Marine and Freshwater Research Marine and Freshwater Research Society
Advances in the aquatic sciences
REVIEW

Defining and using ‘best available science’: a policy conundrum for the management of aquatic ecosystems

Darren S. Ryder A D , Moya Tomlinson A , Ben Gawne B and Gene E. Likens C

A School of Environmental and Rural Science, University of New England, Armidale, NSW 2350, Australia.

B Murray Darling Freshwater Research Centre, Latrobe University, PO Box 991, Wodonga, Vic. 3691, Australia.

C Cary Institute of Ecosystem Studies, Box AB, Millbrook, NY 12545-0129, USA.

D Corresponding author. Email: darren.ryder@une.edu.au

Marine and Freshwater Research 61(7) 821-828 http://dx.doi.org/10.1071/MF10113
Submitted: 25 May 2010  Accepted: 24 June 2010   Published: 23 July 2010

Abstract

Integrative research has been the dominant theme in this Special Issue, demonstrated by contemporary examples of effective collaborations and solutions for the successful engagement of scientists in the policy and management arena. Evident in these papers is the increasing use of the term ‘best available science’ (BAS) as a basis for well-informed resource management decisions. The term is used to engender credibility and trust among stakeholders and promotes greater awareness, communication, involvement, transparency and understanding among research, policy and management communities. However, there remains no clear statement of the properties of BAS or guidance on its practical application in the decision-making process. We define the attributes that underpin BAS and examine the issues of uncertainty, risk and communication as key challenges to successful integrative management. We advocate an interdisciplinary process that facilitates understanding of discipline-based knowledge structures, articulates uncertainty and risk about the scientific information, and promotes engagement and trust among the generators and users of information. Ultimately, successful management of aquatic ecosystems will rely on scientists, managers and decision makers who have the skills and courage to apply the best science available and not wait for the best science possible.

Additional keywords: environmental risk, interdisciplinary, knowledge exchange, scientific uncertainty, water resource management.


References

Allan C.Curtis A.2005Nipped in the bud: why regional scale adaptive management is not blooming.Environmental Management36414425doi:10.1007/S00267-004-0244-1

Allan C., and Stankey G. H. (2009). ‘Adaptive Environmental Management: A Practitioner’s Guide.’ (CSIRO Publishing: Melbourne.)

Allan C., Watts R. J., Commens S., and Ryder D. S. (2009). Using adaptive management to meet multiple goals for flows along the Mitta Mitta River in south eastern Australia. In ‘Adaptive Environmental Management: A Practitioner’s Guide’. (Eds C. Allan and G. H. Stankey.) pp. 57–81. (CSIRO Publishing: Melbourne.)

ARMCANZ/ANZECC (1996). National principles for the provision of water for ecosystems. Sustainable Land and Water Resources Management Committee Subcommittee on Water Resources Occasional Paper SWR No 3. Land and Water Australia, Canberra.

Benda L. E.Poff N. L.Tague C.Palmer M. A.Pizzuto J.et al.2002How to avoid train wrecks when using science in environmental problem solving.BioScience5211271136doi:10.1641/0006-3568(2002)052[1127:HTATWW]2.0.CO;2

Bisbal G.2002The best available science for the management of anadromous salmonids in the Columbia River Basin.Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences5919521959doi:10.1139/F02-157

Bogert L. M.1994That’s my story and I’m stickin’ to it: is the “best available” science any available science under the Endangered Species Act?Idaho Law Review3185150

Bohnet I. C.Kinjun C.2009Community uses and values of water informing water quality improvement planning: a study from the Great Barrier Reef region, Australia.Marine and Freshwater Research6011761182
doi:10.1071/MF08329

Boulton A. J., Piégay H., and Sanders M. (2008). Turbulence and train wrecks: using knowledge strategies to enhance the application of integrative river science to effective river management. In ‘River Futures: An Integrative Scientific Approach to River Repair’. (Eds G. J. Brierley and K. A. Fryirs.) pp. 28–39. (Island Press: Washington, DC.)

Bradshaw G. A., and Borchers G. (2000). Uncertainty as information: narrowing the science-policy gap. Conservation Ecology 4, 7. Available at http://www.consecol.org/vol4/iss1/art7/ [Accessed 22 June 2010].

Brennan M. J.Roth D. E.Feldman M. D.Greene A. R.2003Square pegs and round holes: Application of the “best available scientific data available” standard in the Endangered Species Act.Tullane Environmental Law Journal16386444

Briggs S. V.2006Integrating policy and science in natural resources: Why so difficult?Ecological Management & Restoration73739
doi:10.1111/J.1442-8903.2006.00245.X

Carpenter S. R., Pingali P. L., Bennett E. M., and Zurek M. B. (2005). ‘Ecosystems and Human Well-Being: Scenarios, Volume 2.’ (Island Press: Washington.)

