Animal Production Science Animal Production Science Society
Food, fibre and pharmaceuticals from animals
RESEARCH ARTICLE

Understanding and promoting adoption of conservation practices by rural landholders

D. J. Pannell A F G , G. R. Marshall B , N. Barr C F , A. Curtis D , F. Vanclay E and R. Wilkinson C F
+ Author Affiliations
- Author Affiliations

A School of Agricultural and Resource Economics, University of Western Australia, Crawley, WA 6009, Australia.

B Institute for Rural Futures, University of New England, Armidale, NSW 2351, Australia.

C Department of Primary Industries, Bendigo, Vic. 3554, Australia.

D Faculty of Science and Agriculture, Charles Sturt University, Albury, NSW 2640, Australia.

E Tasmanian Institute of Agricultural Research, University of Tasmania, Hobart, Tas. 7001, Australia.

F Cooperative Research Centre for Plant-Based Management of Dryland Salinity, University of Western Australia, Crawley, WA 6009, Australia.

G Corresponding author. Email: david.pannell@uwa.edu.au

Australian Journal of Experimental Agriculture 46(11) 1407-1424 https://doi.org/10.1071/EA05037
Submitted: 14 February 2005  Accepted: 9 March 2006   Published: 9 October 2006

Abstract

Research on the adoption of rural innovations is reviewed and interpreted through a cross-disciplinary lens to provide practical guidance for research, extension and policy relating to conservation practices. Adoption of innovations by landholders is presented as a dynamic learning process. Adoption depends on a range of personal, social, cultural and economic factors, as well as on characteristics of the innovation itself. Adoption occurs when the landholder perceives that the innovation in question will enhance the achievement of their personal goals. A range of goals is identifiable among landholders, including economic, social and environmental goals. Innovations are more likely to be adopted when they have a high ‘relative advantage’ (perceived superiority to the idea or practice that it supersedes), and when they are readily trialable (easy to test and learn about before adoption). Non-adoption or low adoption of a number of conservation practices is readily explicable in terms of their failure to provide a relative advantage (particularly in economic terms) or a range of difficulties that landholders may have in trialing them.

Additional keywords: agriculture, economics, extension, innovation, learning, natural resource management, personality, policy, psychology, social issues, sociology, trials.


Acknowledgments

The authors are grateful for the reviewer comments received, and to Amabel Fulton and Sally Marsh for their detailed and insightful suggestions. Funders who have contributed directly or indirectly to the preparation of this review include Land and Water Australia, the Australian Research Council, Rural Industries Research and Development Corporation, Grains Research and Development Corporation, and the CRC for Plant-Based Management of Dryland Salinity.


References


Abadi Ghadim AK, Pannell DJ (1999) A conceptual framework of adoption of an agricultural innovation. Agricultural Economics 21, 145–154.
CrossRef |

Abadi Ghadim AK, Pannell DJ (2003) Risk attitudes and risk perceptions of crop producers in Western Australia. In ‘Risk management and the environment: agriculture in perspective’. (Eds BA Babcock, RW Fraser, JN Lekakis) pp. 113–133. (Kluwer: Dordrecht)

Abadi Ghadim AK, Pannell DJ, Burton MP (2005) Risk, uncertainty and learning in adoption of a crop innovation. Agricultural Economics 33, 1–9.
CrossRef |

Anderson AM (1979) ‘How advisors advise: agricultural extension as a social process.’ (Hawkesbury Agricultural College: Richmond)

Anderson AM (1981) ‘Farmers’ expectations and use of agricultural extension services.’ (Hawkesbury Agricultural College: Richmond)

Australian Bureau of Agricultural and Resource Economics (2003) Australian farm surveys report 2002. ABARE, Canberra.

Australian Bureau of Statistics (2002) Salinity on Australian farms. Report 4615.0, Australian Bureau of Statistics, Canberra.

Bardsley B (1982) ‘Farmers’ assessment of information and its sources.’ (School of Agriculture and Forestry, University of Melbourne: Melbourne)

Bardsley P, Harris M (1987) An approach to the econometric estimation of attitudes to risk in agriculture. Australian Journal of Agricultural Economics 31, 112–126.

