
| Crossref | Google Scholar | PubMed |

Le Port A, Lavery S, Montgomery JC (2012) Conservation of coastal stingrays: seasonal abundance and population structure of the short-tailed stingray Dasyatis brevicaudata at a marine protected area. ICES Journal of Marine Science 69, 1427-1435.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |

Lewis A, Newsome D (2003) Planning for stingray tourism at Hamelin Bay, Western Australia: the importance of stakeholder perspectives. International Journal of Tourism Research 5, 331-346.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |

Lynch TP, Foster S, Devine C, Hegarty A, Mcennulty F, Burton M, Lyle JM (2020) Trail camera video systems: investigating their utility in interpreting patterns of marine, recreational, trailer-boat fishers’ access to an offshore Marine Park in differing weather conditions. ICES Journal of Marine Science 77, 3110-3126.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |

Maljković A, Côté IM (2011) Effects of tourism-related provisioning on the trophic signatures and movement patterns of an apex predator, the Caribbean reef shark. Biological Conservation 144, 859-865.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |

Mcelroy WD, Wetherbee BM, Mostello CS, Lowe CG, Crow GL, Wass RC (2006) Food habits and ontogenetic changes in the diet of the sandbar shark, Carcharhinus plumbeus, in Hawaii. Environmental Biology of Fishes 76, 81-92.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |

Meyer CG, Dale JJ, Papastamatiou YP, Whitney NM, Holland KN (2009) Seasonal cycles and long-term trends in abundance and species composition of sharks associated with cage diving ecotourism activities in Hawaii. Environmental Conservation 36, 104-111.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |

Meyer L, Whitmarsh SK, Nichols PD, Revill AT, Huveneers C (2020) The effects of wildlife tourism provisioning on non-target species. Biological Conservation 241, 108317.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |

Mulder CK, Gerkema MP, Van der Zee EA (2013) Circadian clocks and memory: time–place learning. Frontiers in Molecular Neuroscience 6, 10.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |

Newsome D, Lewis A, Moncrieff D (2004) Impacts and risks associated with developing, but unsupervised, stingray tourism at Hamelin Bay, Western Australia. International Journal of Tourism Research 6, 305-323.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |

Niella Y, Flávio H, Smoothey AF, Aarestrup K, Taylor MD, Peddemors VM, Harcourt R (2020) Refined Shortest Paths (RSP): incorporation of topography in space use estimation from node-based telemetry data. Methods in Ecology and Evolution 11, 1733-1742.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |

Oro D, Genovart M, Tavecchia G, Fowler MS, Martínez-Abraín A (2013) Ecological and evolutionary implications of food subsidies from humans. Ecology Letters 16, 1501-1514.
| Crossref | Google Scholar | PubMed |

Pacoureau N, Rigby CL, Kyne PM, Sherley RB, Winker H, Carlson JK, Fordham SV, Barreto R, Fernando D, Francis MP, Jabado RW, Herman KB, Liu K-M, Marshall AD, Pollom RA, Romanov EV, Simpfendorfer CA, Yin JS, Kindsvater HK, Dulvy NK (2021) Half a century of global decline in oceanic sharks and rays. Nature 589, 567-571.
| Crossref | Google Scholar | PubMed |

Patroni J, Simpson G, Newsome D (2018) Feeding wild fish for tourism – a systematic quantitative literature review of impacts and management. International Journal of Tourism Research 20, 286-298.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |

Pini-Fitzsimmons J, Knott NA, Brown C (2018) Effects of food provisioning on site use in the short-tail stingray Bathytoshia brevicaudata. Marine Ecology Progress Series 600, 99-110.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |

Pini-Fitzsimmons J, Knott NA, Brown C (2023) Recreational fishery discard practices influence use of tidal estuary by a large marine mesopredator. Marine and Freshwater Research 74, 320-334.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |

Potter IC, Hyndes GA (1994) Composition of the fish fauna of a permanently open estuary on the southern coast of Australia, and comparisons with a nearby seasonally closed estuary. Marine Biology 121, 199-209.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |

R Core Team (2018) ‘R: a language and environment for statistical computing.’ (R Core Team)

