International Journal of Wildland Fire International Journal of Wildland Fire Society
Journal of the International Association of Wildland Fire
RESEARCH ARTICLE

Effectiveness of aerial seeding and straw mulch for reducing post-wildfire erosion, north-western Montana, USA

Amy H. Groen A and Scott W. Woods A B
+ Author Affiliations
- Author Affiliations

A The University of Montana, Department of Ecosystem and Conservation Sciences, 32 Campus Drive, Missoula, MT 59812, USA.

B Corresponding author. Email: scott.woods@cfc.umt.edu

International Journal of Wildland Fire 17(5) 559-571 https://doi.org/10.1071/WF07062
Submitted: 28 April 2007  Accepted: 15 October 2007   Published: 3 October 2008

Abstract

Various methods are available to reduce post-wildfire erosion, but there is limited quantitative information on the relative effectiveness of these techniques. We used rainfall simulations to compare the erosion and runoff rates from adjacent 0.5-m2 plots treated with aerial grass seeding and straw mulch with untreated control plots following the July 2002 Fox Creek Fire in north-west Montana. In the first summer after the fire, plots seeded at a rate of 9 kg ha–1 had a mean of less than 5% ground cover and the seeding treatment had no effect on the rainsplash erosion rate. In contrast, straw mulch application at a rate of 2.24 Mg ha–1 resulted in ~100% ground cover and an 87% reduction in rainsplash erosion relative to the control (P = 0.001). Measurements on a subset of the plots in the second summer after the fire indicated that ground cover in the treatments and the control averaged 39%, and neither treatment provided a significant increase in ground cover or reduction in erosion relative to the control. These results add to the growing weight of evidence that straw mulch application is highly effective in reducing erosion in the first year after fire, whereas grass seeding is often ineffective because of the limited increase in ground cover that it produces.

Additional keywords: burned area emergency response, erosion control, grass seeding, overland flow, post-fire rehabilitation, restoration, runoff.


Acknowledgements

Funding for the present research was provided by the Montana Water Resource Center through the United States Geological Survey’s 104(b) Water Resources Research program. Anna Birkas, Martin Twer and Mark Flatt assisted with field data collection. The comments of three anonymous reviewers and Dr David Affleck improved the manuscript.


References


Amaranthus MP (1989) Effect of grass seeding and fertilizing on surface erosion in two intensely burned sites in south-west Oregon. In ‘Proceedings of the Symposium on Fire and Watershed Management’. (Tech. Coord. NH Berg) USDA Forest Service, Pacific Southwest Forest and Range Experiment Station, General Technical Report PSW-109, pp. 148–150. (Berkeley, CA)

Arkell EE, Richards F (1986) Short duration rainfall relations for the western United States. In ‘Proceedings: Climate and water management: a critical era and conference on the human consequences of 1985’s climate’, 4–11 August 1986, Asheville, NC. pp. 136–141. (American Meteorological Society: Boston, MA)

Badía D , Martí C (2000) Seeding and mulching treatments as conservation measures of two burned soils in the central Ebro valley, NE Spain. Arid Soil Research and Rehabilitation  14, 219–232.
CrossRef |

Bautista S, Bellot J , Vallejo VR (1996) Mulching treatment for post-fire soil conservation in a semiarid ecosystem. Arid Soil Research and Rehabilitation  10, 235–242.


Benavides-Solorio J , MacDonald LH (2001) Post-fire runoff and erosion from simulated rainfall on small plots, Colorado Front Range. Hydrological Processes  15, 2931–2952.
CrossRef |

Benavides-Solorio J , MacDonald LH (2005) Measurement and prediction of post-fire erosion at the hillslope scale, Colorado Front Range. International Journal of Wildland Fire  14, 457–474.
CrossRef |

Benik SR, Wilson BN, Biesboer DD, Hansen B , Stenlund D (2003) Performance of erosion control products on a highway embankment. Transactions of the ASAE  46, 1113–1119.


Beyers JL (2004) Post-fire seeding for erosion control: effectiveness and impacts on native plant communities. Conservation Biology  18, 947–956.
CrossRef |

Biswell HH , Schultz AM (1965) Surface runoff and erosion as related to prescribed burning. Journal of Forestry  55, 372–373.