Barr N (1994) Landcare from inside-out and outside in. Australian Farm Manager 5, 2–10.

Barr NF (1999) Salinity control, water reform and structural adjustment: the Tragowel Plains irrigation district. PhD thesis. Institute of Land and Food, University of Melbourne, Melbourne.

Barr N (2004) ‘The micro-dynamics of occupational and demographic change in Australian agriculture: 1976–2001.’ (Australian Bureau of Statistics: Canberra)

Barr N, Cary J (2000) ‘Influencing improved natural resource management on farms: a guide to factors influencing the adoption of sustainable natural resource management practices.’ (Bureau of Rural Sciences: Canberra)

Barr N, Wilkinson R (2005) Social persistence of plant-based management of dryland salinity. Australian Journal of Experimental Agriculture 45, 1495–1501.
CrossRef |

Black A (2000) Extension theory and practice: a review. Australian Journal of Experimental Agriculture 40, 493–502.
CrossRef |

Bond G, Wonder B (1980) Risk attitudes amongst Australian farmers. Australian Journal of Agricultural Economics 24, 16–34.

Cancian F (1979) ‘The innovator’s situation.’ (Stanford University Press: Stanford)

Carlson GA, Wetzstein ME (1993) Firm decisions and behavior in pest management on a regional level. In ‘Agricultural and environmental resource economics’. (Eds GA Carlson, D Zilberman, JA Miranowski) pp. 273–288. (Oxford University Press: Oxford)

Cary JW (1986) ‘Farmers’ attitudes to land management for conservation.’ (School of Agriculture and Forestry, University of Melbourne: Melbourne)

Cary JW (1993) The nature of symbolic beliefs and environmental behaviour in a rural setting. Environment and Behavior 25, 555–576.

Cary JW, Weston RE (1978) ‘Social stress in agriculture: the implications of rapid economic change.’ (School of Agriculture and Forestry, University of Melbourne: Melbourne)

Cary JW, Wilkinson RL (1997) Perceived profitability and farmers’ conservation behaviour. Journal of Agricultural Economics 48, 13–21.

Cary J, Webb T, Barr N (2001) ‘The adoption of sustainable practices: some new insights. An analysis of drivers and constraints for the adoption of sustainable practices derived from research.’ (Bureau of Rural Sciences: Canberra)

Cary J, Webb T, Barr N (2002) ‘Understanding landholders’ capacity to change to sustainable practices: insights about practice adoption and social capacity for change.’ (Bureau of Rural Sciences: Canberra)

Chamala S, Keith K (Eds) (1995) ‘Participative approaches for landcare.’ (Australian Academic Press: Brisbane)

Coughenour CM, Chamala S (2000) ‘Conservation tillage and cropping innovation: constructing the new culture of agriculture.’ (Iowa State University Press: Ames, IA)

Curtis AL (1997) Landcare, stewardship and biodiversity conservation. In ‘Frontiers in ecology: building the links’. (Eds NI Klomp, I Lunt) pp. 143–153. (Elsevier Science: Oxford)

Curtis A (2000) Landcare: approaching the limits of volunteer action. Australian Journal of Environmental Management 6, 26–34.

Curtis A, Byron I (2002) ‘Understanding the social drivers of catchment management in the Wimmera.’ (Charles Sturt University: Albury)

Curtis AL, De Lacy T (1996) Landcare in Australia: does it make a difference? Journal of Environmental Management 46, 119–147.
CrossRef |

Curtis A, Robertson A (2003) Understanding landholder management of river frontages: the Goulburn Broken. Ecological Management and Restoration 4, 45–54.
CrossRef |

Curtis A, MacKay J, Van Nouhuys M, Lockwood M, Byron I, Graham M (2000) Exploring landholder willingness and capacity to manage dryland salinity: the Goulburn Broken catchment. Johnstone Centre report no. 138. Charles Sturt University, Albury.

D’Emden FH, Llewellyn RS, Burton MP (2006) Adoption of conservation tillage in Australian cropping regions: an application of duration analysis. Technological Forecasting and Social Change 73, 630–647.
CrossRef |


Dong D, Saha A (1998) He came, he saw (and) he waited: an empirical analysis of inertia in technology adoption. Applied Economics 7, 893–905.