Clark M.2002Dealing with uncertainty: adaptive approaches to sustainable river management.Aquatic Conservation: Marine & Freshwater Ecosystems12347363doi:10.1002/AQC.531

Commonwealth of Australia (2004). Intergovernmental agreement on a National Water Initiative. Council of Australian Governments, Canberra.

Cullen P.1990The turbulent boundary between water science and water management.Freshwater Biology24201209doi:10.1111/J.1365-2427.1990.TB00319.X

Cullen P. (2006). Science and politics – speaking truth to power. North American Benthological Society Conference, Anchorage, Alaska. Available at http://www.wentworthgroup.org/docs/Speaking_Truth_To_Power1.pdf [Accessed 22 June 2010].

Cullen P.Norris R. H.Resh V. H.Reynoldson T. B.Rosenberg D. M.et al.1999Collaboration in scientific research: a critical need for freshwater ecology.Freshwater Biology42131142doi:10.1046/J.1365-2427.1999.00447.X

Davies P. E.Harris J. H.Hillman T. J.Walker K. F.2010The Sustainable Rivers Audit: assessing river ecosystem health in the Murray–Darling Basin, Australia.Marine and Freshwater Research61764777doi:10.1071/MF09043

Doremus H.2004The purposes, effects, and future of the Endangered Species Act’s best available science mandate.Environmental Law (Northwestern School of Law)34397450

Durant R. F.Legge J. S.2006Wicked problems, public policy, and administrative theory – lessons from the GM food regulatory arena.Administration & Society38309334
doi:10.1177/0095399706289713

Eberhard R.Robinson C. J.Waterhouse J.Parslow J.Hart B.et al.2009Adaptive management for water quality planning – from theory to practice.Marine and Freshwater Research6011891195doi:10.1071/MF08347

Francis T. B.Whittaker K. A.Shandas V.Mills A. V.Graybill J. K.2005Incorporating science into the environmental policy process: A case study from Washington State.Ecology and Society103552

Freeman D. M.2000Wicked water problems: sociology and local water organizations in addressing water resources policy.Journal of the American Water Resources Association36483491
doi:10.1111/J.1752-1688.2000.TB04280.X

Gardner A., and Bowmer K. H. (2007). Environmental water allocations and their governance. In ‘Managing Water for Australia: The Social and Institutional Challenges’. (Eds K. Hussey and S. Dovers.) pp. 43–57. (CSIRO Publishing: Melbourne.)

Gawne B.Crase L.Watson A. S.2010Can a collaborative focus on solutions improve our capacity to achieve sustainable water management?Marine and Freshwater Research61814820doi:10.1071/MF09075

Gleick P. H.Adams R. M.Amasino R. M.Anders E.Anderson D. J.et al.2010Climate change and the integrity of science.Science328689690doi:10.1126/SCIENCE.328.5979.689

Hamstead M. (2009). Improving environmental sustainability in water planning. Waterlines report no. 20, National Water Commission, Canberra. Available at http://www.nwc.gov.au/www/html/592-water-allocation-planning-in-australia-current-practices-and-lessons-learned-no-6.asp?intSiteID=1 [Accessed 22 June 2010].

Hanssen L., Rouwette E., and van Katwijk M. M. (2009). The role of ecological science in environmental policy making: from a pacification toward a facilitation strategy. Ecology and Society 14. Available at http://www.ecologyandsociety.org/vol14/iss1/art43/ [Accessed 22 June 2010].

Hardin G.1968The tragedy of the commons.Science16212431248doi:10.1126/SCIENCE.162.3859.1243

Hart D. D.Calhoun A. J. K.2010Rethinking the role of ecological research in the sustainable management of freshwater ecosystems.Freshwater Biology55258269doi:10.1111/J.1365-2427.2009.02370.X

Hillman M.Brierley G.2002Information needs for environmental-flow allocation: A case study from the Lachlan River, New South Wales, Australia.Annals of the Association of American Geographers92617630doi:10.1111/1467-8306.00307

Hillman T.Crase L.Furze B.Ananda J.Maybery D.2005Multidisciplinary approaches to natural resource management.Hydrobiologia55299108doi:10.1007/S10750-005-1508-3

Holling C. S. (1998). Two cultures of ecology. Conservation Ecology 2, 4. Available at http://www.consecol.org/vol2/iss2/art4/ [Accessed 22 June 2010].

Holmes J.Clark R.2008Enhancing the use of science in environmental policy-making and regulation.Environmental Science & Policy11702711doi:10.1016/J.ENVSCI.2008.08.004

Johnson P. A.Brown E. R.2001Incorporating uncertainty in the design of stream channel modifications.Journal of the American Water Resources Association3712251236doi:10.1111/J.1752-1688.2001.TB03634.X

Koehler B.Koontz T. M.2008Citizen partnerships in collaborative watershed partnerships.Environmental Management41143154doi:10.1007/S00267-007-9040-Z

Kroon F. J.Robinson C. J.Dale A. P.2009Integrating knowledge to inform water quality planning in the Tully-Murray basin, Australia.Marine and Freshwater Research6011831188doi:10.1071/MF08349

Ladson A. R.White L. J.Doolan J. A.Finlayson B. L.Hart B. T.et al.1999Development and testing of an Index of Stream Condition for waterway management in Australia.Freshwater Biology41453468doi:10.1046/J.1365-2427.1999.00442.X

Lagacé E.Holmes J.McDonnell R.2008Science-policy guidelines as a benchmark: making the European Water Framework Directive.Area40421434doi:10.1111/J.1475-4762.2008.00836.X

Lake P. S.Bond N.Reich P.2007Linking ecological theory with stream restoration.Freshwater Biology52597615doi:10.1111/J.1365-2427.2006.01709.X

Lefroy E. C., and Pollino C. A. (2009). Using the simplicity cycle in model building. 18th World IMACS/MODSIM Congress, Cairns, Australia. Available at http://mssanz.org.au/modsim09 [Accessed 22 June 2010].

Likens G. E. (1992). ‘The Ecosystem Approach: Its Use and Abuse.’ (Ecology Institute: Oldendorf/Luhe, Germany.)

Likens G. E. (2010). The role of science in decision making: Is anybody listening? Frontiers in Ecology and the Environment, in press.

Likens G. E.Walker K. F.Davies P. E.Brookes J.Olley O.et al.2009Ecosystem science: toward a new paradigm for managing Australia’s inland aquatic ecosystems.Marine and Freshwater Research60271279doi:10.1071/MF08188

Lindenmayer D.Likens G. E.2009Adaptive monitoring: a new paradigm for long-term research and monitoring.Trends in Ecology & Evolution24482486doi:10.1016/J.TREE.2009.03.005

Ludwig D. M.Mangel G.Haddad B.2001Ecology, conservation and public policy.Annual Review of Ecology and Systematics32481517doi:10.1146/ANNUREV.ECOLSYS.32.081501.114116

McGarvey D. J.2007Merging precaution with sound science under the Endangered Species Act.BioScience576570doi:10.1641/B570110

Mills A.Francis T.Shandas V.Whittaker K.Graybill J. K.2009Using best available science to protect critical areas in Washington state: Challenges and barriers to planners.Urban Ecosystems12157175doi:10.1007/S11252-008-0071-X

Milne B. T.1998Motivation and benefits of complex systems approaches in ecology.Ecosystems1449456doi:10.1007/S100219900040

Moore S. A.Wallington T. J.Hobbs R. J.Ehrlich P. H.Holling C. S.et al.2009Diversity in current ecological thinking: implications for environmental management.Environmental Management431727doi:10.1007/S00267-008-9187-2

Morton S. R.Hoegh-Guldberg O.Lindenmayer D. B.Hariss Olson M.Hughes L.et al.2009The big ecological questions inhibiting effective environmental management in Australia.Austral Ecology3419doi:10.1111/J.1442-9993.2008.01938.X

Moss B.2008The Water Framework Directive: Total environment or political compromise?The Science of the Total Environment4003241doi:10.1016/J.SCITOTENV.2008.04.029

Ogilvie D.Egan M.Hamilton V.Petticrew M.2005Systematic reviews of health effects of social interventions: Best available evidence: how low should you go?Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health59886892doi:10.1136/JECH.2005.034199

Phillips C.Allen W.Fenemor A.Bowden B.Young R.2010Integrated catchment management research: lessons for interdisciplinary science from the Motueka Catchment, New Zealand.Marine and Freshwater Research61749763doi:10.1071/MF09099

Pielke R. A.Jr (2007). ‘The Honest Broker: Making Sense of Science in Policy and Politics.’ (Cambridge University Press: New York.)

Poff N. L.Allan J. D.Palmer M. A.Hart D. D.Richter B. D.et al.2003River flows and water wars: emerging science for environmental decision making.Frontiers in Ecology and the Environment1298306doi:10.1890/1540-9295(2003)001[0298:RFAWWE]2.0.CO;2

Popper K. R. (1969). ‘Conjectures and Refutations: The Growth of Scientific Knowledge.’ (Routledge: USA.)