Bubenzer GD (1979) Rainfall characteristics important for simulation. In ‘Proceedings of the Rainfall Simulator Workshop’, Tucson, AZ. USDA Science and Education Administration, Agricultural Research, Western Region, Agricultural Reviews and Manuals ARM-W-10, pp. 22–34. (Oakland, CA)

Cerdà A (1999) Parent material and vegetation affect soil erosion in eastern Spain. Soil Science Society of America Journal  63, 362–368.


Cerdà A (2001) Effects of rock fragment cover on soil infiltration, interrill runoff and erosion European Journal of Soil Science  52, 59–68.
CrossRef |

Clark OR (1940) Interception of rainfall by prairie grasses, weeds, and certain crop plants. Ecological Monographs  10, 243–277.
CrossRef |

Dean AE (2001) Evaluating effectiveness of watershed conservation treatments applied after the Cerro Grande Fire, Los Alamos, New Mexico. MS thesis, University of Arizona, Tucson.

DeByle NV, Packer PE (1972) Plant nutrient and soil losses in overland flow from burned forest clearcuts. In ‘Proceedings: Watersheds in Transition’, 19–22 June 1972, Fort Collins, CO. (Eds S Csallary, T McClaughlin, W Striffler) Proceedings Series No. 14, pp. 296–307. (American Water Resources Association: Herndon, VA)

Ewing R (1996) Post-fire suspended sediment from Yellowstone National Park, Wyoming Water Resources Bulletin  32, 605–627.


Gedalof Z, Peterson DL , Mantua NJ (2005) Atmospheric, climatic, and ecological controls on extreme wildfire years in the north-western United States. Ecological Applications  15, 154–174.
CrossRef |

Gee GW, Bauder JW (1986) Particle size analysis. In ‘Methods of Soil Analysis: Part 1’. (Ed. A Klute) pp. 383–412. (American Society of Agronomy: Madison, WS)

Goldman SJ, Jackson K, Bursztynsky TA (1986) ‘Erosion and Sediment Control Handbook.’ (McGraw-Hill: New York)

Greene RSB, Kinnell PIA , Wood JT (1994) Role of plant cover and stock trampling on runoff and soil-erosion from semi-arid wooded rangelands. Australian Journal of Soil Research  32, 953–973.
CrossRef |

Gresswell RE (1999) Fire and aquatic ecosystems in forested biomes of North America. Transactions of the American Fisheries Society  128, 193–221.
CrossRef |

Hammer RB, Radeloff VC, Fried JS , Stewart SI (2007) Wildland–urban interface housing growth during the 1990s in California, Oregon, and Washington. International Journal of Wildland Fire  16, 255–265.
CrossRef |

Helvey JD (1980) Effects of a north central Washington wildfire on runoff and sediment production. Water Resources Bulletin  16, 627–634.


Insightful Corporation (2005) ‘S-PLUS Version 7.0 for Windows.’ (Insightful Corporation: Seattle, WA)

Johansen MP, Hakonsen TE , Breshears DD (2001) Post-fire runoff and erosion from rainfall simulation: contrasting forests with shrublands and grasslands. Hydrological Processes  15, 2953–2965.
CrossRef |

Keeley JE (2004) Ecological impacts of wheat seeding after a Sierra Nevada wildfire. International Journal of Wildland Fire  13, 73–78.
CrossRef |

Kershner JL, MacDonald L, Decker LM, Winters K (2003) Fire-induced changes in aquatic ecosystems. In ‘Hayman Fire Case Study Analysis’. (Ed. RT Graham) USDA Forest Service, Rocky Mountain Research Station, General Technical Report RMRS-GTR-114, pp. 232–243. (Fort Collins, CO)

Krammes JS, Hill LW (1963) ‘First aid’ for burned watersheds. USDA Forest Service, Pacific Southwest Forest and Range Experiment Station, Research Note PSW-29. (Berkeley, CA)

Krenitsky EC, Carroll MJ, Hill RL , Krouse JM (1998) Runoff and sediment losses from natural and man-made erosion control materials. Crop Science  38, 1042–1046.