Duncan RC (1969) An investigation of the ‘trial’ stage in the adoption process: aerial topdressing in the Clarence Valley. Review of Marketing and Agricultural Economics 37, 207–216.

Feder G, Umali D (1993) The adoption of agricultural innovations: a review. Technological Forecasting and Social Change 43, 215–239.
CrossRef |

Feder G, Just R, Zilberman D (1985) Adoption of agricultural innovations in developing countries: a survey. Economic Development and Cultural Change 33, 255–297.
CrossRef |

Gasson R, Errington A (1993) ‘The farm family business.’ (CAB International: Wallingford)

George RJ, Nulsen RA, Ferdowsian R, Raper GP (1999) Interactions between trees and groundwaters in recharge and discharge areas – a survey of Western Australian sites. Agricultural Water Management 39, 91–113.
CrossRef |

Geroski P (2000) Models of technology diffusion. Research Policy 29, 603–625.
CrossRef |

Gibbs M, Lindner R, Fischer AJ (1987) The discovery of innovations by farmers. Journal of the Australian Institute of Agricultural Science 53, 254–261.

Goodwin BK, Schroeder TC (1994) Human capital, producer education programs, and adoption of forward-pricing methods. American Journal of Agricultural Economics 76, 936–947.
CrossRef |

Griliches Z (1957) Hybrid corn: an exploration in the economics of technological change. Econometrica 25, 501–523.
CrossRef |

Griliches Z (1960) Hybrid corn and economics of innovation. Science 132, 275–280.
CrossRef |


Guerin LJ, Guerin TF (1994) Constraints to the adoption of innovations in agricultural research and environmental management: a review. Australian Journal of Experimental Agriculture 34, 549–571.
CrossRef |

Hagerstrand T (1967) ‘Innovation diffusion as a spatial process.’ (The University of Chicago Press: Chicago, IL)

Havens AE, Rogers EM (1961) Adoption of hybrid corn: profitability and the interaction effect. Rural Sociology 26, 409–414.

Hawkins HS, Watson AS (1972) ‘Shelford: a preliminary report of a social and economic study of a Victorian soldier settlement area.’ (Agricultural Extension Research Unit, University of Melbourne: Melbourne)

Helms GL, Bailey D, Glover TF (1987) Government programs and adoption of conservation tillage practices on nonirrigated wheat farms. American Journal of Agricultural Economics 69, 786–795.
CrossRef |

Howden P, Vanclay F (2000) Mythologisation of farming styles in Australian broadacre cropping. Rural Sociology 65, 295–310.

Howden P, Vanclay F, Lemerle D, Kent J (1998) Working with the grain: farming styles amongst Australian broadacre croppers. Rural Society 8, 109–125.

Janis M, Mann L (1977) ‘Decision making: a psychological analysis of conflict, choice and commitment.’ (Macmillan: New York, NY)

Kaine GW, Lees JW (1994) Patterns in innovation: An analysis of the adoption of practices in beef cattle breeding. Occasional paper no. 190. Rural Development Centre, University of New England, Armidale.

Kaine G, Bewsell D, Boland A, Linehan C (2005) Using market research to understand the adoption of irrigation management strategies in the stone and pome fruit industry. Australian Journal of Experimental Agriculture 45, 1181–1187.
CrossRef |

Kebede Y (1992) Risk behavior and new agricultural technologies: the case of producers in the central highlands of Ethiopia. Quarterly Journal of International Agriculture 31, 269–284.

Kilpatrick S (2000) Education and training: impacts on farm management practice. Journal of Agricultural Education and Extension 7, 105–116.