Reed M. S.Dougill A. J.Baker T. R.2008Participatory indicator development: what can ecologists and local communities learn from each other?Ecological Applications1812531269doi:10.1890/07-0519.1

Regan H. M.Colyvan M.Burgman M. A.2002A taxonomy and treatment of uncertainty for ecology and conservation biology.Ecological Applications12618628doi:10.1890/1051-0761(2002)012[0618:ATATOU]2.0.CO;2

Richter B. D.Warner A. T.Meyer J. L.Lutz K.2006A collaborative and adaptive process for developing environmental flow recommendations.River Research and Applications22297318doi:10.1002/RRA.892

Roberts A. M., and Parnell D. J. (2009). Science tools to inform regional investment decisions: more than ‘toys for the boys’. 18th World IMACS/MODSIM Congress, Cairns, Australia. Available at http://mssanz.org.au/modsim09 [Accessed 22 June 2010].

Robson B. J.Mitchell B. D.2010Metastability in a river subject to multiple disturbances may constrain restoration options.Marine and Freshwater Research61778785doi:10.1071/MF09073

Rogers K. H.2006The real river management challenge: integrating scientists, stakeholders and service agents.River Research and Applications22269280

Roux D. J., Rogers K. H., Biggs H. C., Ashton P. J., and Sergeant A. (2006). Bridging the science–management divide: Moving from unidirectional knowledge transfer to knowledge interfacing and sharing. Ecology and Society 11, 4. Available at
http://www.ecologyandsociety.org/vol11/iss1/art4/ [Accessed 22 June 2010].

Roux D. J.Ashton P. J.Nel J. L.MacKay H. M.2008Improving cross-sector policy integration and cooperation in support of freshwater conservation.Conservation Biology2213821387doi:10.1111/J.1523-1739.2008.01080.X

Ruhl J. B.Salzman J.2006In defense of regulatory peer review.Washington University Law Review84162

Schusler T. M.Decker D. J.Pfeffer M. J.2003Social learning for collaborative natural resource management.Society & Natural Resources16309326
doi:10.1080/08941920390178874

Slavin R.1995Best evidence synthesis: an intelligent alternative to meta-analysis.Journal of Clinical Epidemiology48918doi:10.1016/0895-4356(94)00097-A

Smallwood K. S.Beyea J.Morrison M. L.1999Using the best scientific data for endangered species conservation.Environmental Management24421435doi:10.1007/S002679900244

Sommerwerk N.Bloesch J.Paunović M.Baumgartner C.Venohr M.et al.2010Managing the world’s most international river: the Danube River Basin.Marine and Freshwater Research61736748doi:10.1071/MF09229

Sutherland W. J.Armstrong-Brown S.Armsworth P. R.Brereton T.Brickland J.et al.2006The identification of 100 ecological questions of high policy relevance in the UK.Journal of Applied Ecology43617627doi:10.1111/J.1365-2664.2006.01188.X

Tomlinson M.Davis R.2010Integrating aquatic science and policy for improved water management in Australia.Marine and Freshwater Research61808813doi:10.1071/MF09224

Tress B.Tress G.Fry G.2005Researchers’ experiences, positive, negative, in integrative landscape projects.Environmental Management36792807doi:10.1007/S00267-005-0038-0

van Wyk E.Breen C. M.Roux D. J.Rogers K. H.Sherwill T.et al.2008The Ecological Reserve: towards a common understanding for river management in South Africa.Water S.A.32403409

Waddock S. A.1998Educating holistic professionals in a world of wicked problems.Applied Developmental Science240
doi:10.1207/S1532480XADS0201_3

Watts R. J., Allan C., Bowmer K., Page K., Ryder D. S., et al. (2009). Pulsed flows: a review of environmental costs and benefits and best practice. Waterlines report no. 24, National Water Commission, Canberra. Available at http://www.nwc.gov.au/www/html/2376-pulsed-flows---no-16.asp?intSiteID=1 [Accessed 22 June 2010].

Watts R. J.Ryder D. S.Allan C.Commens S.2010Using river-scale experiments to inform variable releases from large dams: a case study of emergent adaptive management.Marine and Freshwater Research61786797doi:10.1071/MF09190

Webb J. A.Stewardson M. J.Chee Y. E.Schreiber E. S. G.Sharpe A. K.et al.2010Negotiating the turbulent boundary: the challenges of building a science–management collaboration for landscape-scale monitoring of environmental flows.Marine and Freshwater Research61798807doi:10.1071/MF09059



Export Citation Cited By (26)