Reebs SG (1993) A test of time-place learning in a cichlid fish. Behavioural Processes 30, 273-281.
| Crossref | Google Scholar | PubMed |

Richards K, O’Leary BC, Roberts CM, Ormond R, Gore M, Hawkins JP (2015) Sharks and people: insight into the global practices of tourism operators and their attitudes to shark behaviour. Marine Pollution Bulletin 91, 200-210.
| Crossref | Google Scholar | PubMed |

Rosenberger LJ (2001) Pectoral fin locomotion in batoid fishes: undulation versus oscillation. Journal of Experimental Biology 204, 379-394.
| Crossref | Google Scholar | PubMed |

Roycroft EJ, Le Port A, Lavery SD (2019) Population structure and male-biased dispersal in the short-tail stingray Bathytoshia brevicaudata (Myliobatoidei: Dasyatidae). Conservation Genetics 20, 717-728.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |

Shackley M (1998) ‘Stingray City’ – Managing the Impact of Underwater Tourism in the Cayman Islands. Journal of Sustainable Tourism 6, 328-338.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |

Silva S, Silva LF, Vieira A (2023) Protected areas and nature-based tourism: a 30-year bibliometric review. Sustainability 15, 11698.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |

Sulikowski JA, Wheeler CR, Gallagher AJ, Prohaska BK, Langan JA, Hammerschlag N (2016) Seasonal and life-stage variation in the reproductive ecology of a marine apex predator, the tiger shark Galeocerdo cuvier, at a protected female-dominated site. Aquatic Biology 24, 175-184.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |

Sunger N, Teske SS, Nappier S, Haas CN (2012) Recreational use assessment of water-based activities, using time-lapse construction cameras. Journal of Exposure Science & Environmental Epidemiology 22, 281-290.
| Crossref | Google Scholar | PubMed |

Swadling DS, Knott NA, Rees MJ, Pederson H, Adams KR, Taylor MD, Davis AR (2020) Seagrass canopies and the performance of acoustic telemetry: implications for the interpretation of fish movements. Animal Biotelemetry 8, 8.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |

Trave C, Brunnschweiler J, Sheaves M, Diedrich A, Barnett A (2017) Are we killing them with kindness? Evaluation of sustainable marine wildlife tourism. Biological Conservation 209, 211-222.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |

Trip Advisor Australia (2018) Bendalong Beach. Available at https://www.tripadvisor.com.au/Attraction_Review-g10850444-d4090710-Reviews-Bendalong_Beach-Bendalong_Shoalhaven_New_South_Wales.html [accessed 13 December 2019]

Udyawer V, Dwyer RG, Hoenner X, Babcock RC, Brodie S, Campbell HA, Harcourt RG, Huveneers C, Jaine FRA, Simpfendorfer CA, Taylor MD, Heupel MR (2018) A standardised framework for analysing animal detections from automated tracking arrays. Animal Biotelemetry 6, 17.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |

Vaudo JJ, Wetherbee BM, Harvey GCM, Harvey JC, Prebble AJF, Corcoran MJ, Potenski MD, Bruni KA, Leaf RT, Henningsen AD, Collie JS, Shivji MS (2018) Characterisation and monitoring of one of the world’s most valuable ecotourism animals, the southern stingray at Stingray City, Grand Cayman. Marine and Freshwater Research 69, 144.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |

Vianna GMS, Meekan MG, Pannell DJ, Marsh SP, Meeuwig JJ (2012) Socio-economic value and community benefits from shark-diving tourism in Palau: a sustainable use of reef shark populations. Biological Conservation 145, 267-277.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |

Wearmouth VJ, Sims DW (2008) Sexual segregation in marine fish, reptiles, birds and mammals: behaviour patterns, mechanisms and conservation implications. Advances in Marine Biology 54, 107-170.
| Crossref | Google Scholar | PubMed |

Werry JM, Clua E (2013) Sex-based spatial segregation of adult bull sharks, Carcharhinus leucas, in the New Caledonian great lagoon. Aquatic Living Resources 26, 281-288.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |