Relative salinity tolerance of freshwater macroinvertebrates from the south-east Eastern Cape, South Africa compared with the Barwon Catchment, Victoria, Australia
Ben J. Kefford A C , Carolyn G. Palmer B and Dayanthi Nugegoda A
A Biotechnology and Environmental Biology, School of Applied Science, RMIT University, PO Box 71, Bundoora, Vic. 3083, Australia.
B Unilever Centre for Environmental Water Quality, Institute for Water Research (IWR), Rhodes University, PO Box 94, Grahamstown, 6140, Eastern Cape, South Africa.
C Corresponding author. Email: email@example.com
Marine and Freshwater Research 56(2) 163-171 http://dx.doi.org/10.1071/MF04098
Submitted: 13 May 2004 Accepted: 3 February 2005 Published: 12 April 2005
Salinity is rising in many southern African and Australian rivers with unknown effects on aquatic organisms. The extent of spatial variation, at any scale, in salt tolerances of aquatic organisms is unknown, so whether data from one location is applicable elsewhere is also unknown. The acute tolerances (72-h median lethal concentration (LC50)) to sea salt of 49 macroinvertebrate taxa from the south-east Eastern Cape (SEEC), South Africa were compared with those of 57 species from the Barwon Catchment, Victoria, Australia. The mean LC50 values from both locations were similar (Barwon: 31 and SEEC: 32 mS cm-1) and less abundant (rare) taxa tended to be more tolerant than more abundant (common) taxa. There was, however, a greater range of LC50 values (5.5–76 mS cm-1) in the Barwon Catchment than in the SEEC (11–47 mS cm-1). The species sensitivity distribution (SSD) for SEEC taxa was bimodal whereas the Barwon Catchment’s SSD had a single peak. With few exceptions, members of an order had similar tolerances in both locations. The differences in SSD between locations were related to crustacean, odonate and non-arthropod relative richness. Although it is not ideal to extrapolate SSDs from one location to another, it may be reasonable to assume similar salinity tolerances among related taxa.
Extra keywords: acute salinity tolerance, ecotoxicity, rarity, stream invertebrates.
Aldenberg T.Slob W.1993Confidence limits of hazardous concentrations based on logistically distributed NOEC toxicity data.Ecotoxicology and Environmental Safety254863doi:10.1006/EESA.1993.1006
ASTM (1998). ‘Annual book of ASTM Standards, Water and Environmental Technology, Biological Effects and Environmental Fate, Biotechnology; Pesticides. Volume 11.05.’ (American Society for Testing and Materials: West Coshohocken, PA.)
Bayly I. A. E., and Williams W. D. (1973). ‘Inland Waters and their Ecology.’ (Longman Australia Pty Limited: Melbourne.)
Baskauf C. J.Eickmeier W. G.1994Comparative ecophysiology of a rare and a widespread species of Echinacea (Asteraceae).American Journal of Botany81958964
Berezina N. A.2003Tolerance of freshwater invertebrates to changes in water salinity.Russian Journal of Ecology34261266doi:10.1023/A:1024597832095
Brown J. H. (1995). ‘Macroecology.’ (Chicago University Press: Chicago, IL.)
Bruce R. D.1985An up-and-down procedure for acute toxicity testing.Fundamental and Applied Toxicology5151157doi:10.1016/0272-0590(85)90059-4
Bruce R. D.1987A confirmatory study of the up-and-down method for acute toxicity testing.Fundamental and Applied Toxicology897100doi:10.1016/0272-0590(87)90104-7
Cain S. A.1940Some observations on the concept of species senescence.Ecology21213215
Canale G., Papas P. J., Nicol M., Kefford B. J., Crowther D., and McKay S. (2001). Preliminary assessment of the health of the Barwon River catchment in the absence of saline water disposal. Department of Natural Resources and Environment, Melbourne.
Cao Y.Williams D. D.1999Rare species are important in bioassessment (Reply to comment by Marchant).Limnology and Oceanography4418411842
Cleavitt N. L.2002Stress tolerance of rare and common moss species in relation to their occupied environments and asexual dispersal potential.Journal of Ecology90785795doi:10.1046/J.1365-2745.2002.00713.X
Clemens H. P.Jones W. H.1954Toxicity of brine water from oil wells.Transactions of the American Fisheries Society8497109
Dallas H. F., and Day J. A. (1993). The effect of water quality variables on riverine ecosystems: a review. Report no TT 61/93. Water Research Commission of South Africa, Pretoria.
Day J. A., Stewart B. A., de Moor I. L., and Louw A. E. (2001). Guides to the freshwater invertebrates of southern Africa, Volume 4: Crustacea. Report no TT 141/01. Water Research Commission of South Africa, Pretoria.
DWA (1986). Management of the Water Resources of the Republic of South Africa. Department of Water Affairs, Pretoria, South Africa.
Forbes A. T.Allanson B. R.1970aEcology of the Sundays River Part II. Osmoregulation in some mayfly nymphs (Ephemeroptera: Baetidae).Hydrobiologia36489503doi:10.1007/BF00039802
Forbes A. T.Allanson B. R.1970bEcology of the Sundays River Part I. Water chemistry.Hydrobiologia36479488doi:10.1007/BF00039801
Forbes V. E.Calow P.2002Species sensitivity distributions revisited: a critical appraisal.Human and Ecological Risk Assessment8473492
Gaston K. J. (1994). ‘Rarity.’ (Chapman & Hall: London.)
Goetsch P. A.Palmer C. G.1997Salinity tolerance of selected macroinvertebrates of the Sabie River, Kruger National Park, South Africa.Archives of Environmental Contamination and Toxicology323241doi:10.1007/S002449900152
Gordon N. D., McMahon T. A., and Finlayson B. L. (1992). ‘Stream Hydrology: An Introduction for Ecologists.’ (John Wiley & Sons: West Sussex.)
Gray J. S. (1981). ‘The Ecology of Marine Sediments: An Introduction to the Structure and Function of Benthic Communities.’ (Cambridge University Press: Cambridge.)
Greulich S.Bornette G.Amoros C.Roelofs J. G. M.2000Investigation on the fundamental niche of a rare species: an experiment on establishment of Luronium natans.Aquatic Botany66209224doi:10.1016/S0304-3770(99)00073-X
Haigh E. H., and Davies-Coleman H. (1999). The development of a production facility for standard laboratory test organisms for ecotoxicological research. Report no 755/1/99. Water Research Commission of South Africa, Pretoria.
Hamilton S. J.1995Hazard assessment of inorganics to three endangered fish in the Green River, Utah.Ecotoxicology and Environmental Safety30134142doi:10.1006/EESA.1995.1017
Hart B.Bailey P.Edwards P.Hortle K.James K.McMahon A.Meredith C.Swadling K.1991A review of salt sensitivity of Australian freshwater biota.Hydrobiologia210105144
Hodgson J. G.1986Commonness and rarity in plants with special reference to the Sheffield flora Part II: the relative importance of climate, soil and land use.Biological Conservation36253274doi:10.1016/0006-3207(86)90053-4
Hodgson J. G.1993Commonness and rarity in British butterflies.Journal of Applied Ecology30407427
Kay W. R.Halse S. A.Scanlon M. D.Smith W. J.2001Distribution and environmental tolerances of aquatic macroinvertebrate families in the agricultural zone of southwestern Australia.Journal of the North American Bentholigcal Society20182199
Kefford B. J.1998The relationship between electrical conductivity and selected macroinvertebrate communities in four river systems of south-west Victoria, Australia.International Journal of Salt Lake Research7153170doi:10.1023/A:1009019404720
Kefford B. J.2000The effect of saline water disposal: implications for monitoring programs and management.Environmental Monitoring and Assessment63313327doi:10.1023/A:1006201512469
Kefford B. J.Nugegoda D.2005Lack of critical salinity thresholds: effects of salinity on growth and reproduction of the freshwater snail Physa acuta.Environmental Pollution134377383doi:10.1016/J.ENVPOL.2004.09.018