Kington EA, Pannell DJ (2003) Dryland salinity in the upper Kent River catchment of Western Australia: Farmer perceptions and practices. Australian Journal of Experimental Agriculture 43, 19–28.
CrossRef |

Kingwell RS, Pannell DJ, Robinson SD (1993) Tactical responses to seasonal conditions in whole-farm planning in Western Australia. Agricultural Economics 8, 211–226.
CrossRef |

Kingwell R, Hajkowicz S, Young J, Patton D, Trapnell L, Edward A, Krause M, Bathgate A (2003) ‘Economic evaluation of salinity management options in cropping regions of Australia.’ (Grains Research and Development Corporation: Canberra)

Knowles M (1984) ‘The adult learner: a neglected species.’ (Gulf Publishing Company: Houston, TX)

Latta J (2002) ‘A survey of farming practices in the low rainfall Mallee Regions of New South Wales, South Australia and Victoria.’ (Department of Natural Resources and Environment: Walpeup)

Leathers HD, Smale M (1992) A Bayesian approach to explaining sequential adoption of components of a technological package. American Journal of Agricultural Economics 68, 519–527.

Lindner RK (1987) Adoption and diffusion of technology: an overview. In ‘Technological change in postharvest handling and transportation of grains in the humid tropics’. (Eds BR Champ, E Highley, JV Remenyi) pp. 144–151. (ACIAR Proceedings No. 19, Australian Centre for International Agricultural Research: Canberra)

Lindner RK, Pardey PG, Jarrett FG (1982) Distance to information source and the time lag to early adoption of trace element fertilizers. Australian Journal of Agricultural Economics 26, 98–113.

Llewellyn RS (2002) Adoption of integrated weed management by grain growers. PhD thesis, School of Agricultural and Resource Economics, University of Western Australia, Perth.

Llewellyn RS, Pannell DJ, Lindner RK, Powles SB (2005) Targeting key perceptions when planning and evaluating extension. Australian Journal of Experimental Agriculture 45, 1627–1633.
CrossRef |

Lockie S, Mead A, Vanclay F, Butler B (1995) Factors encouraging the adoption of more sustainable cropping systems in south-east Australia: profit, sustainability, risk and stability. Journal of Sustainable Agriculture 6, 61–79.

Lodge GM (1991) Management practices and other factors contributing to the decline in persistence of grazed lucerne in temperate Australia: a review. Australian Journal of Experimental Agriculture 31, 713–724.
CrossRef |

Makeham JP, Malcolm LR (1993) ‘The farming game now.’ (Cambridge University Press: Cambridge)

Marra M, Pannell DJ, Abadi Ghadim A (2003) The economics of risk, uncertainty and learning in the adoption of new agricultural technologies: where are we on the learning curve? Agricultural Systems 75, 215–234.
CrossRef |

Marsh SP (1998) What can agricultural researchers do to encourage the adoption of sustainable farming systems? SEA Working paper 98/05. Agricultural and Resource Economics, University of Western Australia, Perth. Available at http://www.crcsalinity.com.au/newsletter/SeaNews/dpap987f.htm (verified 21 September 2006)

Marsh SP, Pannell DJ (2000) Agricultural extension policy in Australia: the good, the bad and the misguided. Australian Journal of Agricultural and Resource Economics 44, 605–627.
CrossRef |

Marsh S, Pannell D, Lindner R (2000) The impact of agricultural extension on adoption and diffusion of lupins as a new crop in Western Australia. Australian Journal of Experimental Agriculture 40, 571–583.
CrossRef |

Marsh SP, Burton MP, Pannell DJ (2006) Understanding farmers’ monitoring of water tables for salinity management. Australian Journal of Experimental Agriculture 46, 1113–1122.
CrossRef |

Marshall GR (2004a) From words to deeds: enforcing farmers’ conservation cost-sharing commitments. Journal of Rural Studies 20, 157–167.
CrossRef |

Marshall GR (2004b) Farmers cooperating in the commons? A study of collective action in salinity management. Ecological Economics 51, 271–286.
CrossRef |

Marshall GR (2005) ‘Economics for collaborative environmental management: renegotiating the commons.’ (Earthscan Publications: London)

Mesiti L, Vanclay F (2006) Specifying the farming styles in viticulture. Australian Journal of Experimental Agriculture 46, 585–593.
CrossRef |

Miranowski JA, Carlson GA (1993) Agricultural resource economics: an overview. In ‘Agricultural and environmental resource economics’. (Eds GA Carlson, D Zilberman, JA Miranowski) pp. 3–27. (Oxford University Press: New York, NY)