Kruse R, Bend E , Bierzychudek P (2004) Native plant regeneration and introduction of non-natives following post-fire rehabilitation with straw mulch and barley seeding. Forest Ecology and Management  196, 299–310.
CrossRef |

Lal R (1994) ‘Soil Erosion Research Methods.’ 2nd edn. (Soil and Water Conservation Society: Ankeny, IO)

Legleiter CJ, Lawrence RL, Fonstad MA, Marcus WA , Aspinall R (2003) Fluvial response a decade after wildfire in the northern Yellowstone ecosystem: a spatially explicit analysis. Geomorphology  54, 119–136.
CrossRef |

Libohova Z (2004) Effects of thinning and a wildfire on sediment production rates, channel morphology, and water quality in the upper South Platte River watershed. MS thesis, Colorado State University, Fort Collins.

Loch RJ (2000) Effects of vegetation cover on runoff and erosion under simulated rain and overland flow on a rehabilitated site on the Meandu mine, Tarong, Queensland. Australian Journal of Soil Research  38, 299–312.
CrossRef |

Manly BFJ (2006) ‘Randomization, Bootstrap and Monte Carlo Methods in Biology.’ 3rd edn. (Chapman and Hall: Boca Raton, FL)

Meyer LD , Harmon WC (1979) Multiple intensity rainfall simulator for erosion research on row sideslopes. Transactions of the American Society of Agricultural and Biological Engineers  22, 100–103.


Meyer LD, Wischmeier WH , Foster GR (1970) Mulch rates required for erosion control on steep slopes. Soil Science Society of America Journal  34, 928–931.


Miles SR, Haskins DM, Darrel W (1989) Emergency rehabilitation: cost, risk and effectiveness. In ‘Proceedings of the Symposium on Fire and Watershed Management’. (Tech. Coord. NH Berg) USDA Forest Service, Pacific Southwest Forest and Range Experiment Station, General Technical Report PSW-109, pp. 97–103. (Berkeley, CA)

Miller JF, Frederick RH, Tracey RJ (1973) ‘Precipitation Frequency Atlas of the Western United States. Vol. I: Montana.’ NOAA Atlas 2. (National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration: Silver Springs, MD, USA)

Moody JA , Martin DA (2001) Initial hydrologic and geomorphic response following a wildfire in the Colorado Front Range. Earth Surface Processes and Landforms  26, 1049–1070.
CrossRef |

Morris SE , Moses TA (1987) Forest fire and natural soil erosion regime in the Colorado Front Range. Annals of the American Association of Geographers  77, 245–254.
CrossRef |

Neary DG, Ryan KC, DeBano LF (Eds) (2005) Wildland fire in ecosystems: effects of fire on soil and water. USDA Forest Service, Rocky Mountain Research Station, General Technical Report RMRS-GTR-42 Vol. 4. (Ogden, UT)

Ott L (1993) ‘An Introduction to Statistical Methods and Data Analysis.’ 4th edn. (Wadsworth Publishing Company: Belmont, CA, USA)

Parizek B, Rostagno CM , Sottini R (2002) Soil erosion as affected by shrub encroachment in north-eastern Patagonia. Journal of Range Management  55, 43–48.
CrossRef |

Renard KG, Foster GR, Weesies GA, McCool DK, Yoder DC (1997) ‘Predicting Soil Erosion by Water: a Guide to Conservation Planning with the Revised Universal Soil Loss Equation (RUSLE).’ USDA Agriculture Handbook 703. (Washington, DC)

Robichaud PR (2000) Fire effects on infiltration rates after prescribed fire in northern Rocky Mountain forests, USA. Journal of Hydrology  231–232, 220–229.
CrossRef |

Robichaud PR (2005) Measurement of post-fire hillslope erosion to evaluate and model rehabilitation treatment effectiveness and recovery. International Journal of Wildland Fire  14, 475–485.
CrossRef |