Kefford B. J.Papas P. J.Nugegoda D.2003Relative salinity tolerance of macroinvertebrates from the Barwon River, Victoria, Australia.Marine and Freshwater Research54755765doi:10.1071/MF02081
Kefford B. J.Papas P. J.Metzeling L.Nugegoda D.2004aDo laboratory salinity tolerances of freshwater animals correspond with their field salinity?Environmental Pollution129355362doi:10.1016/J.ENVPOL.2003.12.005
Kefford B. J.Dalton A.Palmer C. J.Nugegoda D.2004bThe salinity tolerance of eggs and hatchlings of selected aquatic macroinvertebrates in south-east Australia and South Africa.Hydrobiologia517179192doi:10.1023/B:HYDR.0000027346.06304.BC
Kefford B. J.Palmer C. G.Pakhomova L.Nugegoda D.2004cComparing different approaches to measuring the salinity tolerance of freshwater invertebrates.Water SA30499506
Knowles J. N.Williams W. D.1973Salinity range and osmoregulatory ability of Corixids (Hemiptera: Heteroptera) in south-east Australian inland waters.Australian Journal of Marine and Freshwater Research24297302
Marchant R.1999How important are rare species in aquatic community ecology and bioassessment? A comment on the conclusions of Cao et al.Limnology and Oceanography4418401841
Marchant R.2002Do rare species have any place in multivariate analysis for bioassessment?Journal of the North American Bentholigcal Society21311313
McMahon R. F.2002Evolutionary and physiological adaptations of aquatic invasive animals: r-selection versus resistance.Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences5912351244doi:10.1139/F02-105
MDBMC (1987). Salinity and drainage strategy background paper. Murray–Darling Basin Ministerial Council, Background Paper No. 87/1. Commonwealth, NSW, VIC, SA, QLD and ACT governments, Australia.
MDBMC (1999). The salinity audit of the Murray–Darling Basin. A 100-year perspective 1999. Murray–Darling Basin Ministerial Council. Commonwealth, NSW, VIC, SA, QLD and ACT governments, Australia.
Metzeling L.1993Benthic macroinvertebrates community structure in streams of different salinities.Australian Journal of Marine and Freshwater Research44335351
Nielsen D. L., and Hillman T. J. (2000). Ecological effects of dryland salinity on aquatic ecosystems. Technical Report 4/2000. Cooperative Research Centre for Freshwater Ecology, Albury.
OECD (1996). ‘Guidelines for Testing of Chemicals.’ (Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development: Paris.)
O’Keeffe J. H.de Moor F. C.1988Changes in the physico-chemistry and benthic invertebrates of the Great Fish River, South Africa, following an interbasin transfer of water. Regulated RiversResearch Management23955
Palmer C.Palmer A.O’Keeffe J.Palmer R.1994Macroinvertebrate community structure and altitudinal changes in the upper reaches of a warm temperate southern African river.Freshwater Biology32337347
Palmer C. G.O’Keeffe J. H.1991Are macroinvertebrates assemblages in the Buffalo River, southern Africa, associated with particular biotopes?Journal of the North American Benthological Society10349357
Palmer R. W.O’Keeffe J. H.1990Downstream effects of a small impoundment on a turbid river.Archives fur Hydrobiologia119457473
Sappington L. C.Mayer F. L.Dwyer F. J.Buckler D. R.Jones J. R.Ellersieck M. R.2001Contaminant sensitivity of threatened and endangered fishes compared to standard surrogate species.Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry2028692876doi:10.1897/1551-5028(2001)020<2869:CSOTAE>2.0.CO;2
Shirgur G. A.Kewalramani H. G.1973Observations of salinity and temperature tolerance of some of the freshwater insects.The Journal of Biological Sciences164252
Smith P. J. (2002). ‘Analysis of Failure and Survival Data.’ (Chapman & Hall: Boca Raton, FL.)
Solomon K.Giesy J.Jones P.2000Probabilistic risk assessment of agrochemical in the environment.Crop Protection19649655doi:10.1016/S0261-2194(00)00086-7
Williams W. D.1987Salinization of rivers and streams: an important environmental hazard.Ambio16180185
Williams W. D.Taaffe R. G.Boulton A. J.1991Longitudinal distribution of macroinvertebrates in two rivers subject of salinization.Hydrobiologia210151160