Miranowski JA, Hrubovak J, Sutton J (1991) The effects of commodity programs on resource use. In ‘Commodity and resource policies in agricultural systems’. (Eds N Bockstael, R Just) pp. 275–292. (Springer-Verlag: New York, NY)

Mues C, Chapman L, Van Hilst R (1998) ‘Survey of Landcare and land management practices: 1992–93.’ (Australian Bureau of Agricultural and Resource Economics: Canberra)

Mullen JD, Vernon D, Fishpool KI (2000) Agricultural extension policy in Australia: public funding and market failure. Australian Journal of Agricultural and Resource Economics 44, 629–645.
CrossRef |

Nicoll R (1994) ‘Landholders’ knowledge and perceptions of dryland salinity control options in the Broadford and Kilmore shires.’ (Environmental Management Research Project, Deakin University: Melbourne)

Ohlmer B, Olson K, Brehmer B (1998) Understanding farmers’ decision making processes and improving managerial assistance. Journal of Agricultural Economics 18, 273–290.
CrossRef |

Ostrom E (1998) A behavioral approach to the rational choice theory of collective action. American Political Science Review 92, 1–22.
CrossRef |

Ostrom E, Gardner R, Walker J (1994) Regularities from the laboratory and possible explanations. In ‘Rules, games, and common-pool resources’, (Eds E Ostrom, R Gardner, J Walker) pp. 195–220. (University of Michigan Press: Ann Arbor, MI)

Pannell DJ (1996) Lessons from a decade of whole-farm modelling in Western Australia. Review of Agricultural Economics 18, 373–383.
CrossRef |

Pannell DJ (1999) Social and economic challenges in the development of complex farming systems. Agroforestry Systems 45, 395–409.
CrossRef |

Pannell DJ (2001a) Dryland salinity: economic, scientific, social and policy dimensions. The Australian Journal of Agricultural and Resource Economics 45, 517–546.
CrossRef |

Pannell DJ (2001b) Explaining non-adoption of practices to prevent dryland salinity in Western Australia: implications for policy. In ‘Land degradation’. (Ed. A Conacher) pp. 335–346. (Kluwer: Dordrecht)

Pannell DJ, McFarlane DJ, Ferdowsian R (2001) Rethinking the externality issue for dryland salinity in Western Australia. Australian Journal of Agricultural and Resource Economics 45, 459–475.
CrossRef |

Phillips TI (1985) The development of methodologies for the determination and facilitation of learning for dairy farmers. MAgSci thesis. School of Agriculture and Forestry, University of Melbourne, Melbourne.

Presser HA, Cornish JB (1968) ‘Channels of information and farmers’ goals in relation to the adoption of recommended practices: a survey in a dried fruit growing district.’ (University of Melbourne, School of Agriculture: Melbourne)

Rahm MR, Huffman WE (1984) The adoption of reduced tillage: the role of human capital and other variables. American Journal of Agricultural Economics 66, 405–412.
CrossRef |

Ransom K, Barr N (1994) The adoption of dryland lucerne in north-central Victoria. Research Report Series No. 151. Department of Agriculture, Melbourne.

Reeve I (2001) Australian farmers’ attitudes on rural environmental issues: 1991–2000. Report to Land and Water Australia. Institute for Rural Futures, University of New England, Armidale.

Reeve I, Frost L, Musgrave W, Stayner R (2002) Agriculture and natural resource management in the Murray Darling Basin: policy history and analysis. Report to the Murray Darling Basin Commission. Institute for Rural Futures, University of New England, Armidale.

Ridley AM, Pannell DJ (2005) The role of plants and plant-based R&D in managing dryland salinity in Australia. Australian Journal of Experimental Agriculture 45, 1341–1355.
CrossRef |

Rogers EM (1962) ‘Diffusion of innovations.’ (Free Press: New York, NY)

Rogers EM (2003) ‘Diffusion of innovations.’ 5th edn. (Free Press: New York, NY)

Röling NG (1988) ‘Extension science, information systems in agricultural development.’ (Cambridge University Press: Cambridge)

Ruttan VW (1996) What happened to technology adoption–diffusion research? Sociologia Ruralis 36, 51–73.