Robichaud PR, Brown RE (1999) What happened after the smoke cleared: onsite erosion rates after a wildfire in eastern Oregon. In ‘Proceedings of the Annual Summer Specialty Conference, Wildland Hydrology’, 30 June–2 July 1999, Bozeman, MT. pp. 419–426. (American Water Resources Association: Moscow, ID)

Robichaud PR, Beyers JL, Neary DG (2000) Evaluating the effectiveness of post-fire rehabilitation treatments. USDA Forest Service, Rocky Mountain Research Station, General Technical Report RMRS-GTR-63. (Fort Collins, CO)

Robichaud PR, MacDonald LH, Freeouf J, Neary D, Martin D (2003) Post-fire rehabilitation of the Hayman Fire. In ‘Hayman Fire Case Study Analysis’. (Ed. RT Graham) USDA Forest Service, Rocky Mountain Research Station, General Technical Report RMRS-GTR-114, pp. 293–313. (Fort Collins, CO)

Robichaud PR, Lillybridge TR , Wagenbrenner JW (2006) Effects of post-fire seeding and fertilizing on hillslope erosion in north-central Washington, USA. Catena  67, 56–67.
CrossRef |

Rough D (2007) Effectiveness of rehabilitation treatments in reducing post-fire erosion after the Hayman and Schoonover fires, Colorado Front Range. MS thesis, Colorado State University, Fort Collins.

Shakesby RA , Doerr SH (2006) Wildfire as a hydrological and geomorphological agent. Earth-Science Reviews  74, 269–307.
CrossRef |

Snelder DJ , Bryan RB (1995) The use of rainfall simulation tests to assess the influence of vegetation density on soil loss on degraded rangelands in the Baringo District, Kenya. Catena  25, 105–116.
CrossRef |

Spigel KM , Robichaud PR (2007) First-year post-fire erosion rates in the Bitterroot National Forest, Montana. Hydrological Processes  21, 998–1005.
CrossRef | CAS |

SPSS Inc. (1999) ‘SPSS for Windows, Release 10.0.5 (27 November 1999).’ (SPSS Inc.: Chicago, IL)

US General Accounting Office (2003) Wildland Fires: Better Information Needed on Effectiveness of Emergency Stabilization and Rehabilitation Treatments. US General Accounting Office, Report to Congressional Requestors GAO-03–430. (Washington, DC)

USDA (1980) ‘Soil Survey of Glacier County and Part of Ponderosa County, Montana.’ USDA Soil Conservation Service. (Washington, DC)

USDA (1994) ‘Soil Survey Manual.’ USDA Handbook No. 18. (Washington, DC)

USDA (1995) ‘Burned Area Emergency Rehabilitation Handbook.’ Ch. 20. USDA Forest Service, Forest Service Handbook FSH 2509.13–95–6. (Washington, DC)

Van de Water R (1998) Post-fire riparian zone management: the Salmon River experience. In ‘Proceedings, Nineteenth Annual Forest Vegetation Management Conference: Wildfire Rehabilitation’, 20–22 January 1998, Redding, CA. pp. 25–40. (Forest Vegetation Management Conference: Redding, CA, USA)

Wagenbrenner JW, MacDonald LH , Rough D (2006) Effectiveness of three post-fire rehabilitation treatments in the Colorado Front Range. Hydrological Processes  20, 2989–3006.
CrossRef |

Westerling AL, Gershunov A, Brown TJ, Cayan DR , Dettinger MD (2003) Climate and wildfire in the western United States. Bulletin of the American Meteorological Society  84, 595–604.
CrossRef |

Westerling AL, Hidalgo HG, Cayan DR , Swetnam TW (2006) Warming and earlier spring increase western US fire activity. Science  313, 940–943.
CrossRef | CAS | PubMed |

Wondzell SM , King JG (2003) Post-fire erosional processes in the Pacific Northwest and Rocky Mountain regions. Forest Ecology and Management  178, 75–87.
CrossRef |

Woods SW , Balfour V (2008) The effect of ash on runoff and erosion after a forest wildfire, Montana, USA. International Journal of Wildland Fire ,
CrossRef |



Export Citation Cited By (37)