Shampine A (1998) Compensating for information externalities in technology diffusion models. American Journal of Agricultural Economics 80, 337–346.
CrossRef |

Shapiro BI, Brorsen BW, Doster DH (1992) Adoption of double-cropping soyabean and wheat. Southern Journal of Agricultural Economics 24, 33–40.

Shrapnel M (2002) ‘Bushies and cockies — beyond the myths: the personalities of our outback land managers.’ MSc thesis. University of Queensland, Brisbane.

Shrapnel M, Davie J (2001) The influence of personality in determining farmer responsiveness to risk. Journal of Agricultural Education and Extension 7, 167–178.

Sinden JA, King DA (1990) Adoption of soil conservation measures in Manilla Shire, New South Wales. Review of Marketing and Agricultural Economics 58, 179–192.

Sobels J, Curtis A, Lockie S (2001) The role of Landcare networks in rural Australia: exploring the contribution of social capital. Journal of Rural Studies 17, 265–276.
CrossRef |

Stoyles M (1992) ‘Cultural barriers to extension: results of a survey of the non English speaking background farmers in east Shepparton.’ (Ethnic Communications: Melbourne)

Tonks I (1983) Bayesian learning and the optimal investment decision of the firm. Economic Journal 93, 87–98.
CrossRef |

Tsur Y, Sternberg M, Hochman E (1990) Dynamic modelling of innovation process adoption with risk aversion and learning. Oxford Economic Papers 42, 336–355.

Vanclay F (1986) Socio-economic correlates of adoption of soil conservation technology. Master of Social Science thesis. Department of Anthropology and Sociology, University of Queensland, Brisbane.

Vanclay F (1992) The social context of farmers’ adoption of environmentally sound farming practices. In ‘Agriculture, environment and society: contemporary issues for Australia.’ (Eds G Lawrence, F Vanclay, B Furze) pp. 94–121. (Macmillan: Melbourne)

Vanclay F (1997) The social basis of environmental management. In ‘Critical landcare.’ (Eds S Lockie, F Vanclay) pp. 9–27. (Centre for Rural Social Research, Charles Sturt University: Wagga Wagga)

Vanclay F (2002) Conceptualising social impacts. Environmental Impact Assessment Review 22, 183–211.
CrossRef |

Vanclay F (2004) Social principles for agricultural extension to assist in the promotion of natural resource management. Australian Journal of Experimental Agriculture 44, 213–222.
CrossRef |

Vanclay F, Lawrence G (1995) ‘The environmental imperative.’ (Central Queensland University Press: Rockhampton)

Vanclay F, Lockie S (1993) ‘Barriers to the adoption of sustainable crop rotations.’ (Centre for Rural Social Research, Charles Sturt University: Wagga Wagga)

Vanclay F, Mesiti L, Howden P (1998) Styles of farming and farming subcultures: Appropriate concepts for Australian rural sociology? Rural Society 8, 85–107.

Vanclay F, Howden P, Mesiti L, Glyde S (2006) The social and intellectual construction of farming styles. Sociologia Ruralis 46, 61–82..
CrossRef |

Weston RE, Cary JW (1979) ‘A change for the better: stress, attitudes and decision making of dairy farmers 1976 to 1978.’ (School of Agriculture and Forestry, University of Melbourne: Melbourne)

Wiebers UC (1992) Economic and environmental effects of pest management information and pesticides: the case of processing tomatoes in California. PhD thesis. Tecnische Universität Berlin, Fachbereich Internationale Agrarentwicklung, Institue für Agrarbetriebs-Und Standortsokonomie.

Wilkinson RL (1989) ‘Stepwise adoption of a complex agricultural technology.’ MAgrSc thesis. University of Melbourne, Melbourne.

Wilkinson R, Cary J (1992) ‘Monitoring landcare in north central Victoria.’ (School of Agriculture and Forestry, University of Melbourne: Melbourne)

Wilkinson RL, Cary JW (1993) ‘Monitoring soilcare in north east Victoria.’ (School of Agriculture and Forestry, University of Melbourne: Melbourne)








Rent Article (via Deepdyve) Export Citation Cited By (449)

View Altmetrics